Results of Curative Treatment for Cancer of the Tonsil / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: To report the results of curative treatment for patients with tonsil cancer by retrospective analysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From Jan. 1995 till Dec. 2000, 27 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsil received curative treatment at Samsung Medical Center. Therapeutic decision was made through multidisciplinary conference, and curative radiation therapy was favored when, (1) the patient's condition was not fit for general anesthesia and surgery, (2) the patient refused surgery, (3) complete resection was presumed impossible, or (4) too severe disability was expected after surgery. Surgery was the main local modality in 17 patients (S+/-RT group), and radiation therapy in 10 (RT+/-CT group). The median follow-up period was 41 months. RESULTS: AJCC stages were I/II in four, III in two, and Iv in 21 patients. The 5-year disease-free survival rate was 73.3% in all patients, 70.6% in the S+/-RT group, and 77.8% in the RT+/-CT group. Treatment failure occurred in seven patients, all with stage III/IV, and all the failures occurred within 24 months of the start of treatment. Five patients among the S CT group developed treatment failures; 2 local, 2 regional, and 1 distant (crude rate=29.4%). Two patients among the RT+/-CT group developed failures; 1 synchronous local and regional, and 1 distant (crude rate=20.0%). The 5-year overall survival rate was 77.0% in all patients, 80.9% in the S+/-RT group, and 70.0% in the RT+/-CT group. CONCLUSION: We could achieve favorable results that were comparable to previously reported data with respect to both the rates of local control and of survival by applying S+/-RT and RT+/-CT. RT+/-CT is judged to be an alternative option that can avoid the functional disability after surgical resection.

Fast Spin-Echo T2-Weighted MR Imaging of Tongue Cancer: the Value of Fat-suppression

PURPOSE: To compare the diagnostic efficacy of fast spin-echo (FSE) T2-weighted MR imaging with and without fat suppression. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twelve patients (7 men and 5 women; mean age, 48 years) with pathologically proven cancer of the tongue were included in this study. In all of these, FSE T2-weighted MR images with and without fat suppression were obtained in the same imaging planes before surgery or biopsy. Two radiologists visually compared the images thus obtained in terms of detection, extent, and conspicuity of the tumor, and the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of each tumor was also calculated. RESULTS: In all patients, both imaging modalities were equal in terms of tumor detection. In 4 of 12(33%), the extent of the tumor was greater with fat suppression, while in eight (67%), it was almost the same both with and without. In ten patients (83%), the tumor was more conspicuous with fat suppression, and percentage CNRs were significantly higher with fat suppression than without (180 +/-70% and 113 +/-61%, respectively; p = 0.02). CONCLUSION: For the evaluation of patients with tongue cancer, fat-suppressed FSE T2-weighted MR imaging is superior to its conventional equivalent.

Fast Spin-Echo T2-Weighted MR Imaging of Tongue Cancer: the Value of Fat-suppression

PURPOSE: To compare the diagnostic efficacy of fast spin-echo (FSE) T2-weighted MR imaging with and without fat suppression. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twelve patients (7 men and 5 women; mean age, 48 years) with pathologically proven cancer of the tongue were included in this study. In all of these, FSE T2-weighted MR images with and without fat suppression were obtained in the same imaging planes before surgery or biopsy. Two radiologists visually compared the images thus obtained in terms of detection, extent, and conspicuity of the tumor, and the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) of each tumor was also calculated. RESULTS: In all patients, both imaging modalities were equal in terms of tumor detection. In 4 of 12(33%), the extent of the tumor was greater with fat suppression, while in eight (67%), it was almost the same both with and without. In ten patients (83%), the tumor was more conspicuous with fat suppression, and percentage CNRs were significantly higher with fat suppression than without (180 +/-70% and 113 +/-61%, respectively; p = 0.02). CONCLUSION: For the evaluation of patients with tongue cancer, fat-suppressed FSE T2-weighted MR imaging is superior to its conventional equivalent.

Vocal Cord Paralysis Due to Extralaryngeal Causes: Evaluation with CT1

PURPOSE: To evaluate the use of CT in patients with vocal cord paralysis due to extralaryngeal cause s ,andto use CT for the assessment of extralaryngeal diseases causing vocal cord paralysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Weprospectively studied the results of CT in 41 patients with vocal cord paralysis in whom laryngoscopy revealed nolaryngeal cause and physical examination demonstrated no definite extralaryngeal cause. The extralaryngeal causeof vocal cord palsy was determined after comprehensive clinical diagnosis. Enhanced CT scans were acquired fromthe skull base and continued to the level of the aorticopulmonary window. We used CT to assess the detection ratefor extralaryngeal causes and to extimate the extent of extralaryngeal disease and the distribution of lesions. RESULTS: CT revealed that in 20 of 41 patients(49%) the extralarygeal causes of vocal paralysis were as follows :thyroid cancer(n=10), nodal disease(n=6), esophageal cancer(n=2), neurogenic tumor(n=1), aortic aneurysm(n=1).Lesions were located on the left side in 13 patients(65%), and in the tracheoesophageal groove in 15(75%). CONCLUSION: In patients with vocal cord paralysis in whom no definite lesion is seen on physical examination, CT could be a useful primary imaging method for the assessment of extralaryngeal causes.