In vitro susceptibility of Trypanosoma cruzi strains from Santander, Colombia, to hexadecylphosphocholine (miltefosine), nifurtimox and benznidazole

Introduction. The current chemotherapy for Chagas disease is unsatisfactory with only two drugs available for treatment. Research to discover new drugs for Chagas disease is urgent. Hexadecyl-phosphocholine (HPC, miltefosine) has been demonstrated to have in vitro activity against Trypanosoma cruzi parasites, but its activity on different Colombian T. cruzi strains is not known. Objective. To evaluate the in vitro susceptibility of T. cruzi strains isolated from humans and vectors in Santander, Colombia, to miltefosine, nifurtimox and benznidazole. Materials and methods. Eight T. cruzi Colombian strains and three reference strains (Esmeraldo, SilvioX10 and Y) were studied. Drug activities against extracellular epimastigotes and intracellular amastigotes were determined by microscopic counting. The results were expressed as the concentrations that inhibited 50% and 90% growth (IC50 and IC90). Results. For miltefosine a similar range of drug activity was observed against all the Colombian strains, all parasites being more susceptible to miltefosine than to the reference drugs. The intracellular amastigotes were more susceptible to miltefosine (IC50 0.08 to 0.63 ìM and IC90 0.21 to 2.21 ìM) than extracellular forms (IC50 <0.92 to 2.29 ìM and IC90 1.38 to 4.76 ìM). For reference drugs, parasites were more susceptible to nifurtimox than to benznidazole and some differences in activity of benznidazole between T. cruzi strains was observed. Conclusions. The results showed the significant in vitro activity of miltefosine against T. cruzi stages, and the expected results for the reference drugs. Further in vivo studies with miltefosine are planned.

Introducción. Los tratamientos actuales para la enfermedad de Chagas son insatisfactorios y sólo existen dos medicamentos disponibles. La búsqueda de alternativas terapéuticas es prioritaria. La hexadecilfosfocolina (miltefosina) ha mostrado actividad in vitro contra Trypanosoma cruzi. Sin embargo, su actividad en aislamientos de T. cruzi obtenidos en Colombia aún no ha sido reportada. Objetivo. Evaluar la susceptibilidad in vitro a miltefosina, nifurtimox y benznidazole de cepas de T. cruzi aisladas de humanos y vectores en Santander, Colombia. Materiales y métodos. Se evaluó la susceptibilidad de los tres medicamentos en ocho cepas colombianas de T. cruzi y tres cepas de referencia: Esmeraldo, Silvio X10 y Y. La actividad de los compuestos fue determinada en epimastigotes extracelulares y amastigotes intracelulares, por conteo microscópico. Los resultados se expresaron en concentraciones inhibitorias 50 y 90 (CI50 y CI90). Resultados. Para la miltefosina, se observaron rangos similares en la actividad del medicamento entre las cepas colombianas; todos los parásitos fueron más susceptibles a la miltefosina que a los medicamentos de referencia. Los amastigotes intracelulares fueron más sensibles a la miltefosina (CI50, 0,08 a 0,63 µM y CI90, 0,21 a 2,21 µM) que las formas extracelulares (CI50, <0,92 a 2,29 µM y CI90, 1,38 a 4,76 µM). En los medicamentos de referencia, los parásitos fueron más susceptibles al nifurtimox que al benznidazole. Se observaron algunas diferencias en la actividad del benznidazole en las cepas estudiadas de T. cruzi. Conclusiones. Los resultados obtenidos de la actividad in vitro de miltefosina y de los medicamentos de referencia contra aislamientos de T. cruzi son satisfactorios y serán considerados en estudios posteriores in vivo.

Current scenario of drug development for leishmaniasis.

Although three new drugs or drug formulations, liposomal amphotericin B (AmBisome), miltefosine and paromomycin should be available for the treatment of visceral leishmaniasis (VL) within the next year, they all suffer from limitations of either cost, specific toxicities or parenteral administration. As part of research to identify better treatments for VL and cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL), alternative and potentially cheaper formulations of amphotericin B, alklyphosphocholines other than miltefosine and improved formulations of paromomycin for CL have been identified. Other drugs or compounds that have demonstrated activity in experimental rodent models of infection include licochalcone derivatives, quinoline derivatives, bisphosphonates and a maesabalide; further chemistry based upon these leads is warranted. The process for discovery and development of new antileishmanials would also benefit from improved models, for example, transfected parasites, and non invasive methods of measuring parasite load in rodent models of infection.