The knowledge and skills gap of medical practitioners delivering district hospital services in the Western Cape; South Africa

Introduction District (community) hospitals play an important role in the delivery of health services at community level; especially in rural areas. These hospitals provide comprehensive level-one health services to their communities; and serve as a resource for the whole health district. Most district hospitals are situated in rural areas; with medical services in these hospitals being rendered by generalist medical practitioners. The education and training of generalist practitioners for rural practice needs specific attention. Firstly; the unique nature of rural practice makes it necessary for doctors to undergo relevant and focused instruction. Rural family practice requires that doctors have the knowledge and skills to practise in settings where high technology and specialist resources are not available; while at the same time requiring that they be able to perform a wide range of advanced functions and procedures. Secondly; it is argued that appropriate education and training for rural practice can positively influence the recruitment and retention of medical practitioners in rural areas.5 The teaching of the knowledge and skills required for rural practice should take place in an appropriate setting that promotes interest in rural practice and familiarises the student with its particular challenges. There is a paucity of data in South Africa on medical practitioners staffing district hospitals; especially in terms of their knowledge and skills levels. Such information is critical if rural hospitals are to deliver equitable and quality health services; and also for guiding appropriate undergraduate; postgraduate and continuing professional education for rural practice. With this as background; health service managers in the Western Cape requested a skills audit of medical officers in district hospitals to identify a possible gap in competencies that may impact on service delivery. The aim of this study was thus to identify the knowledge and skills of medical practitioners delivering these services in the Western Cape and to compare them with service needs in order to make recommendations for education and training. This article reports on the results of the knowledge and skills gap analysis; while the results of the district hospital performance data and in-depth interviews are reported elsewhere. Method The competencies of medical practitioners working in 27 district hospitals were explored by using a self-administered questionnaire containing a competency rating of proxy markers. The data were analysed using the SAS statistical package. Variables were examined for statistically significant differences. Results A response rate of 75

The Knowledge and Skills Gap of Medical Practitioners Delivering District Hospital Services in the Western Cape; South Africa

Introduction: District (community) hospitals play an important role in the delivery of health services at community level; especially in rural areas. These hospitals provide comprehensive level-one health services to their communities; and serve as a resource for the whole health district. Most district hospitals are situated in rural areas; with medical services in these hospitals being rendered by generalist medical practitioners. The education and training of generalist practitioners for rural practice needs specific attention. Firstly; the unique nature of rural practice makes it necessary for doctors to undergo relevant and focused instruction. Rural family practice requires that doctors have the knowledge and skills to practise in settings where high technology and specialist resources are not available; while at the same time requiring that they be able to perform a wide range of advanced functions and procedures. Secondly; it is argued that appropriate education and training for rural practice can positively influence the recruitment and retention of medical practitioners in rural areas.5 The teaching of the knowledge and skills required for rural practice should take place in an appropriate setting that promotes interest in rural practice and familiarises the student with its particular challenges. There is a paucity of data in South Africa on medical practitioners staffing district hospitals; especially in terms of their knowledge and skills levels. Such information is critical if rural hospitals are to deliver equitable and quality health services; and also for guiding appropriate undergraduate; postgraduate and continuing professional education for rural practice. With this as background; health service managers in the Western Cape requested a skills audit of medical officers in district hospitals to identify a possible gap in competencies that may impact on service delivery. The aim of this study was thus to identify the knowledge and skills of medical practitioners delivering these services in the Western Cape and to compare them with service needs in order to make recommendations for education and training. This article reports on the results of the knowledge and skills gap analysis; while the results of the district hospital performance data and in-depth interviews are reported elsewhere.Method: The competencies of medical practitioners working in 27 district hospitals were explored by using a self-administered questionnaire containing a competency rating of proxy markers. The data were analysed using the SAS statistical package. Variables were examined for statistically significant differences.Results: A response rate of 75 (110/147) was achieved. Part-time (older) medical officers regarded themselves as more experienced and more competent than full-time (younger) employees in most areas; except when managing problems relating to HIV/AIDS. Termination of pregnancy was the procedure most frequently not performed despite practitioners being competent to do so. A substantial need for supervision was identified for managing less common emergency conditions; as well as for some outpatient problems; including preventative; promotive and rehabilitation activities.Conclusions: The knowledge and skills gaps varied considerably according to the individuals' education; training and experience; as well as their circumstances and working conditions. The superior competencies of the older practitioners reinforce the importance of the recruitment and retention of more experienced practitioners. The uneven skill and knowledge base in aspects of HIV/AIDS management should be addressed urgently by initiatives such as the internet-based course on HIV/AIDS developed by the Family Medicine Education Consortium (FaMEC). Departments of Family Medicine should urgently re-orientate their curricula to meet the training needs for level-one hospital practice

The Maintenance of Competence of Rural District Hospital Practitioners

Introduction: It is important for rural district hospital practitioners to maintain their competence to provide equitable health service for rural communities. The scope of their practice dictates that they must stay up-to-date with a large variety of knowledge and skills despite limited educational opportunities. Rural practitioners use continuing professional development (CPD) activities that are most accessible to them; but it is not known whether these activities are educationally sound and effective.Aim: We designed a study to investigate the content and methods used for the maintenance of competence by rural district hospital practitioners in the Western Cape Province; South Africa.Methods: Expert opinion was sought to evaluate the topics requiring up-dating and the validity of the learning methods to maintain competence in practice. This was achieved by employing the Delphi technique to reach consensus on content and methodology. Categorical data analysis and a principal factor analysis were performed. The qualitative data were developed into themes and presented as a conceptual framework.Results: Consensus was reached on the principal content areas requiring updating. Methods that were found most useful were in-service learning under supervision; structured courses; small group discussions and practical workshops. Rotations in tertiary hospitals; lectures by specialists; journal reading and Internet learning were less supported.Conclusion: This study provides a practical model for continuing instruction plus self-directed learning in context. Three content domains were established namely; commonly encountered areas of practice; identified gaps and needs specific to the practitioner and the setting. The implementation of external updating programmes must be tailored to suit the practitioners while the self-directed aspects should include reflective practice. Priority areas are identified and classified as well as educational methods which can contribute towards the maintenance of competence of rural practitioners