ABSTRACT
El objetivo de este estudio fue evaluar una intervención en educación nutricional y actividad física para prevenir obesidad en escolares chilenos, mediante seguimiento longitudinal de tres años. La muestra incluyó 597 niños de 4 a 7 años asistentes a 7 escuelas públicas de una comuna de bajo nivel socioeconómico de Santiago. Los principales aspectos de la intervención fueron: capacitación de profesores para que apliquen un programa de educación nutricional, aumento de las clases de educación física de 3 a 4 sesiones semanales y mejoría de su calidad. Se midió: Peso (P), Talla (T), circunferencia de cintura (CC) y test de caminata de 6 minutos (TM6). Se calculó IMC, Z IMC, % de escolares normales (N), sobrepeso (SP) y obesos (OB), CC > percentil 90 (NHANES III) y condición física (T6M/talla). Se evaluaron los cambios anuales de Z IMC, CC, TM6 y TM6/talla usando el test de repeticiones de ANOVA y el test de proporciones. Se evaluaron cambios en conocimientos sobre alimentación saludable en 2 de los 3 años. Los resultados mostraron que el porcentaje de obesidad (17%) no cambió los primeros dos años, sin embargo aumentó el tercer año a un 19,3%; Z IMC aumentó de 0,3 a 0,38 (p=0,052) en los N, sin cambio en SP y disminuyendo significativamente en los OB (2,73 a 2,41 p<0,0001). % CC >percentil 90 disminuyó en los SP y OB. El incremento en el TM6 fue mayor en los N. La condición física mejoró en todos los niños, pero fue significativo sólo en los N (p=0,0002). Hubo un aumento significativo en los conocimientos alimentarios. Se concluye que a pesar de una disminución en el Z IMC de los OB y una mejoría en la condición física de los N y de los conocimientos en todos los escolares, la obesidad aumentó al tercer año. Este estudio muestra que a nivel escolar es necesario implementar intervenciones más intensas y con otro tipo de metodologías, para impedir que la obesidad infantil continúe aumentando.
Evaluation of an obesity prevention intervention which includednutrition education and physical activity applied in public schools of Santiago, Chile . The main objective of this study was to assess the effectiveness of an obesity prevention intervention which included nutrition education and physical activity applied to low income Chilean children in a longitudinal three-year follow-up study. Participants included all 4-7 year old children from 7 public schools located in a low socioeconomic district of Santiago. The main aspects of the intervention were: training of teachers so they could apply an educational program on healthy eating, increase in physical education classes from 3 to 4 per week, and improvement of their quality. Weight, height, waist circumference (WC) and the 6-minute walk distance (6MWD) were assessed yearly in 597 children. We calculated BMI, BMI Z, % normal (N), overweight (OW) and obesity (OB), WC > 90th percentile (NHANES III) and fitness (6MWD/ height). Annual changes in BMI Z, WC, 6MWD and fitness were assessed, using repeated measures ANOVA and the test of proportions. Knowledge in healthy eating was assessed during 2 of the 3 years. Results showed that % OB remained unchanged for 2 years (17%) but increased to 19.3 % at follow-up. BMI Z increased from 0.3 to 0.38 (p= 0.052) in the N, remained unchanged in the OW, while decreasing significantly in the OB (2.73 to 2.41 p< 0.0001). % WC > 90 th percentile decreased in the OW and OB; 6 MWD was higher in the OW, but the increase in distance overtime was greater among the N. Overall fitness improved, however it was only significant among the N (p= 0.0002). There was a significant increase in food knowledge. We conclude that in spite of a decrease in BMI Z of the OB, an improvement in fitness in the N and food knowledge in all the children, obesity increased at follow- up. This study shows that in school-based obesity programs it is necessary to apply more intense interventions with another type of methodology; otherwise this condition will continue to rise.
Subject(s)
Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Male , Health Promotion/methods , Obesity/prevention & control , Physical Education and Training , School Health Services , Body Mass Index , Chile , Longitudinal Studies , Program Evaluation , Socioeconomic FactorsABSTRACT
Background: In 2007, a preventive strategy for childhood obesity, that included food education and an increase in physical activity, was implemented in seven public schools located in Santiago. In four of these schools, a counseling program about healthy lifestyles for teachers was also carried out. Aim: To test if counseling had an effect in the intervention for children. Material and Methods: Anthropometric measures were assessed in children at baseline and after two years of intervention. Teachers were also evaluated with anthropometry and a blood sample was obtained to measure blood glucose and serum lipids. Results: Four hundred twelve children from schools whose teachers had counseling and 237 children from schools whose teachers did not have it were evaluated. Twenty-eight teachers with and 19 with no counseling were assessed. In children, the overall prevalence of obesity decreased from 20.2 to 18.3 percent (p = 0.03). This reduction was only significant among females. BMIZ score decreased significantly in children of both genders. No effect of counseling was observed on weight reduction. Among teachers that received counseling, the prevalence of obesity decreased from 25 to 22.4 percent, with significant improvements in blood glucose and HDL cholesterol. Conclusions: Counseling directed at teachers did not improve the effect of a program to reduce obesity among schoolchildren.