Ideas for Safer Acupuncture Practice (2) / 全日本鍼灸学会雑誌

Continued from the previous year's theme of our workshop, we collected various information and ideas for safer acupuncture practice. Subjects and presentations of the present workshop were as follows:<BR>1. Literature review of papers on adverse events published between 2003and 2006<BR> 1) Papers in domestic journals (by Ishizaki and Egawa)<BR> 2) Papers in foreign journals (by Yamashita and Umeda)<BR>2. Debate on wearing sterilized fingerstall or glove<BR> 1) Present status of the use of fingerstall in acupuncture practice (by Katai and Minowa)<BR> 2) Practical side of clinical education of acupuncture using fingerstall (by Hatakeyama and Furuya)<BR> 3) Problem of using individual fingerstalls in acupuncture practice (by Handa and Miyamoto)<BR>We will continue to provide information and discuss solutions in order to reach a common understanding and specific methods for safer acupuncture practice.

Influence on Individual Finger Stalls in Pain during Acupuncture Operation / 全日本鍼灸学会雑誌

[Objective] In this study, the pain of receiving acupuncture was evaluated with or without individual finger stalls.<BR>[Design] In a randomized, subject- and operating person-blind, controlled study.<BR>[Methods] Sixteen acupuncturists and same number of normal volunteers participated in this study. Two needles were inserted into each side of the lumbar muscles. The trials were carried out twice using finger stalls and with bare fingers. These trials were performed in random order. Right after the insertion of needles and at the beginning of electrical stimulation, the subjects were asked to answer a questionnaire about the severity and quality of pain on receiving acupuncture. Durations of procedures were measured. We asked the acupuncturists whether they felt any difficulty in performing acupuncture using finger stalls.<BR>[Result] The majority of acupuncturists reported that using the finger stalls during treatment was inconvenient. Although the severity of pain of acupuncture did not significantly differ between that with and that without finger stalls, the average value was slightly higher with finger stalls. The qualities of pain on receiving acupuncture did not significantly differ between the two methods, however, the numbers of selected words differed on some items. The subjects could not recognize the use of individual finger stalls. The use of finger stalls did not influence the duration of the procedure.<BR>[Conclusion] In this study, the qualities of pain on receiving acupuncture did not significantly differ between that with and that without finger stalls. The subjects could not recognize the use of individual finger stalls.