Awareness and confidence of family physicians in recognition and treatment of psychiatric disorders

OBJECTIVES: This paper aims to evaluate the competence and confidence of the primary care practitioner in the recognition, diagnosis and treatment of mental disorders.METHODOLOGY: A validated 13 point questionnaire which incorporated items from the DSM IV was given to the participants of the annual convention of the Philippine Academy of Family Physician held in Davao City Sept 8-10, 2000.RESULTS: Four hundred eighty five family physicians returned the self administered questionnaire. Fifty one percent (248/ 485) claimed they would immediately refer patients to the psychiatrist while 28% (137/ 485) would initiate treatment on their own. Fourteen percent (68/ 485) and 10.9% (53/ 485) of the respondents indicated that they were familiar with the DSM IV criteria for schizophrenia and depression respectively; however only 11.3 % (55/485)were confident in using the criteria for diagnosis. Fortytwo percent (204/485) described schizophrenic patients as being irritable and aggressive, 30% (146/485) believed that hallucinations were the hallmark symptom, while 18% (88/485) considered bizarre behavior as the most significant indicator of schizophrenia. For depression the subjective feeling of sadness and worthlessness was most indicative of depression for the respondents (63% or 305), while 21% or 102 considered low self esteem or unstable self image as one of the criteria for depression and 16% or 78 thought of diminished interest or pleasure in all activities as the more important symptom to look for when diagnosing depression. Tricyclic antidepressants were still the preferred drug by most family physicians in treating depression (72% or 340) while 62% (301/ 485) prescribed benzodiazepines and 51% (248/ 485) also used the newer selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. Patients with schizophrenia would be given typical psychotropic drugs like chlorpromazine or haloperidol more commonly (88% or 427), while 46% (224/ 485) had begun to prescribe atypical antipsychotic medications.CONCLUSION:The family physician seems to be hesitant or unsure with their diagnosing or treating psychiatric patients though willing to administer psychotropic medications.

Awareness and confidence of family physicians in recognition and treatment of psychiatric illness

The family practitioner plays an important role in the detection and treatment of mental disorders. It is said that over half of all persons affected with mental illness are initially seen and treated by the non-psychiatrist in the outpatient setting rather than in the specialty mental health clinic. Objective: This paper aims to evaluate perceived level of confidence and competence of the primary care practitioner in the recognition, diagnosis, and management of mental disorders. Methods: A survey of family physicians and general practitioners using a thirteen (13)-point questionnaire during an annual convention of the Philippine Academy of Family Physicians (PAFP) was conducted. The questionnaire included items that attempted to quantify: exposure to psychiatry during residency and current medical practice; proportion of mental illness cases among total patient load; signs and symptoms that would be associated with mental illness; familiarity with standardized criteria for diagnosing mental illness i.e. schizophrenia and depression; familiarity with therapeutic medications; and perceived level of confidence in treating psychiatric cases. Results and Conclusion: The study implies that the family physician, although aware of the general signs and symptoms indicative of mental illness, is still hesitant in formulating a definitive diagnosis. Possible reasons for this attitude may be inadequate training in psychiatry as well as unfamiliarity and perceived difficulty with the DSM-IV.