ABSTRACT
Objective:To clarify the long-term trend of nursing human resource allocation in China, and provide basis for relevant departments to optimize nursing human resource allocation.Methods:Data were extracted from China′s health statistical yearbook from 1990 to 2019. Six indicators of the number of registered nurses, the number of registered nurses per 1 000 population, the ratio of registered nurses to health technicians, doctor-nurse ratio, hospital bed-nurse ratio and nurse-patient ratio were used to make a descriptive statistical analysis on the changing trend of nursing human resources in China.Results:From 1990 to 2019, the number of registered nurses increased from 0.970 million to 4.445 million in China, with an average annual growth rate of 5.37%, the average annual growth rate was 2.23% from 1990 to 2005, 9.96% from 2006 to 2013, and 8.21% from 2014 to 2019. The number of registered nurses per 1 000 population increased from 0.85 to 3.18, with a 4.65% annual growth rate, the doctor-nurse ratio increased from 1∶0.55 to 1∶1.15, with a 2.58% annual growth rate, the hospital bed-nurse ratio increased from 1∶0.33 to 1∶0.50, and the average annual growth rate was 1.44%. The proportion of registered nurses to health technicians increased from 24.87% in 1990 to 43.84% in 2019, however, the number of registered nurses in hospitals accounted for about 73.00% of registered nurses in health institutions.Conclusions:From 1990 to 2019, the overall allocation efficiency of nursing human resources in China has been significantly optimized, and indicators such as doctor-nurse ratio and hospital bed-nurse ratio have improved, but the growth rate is slowing down. The relevant departments need to take necessary measures to further increase the absolute and relative number of nurses to cope with the increasing service demand.
ABSTRACT
Objective@#To test the applicability of the relative value used to measure Chinese nurses′ workload, and measure part of single workload of nursing procedures.@*Methods@#Time, physical effort, mental effort and medical risk were used as the four dimensions to evaluate nurses′ workload. Based on these dimensions, a set of questionnaires covering 117 common nursing procedures were designed and 58 nurses form 58 hospitals were surveyed. Establishing three different regulation modals, of which the applicability and stability were evaluated through the good of fit.@*Results@#Median of the relative value of different dimensions was used to indicate the average level of the various nursing procedures′ workload. The results showed that the median of relative value between 100 to 199 accounted for the largest share, up to 88.89% of 104 items. The median of relative value between 200 to 299 accounted for 7.69%(9 items). The median of relative value between 0 to 99(3 items)and more than 300(1 item)accounted for a small proportion. The lowest point of workload was blood pressure measuring, having a relative value of 90(70, 100) while the PICC catheterization accounted for the highest point of workload, being 370(200, 500) Three kinds of modals were valid(Model Ⅰ, F=10 626.16, P<0.001; Model Ⅱ, F=17 108.22, P<0.001; Model Ⅲ: F=6 694.16, P<0.001), while the good of fit of these regulation modals was between 0.8 to 0.9. Time, physical effort, mental effort and iatrogenic risk were the key variables of nurses′ workload.@*Conclusions@#The applicability of the relative value to measure nurses′ workload is fairly satisfactory, and the relative value points based on multi-dimension will enjoy a promising future.
ABSTRACT
Objective To test the applicability of the relative value used to measure Chinese nurses′workload, and measure part of single workload of nursing procedures. Methods Time, physical effort, mental effort and medical risk were used as the four dimensions to evaluate nurses′ workload. Based on these dimensions, a set of questionnaires covering 117 common nursing procedures were designed and 58 nurses form 58 hospitals were surveyed. Establishing three different regulation modals, of which the applicability and stability were evaluated through the good of fit.Results Median of the relative value of different dimensions was used to indicate the average level of the various nursing procedures′workload. The results showed that the median of relative value between 100 to 199 accounted for the largest share, up to 88.89% of 104 items. The median of relative value between 200 to 299 accounted for 7.69% (9 items). The median of relative value between 0 to 99(3 items) and more than 300 (1 item) accounted for a small proportion. The lowest point of workload was blood pressure measuring, having a relative value of 90(70, 100) while the PICC catheterization accounted for the highest point of workload, being 370 ( 200, 500 ) Three kinds of modals were valid(Model Ⅰ,F=10 626.16, P<0.001; Model Ⅱ,F=17 108.22, P<0.001; Model Ⅲ:F=6 694.16, P<0.001), while the good of fit of these regulation modals was between 0.8 to 0.9. Time, physical effort, mental effort and iatrogenic risk were the key variables of nurses′workload. Conclusions The applicability of the relative value to measure nurses′ workload is fairly satisfactory, and the relative value points based on multi-dimension will enjoy a promising future.
ABSTRACT
Clinical training base is playing an important role in the quality guarantee of postgradu-ates in clinical medicine. The clinical allocation, teaching resources and teaching staff are important factors affecting the quality of teaching. Clinical training bases should define the teaching objectives and guarantee the teaching orientation, organization and incentive system. Meanwhile, the clinical training bases should do well in teaching evaluation and continuous improvement, so that to promote the implementation of teaching objectives and ensure the quality of teaching. Finally, a training mechanism centering on the growth and development of postgraduates majoring in clinical medicine will be constructed, improving the training effect and cultivating excellent clinicians.
ABSTRACT
Objectives: China has observed an increasing prevalence of cardiovascular diseases among its population, which is putting heavy economic burden both on individuals and the whole society.Conducting a multi-angle study of cardiovascular patients with economic burden can help adjust the health care policy to reduce the economic burden of patients.Methods: Using the baseline data (2011) and follow-up data (2013) of the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Survey, this study selected cardiovascular patients aged 45 and above to calculate their direct medical cost, direct non-medical cost as well as self-paid cost before and after reimbursement.The total cost and self-paid cost are both calculated, and gender difference and rural-urban difference are also analyzed.Results: The prevalence of cardiovascular disease among the population age 45 and above was 13.9% in 2013 and 12.1% in 2011, while the prevalence in women was higher than in men and urban areas higher than rural areas.The average annual total costs for individual patient before reimbursement in 2013 was lower than that in 2011, but contrary to the trend of self-pay costs.Urban patients had higher amount of direct medical cost, lower co-payment rate and lower non-medical cost such as transportation and accommodation than their rural counterpart.Both urban and rural patients self-paid more on outpatient services than inpatient services.Conclusion: Based on these analyses, this paper suggests that Chinese policy makers should look deeper into patient behaviors as well as their economic burden before revising the current health policy.More practices regarding to the unbalanced distribution of health resources between urban and rural areas are needed, in order to ensure patients living in remote areas could get access to appropriate treatment without paying heavy non-medical cost.
ABSTRACT
Objective: To assess and analyze the operation efficiency of 8 commission general public hospitals managed directly by National Health and Family Planning Commission and 8 municipal general hospitals managed directly by Beijing Municipal Administration of Hospitals in Beijing and to provide suggestions on improving service capacity and designing relevant health policy.Methods: Input and output data of 8 commission hospitals and 8 municipal hospitals were obtained from Beijing Direct-Reported Health Statistics data from 2011 to 2014.Data envelopment analysis was used as the hospital operation efficiency measurement tool.The CCR and BCC models were built to calculate technical efficiency (TE), pure technical efficiency (PTE), scale efficiency (SE) and the status of scale efficiency of 16 hospitals in 2011 and 2014;the Malmquist index model was built to analyze the total factor productivity change (TFPC), technological change (TC), technical efficiency change, pure technical efficiency change and scale efficiency change of the 16 hospitals from 2011 to 2014.Results: In 2011, the TE, PTE and SE of the commission hospitals were higher than those of the municipal hospitals, and the TEs of the commission hospitals and the municipal hospitals were 0.918 and 0.873 respectively.In 2014, the TE, PTE and SE of commission hospitals were lower than those of the municipal hospitals, and the TE of the commission hospitals and the municipal hospitals were 0.906 and 0.951, respectively, which was contrary to the results in 2011.According to the Malmquist index model, the average of TFPC of the municipal hospitals was larger than that of the commission hospitals, the former increased 5.9% and the latter increased 2.8% per year;the average of TC was greater than the one in both the municipal hospitals and the commission hospitals, with a growth of 3.2% and 2.9% per year, respectively;the average growth of PTE in the commission hospitals was lower than that of the municipal hospitals, and the average descent of SE in the commission hospitals was larger than that in the municipal hospitals.Conclusion: There are significant differences in the operation efficiency between different management systems and the main factors associated with operation efficiency are the technological and management level.Given scale efficiency status and macroeconomic medical policies, the commission hospitals and the municipal hospitals require further adjusting the distribution of medical resources, and it is of great significance for all the commission hospitals and the municipal hospitals to improve the management level and resource integration capability.
ABSTRACT
Objective To identify the critical indicators of nursing practice environment in China, as a reference for related studies. Methods Descriptive systematic review was used to retrieve literature of nursing practice environment, collect all potential indicators and design questionnaires based on those indicators. In the end, 39 potential indicators were identified, for a questionnaire survey of nurses from cooperating medical institutions in 30 provinces in China, with the data subject to statistical analysis in multiple linear regression model. Results Questionnaire items of higher mean score were usually found with a smaller 95% confidence interval, while coefficient of variation tended to be lower. Seventeen indicators were recommended as key indicators for nursing practice environment in China, including proper working hours and intensity, opportunities for nurses to participate in hospital management, good working relationship with doctors within a department,nursing managers′support for nurses′right decisions. The remaining components turned out to be insignificant in the analysis. Conclusions The influencing factors for the nursing practice environment in China are different from other countries. In this consideration, nursing managers should further explore and focus on such special indicators, and proactively improve the quality of nursing practice environment for better nursing service.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To study the association of air pollution with health service demand of the elderly and middle-age patients with cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases,and to provide a scientific ba-sis for development of environmental protection policy and health service policy of the Chinese govern-ment.Methods:This study included survey data on self-evaluated health,outpatient service demand and inpatient service demand of the patients with hypertension,heart disease and stroke in 62 cities of 1 7 provinces from China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study(CHARLS)in 201 1 and 201 3,and com-bined it with the data on the annual concentrations of inhalable particulate matter(PM1 0 ),sulfur dioxide (SO2 )and nitrogen dioxide(NO2 )of those provinces and cities.Conditional Logistic regression was car-ried out to assess the possible effects of air pollutants on self-evaluated health and health service utiliza-tion.Results:The results showed that turning points existed in the effects of concentrations of NO2 and SO2 on the health service demand of the patients with hypertension,heart disease and stroke.The inpa-tient service demand of the hypertension patients increased with NO2 concentration when it was lower than 35.1 μg/m3 and decreased with NO2 concentration for higher value.Self-evaluated health of the patients with heart disease and stroke decreased with SO2 concentration when it was lower than 63.8 μg/m3 and increased with SO2 concentration for higher value.In addition,no evidence was found for the association between PM1 0 and health service demand.Conclusion:Air pollution may have effects on health service demand of the patients with hypertension,cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases,and different air pollutants at high or low concentration may have different health effects.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To study direct medical cost of hypertensive patients without complicated disea-ses,to analyze substitution impacts of outpatient expenditure on inpatient expenditure,and then to make recommendations to health policy makers and hypertensive patients for managing hypertension.Methods:The claims data of hypertensive patients insured by the rural new cooperative medical scheme in a city in northern China from 2008 to 201 3 were analyzed,descriptive statistics employed to analyze direct medical cost of hypertensive patients and hypertensive patients without complicated diseases which was one of the three groups divided by medical treatment conditions (hypertension without complicated diseases,hyper-tension with complicated diseases,and other diseases),and the differences between groups compared by t test.The fixed effect two-part model was employed to analyze the substitution effect of outpatient services on inpatient services,and specific effects of outpatient times and reimbursement expenses on the inpatient expenditure were calculated by Logistic regression analysis.Results:For the hypertensive pa-tients,the average cost of outpatients was 283.49 Yuan in 2008 and rose to 370.93 Yuan in 201 3.After being divided into three groups,for hypertensive patients without complicated diseases,the average cost of outpatient was 449.79 Yuan in 2008 and rose to 582.53 Yuan in 201 3.In the total cost of the outpa-tient,45.73% was for the hypertensive patients without complicated diseases;in the total cost of the in-patient,only 9.29% was for the hypertensive patients without complicated diseases.By calculating the marginal effect of parameter estimation through the fixed effect two-part model,the inpatient cost could be significantly reduced by increasing the visit times of outpatient utilization or the cost of outpatient reim-bursement.For example,in 201 3,a 1 % rise of outpatient visit times increased outpatient expenditures by 6.48 million Yuan,which could reduce inpatient expenditures by 39.86 million Yuan.The substitu-ted ratio of outpatient cost on inpatient cost had been around 5 in 201 0 and later.Conclusion:The health policy-makers and hypertensive patients should pay more attentions to the substitution of outpatient cost for inpatient cost,especially for the hypertensive patients without complicated diseases whose direct medical cost was mainly due to outpatient rather than inpatient costs.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To explore the association between different urbanization levels and non-commu-nicable diseases (NCDs)in China and provide suggestions on designing relevant health policies in the ur-banization process.Methods:We obtained health-related data from China Health and Retirement Longi-tudinal Study (CHARLS)201 1 .This study used multistage sampling in design stage and covered 1 50 districts/counties,representative at the levels of the country.Geo-information system (GIS)method was used to get district areas data,and in combination with the Sixth National Census population data,we computed the population density which was regarded as the proxy variable of urbanization level in every city.The Logistic model was used to explore the effect of urbanization level on hypertension,diabetes, smoking,drinking,overweight and obesity.Results:Compared with other cities in China,Shanghai and Shenzhen,with the population density of more than 3 000 people per km2 ,were the cities with highest urbanization level.From the map of urbanization distribution across China,it was found that the urbani-zation levels of the northwestern districts were lower than those of the southeastern and coastal districts. The hypertension rate increased with the development of urbanization but there was no statistical signifi-cance.The proportion of patients with diabetes went up first and then saw a decrease trend in the process of urbanization.Drinking rate,overweight rate and obesity rate had similar trends,falling to their lowest point when urbanization level equaled 737,1 1 86 and 1 353 people per km2 respectively and then ex-perienced upward trends.By contrast,smoking rate declined first and then went up (the turning point was 1 029 people per km2 ).Conclusion:Different urbanization levels have different effects on NCDs, health-related behavior,overweight and obesity.Low urbanization level may create negative impact on health while high level can pose positive effect and increase people’s health condition possibly due to the improvement of health care accessibility and the quality of living environment.Policy-makers should spe-cially focus on different residents’health problems in different periods of urbanization,such as the impact of environmental pollution,health resources’allocation and accessibility of health services.It is necessa-ry to reduce or avoid the negative effect of urbanization on NCDs during the local development process to face the NCDs’threat.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To study the substitution effect of outpatient services on inpatient services and provide suggestions on designing outpatient policies. Methods:The data were from 13 districts/counties in one area of eastern China from 2007 to 2013 for the new cooperative medical scheme. This study em-ployed a fixed effects model to analyze the impacts of outpatient visit times, expenditure amounts and re-imbursements on inpatient services. Results: One outpatient visit reduced the total amount of inpatient services by 20 Yuan. An increase of 10 000 Yuan outpatient reimbursements saved 9 700 Yuan inpatient expenses. An increase of 10 000 Yuan outpatient expenses led to a decrease of 3 000 Yuan inpatient re-imbursements. The outpatient services did not increase the inpatient hospitalization times significantly. In particular, the effects of the outpatient services were mainly on the inpatient services at the district/coun-ty levels, and no significant impacts on the outpatient services at the city levels. Conclusion:There is a substitution effect of outpatient services on inpatient services. The health insurance departments should take this substitution effect into account and shift more funds on outpatient series, when they design out-patient and inpatient reimbursement policies.
ABSTRACT
Objective: To study the influence of contractual medical association on inpatient service performance. Methods:The data came from“Database of Inpatient Record” administered by Department of Medical Insurance. Using diagnosis related groups ( DRG) as the tool of risk-adjustment, the third-tier general hospitals and second-tier general hospitals in medical alliance as the intervention group, and the average level of the same grade local hospitals as the control group, the influence of medical alliance on inpatient service performance was evaluated. The difference in difference ( DID) method was used for the data analysis. The assessing indicators included the number of DRG group, case mix index ( CMI) , the total weight, cost efficiency index and time efficiency index. Results:After the establishment of medical association, compared with the average level of the same grade local hospitals, in the third-tier general hospitals of medical alliance, the growth rate of the total weight had declined, and cost efficiency index had increased, while in the second-tier general hospitals of medical alliance, the CMI value had de-clined, and the cost efficiency index had increased. Conclusion:Contractual medical association played a role of triage patients, and improved the service levels and management efficiency of the second-tier general hospitals.
ABSTRACT
Objective:This paper investigates the difference of chronic disease in different social class of the elderly in Beijing .Method: Date of a representative sample included 1717 residents aged 60 and above are drawn from Beijing elderly household survey 2013 conducted by Peking university school of public health .With income , ed-ucation , occupation and residence household as indicators of social class , logistic regression model is used for analy-zing the difference of chronic disease prevalence among different socio-economic status .Result:The non-agricultural household group , middle and highest income group , the least and highest groups of education have a lower probability and the farming , forestry, animal husbandry and fishing water production personnel before retired have a higher risk of suffering from chronic disease .In terms of multiple chronic diseases , second lowest 20%income group tie to high-er risk of suffering three or more chronic conditions simultaneously .Conclusion: Strategies development of chronic disease prevention and control should take full account of social determinants of health such as the social stratifica -tion , not just for the direct cause of chronic diseases .Agricultural household , low-income and low-education group of people should be priorities in Beijing elderly chronic disease prevention and control .
ABSTRACT
Authors described characteristics of medical service performance evaluation,and strategy options for scientifically evaluating such performance,and systematically presented the conditions and methodology of DRGs-based evaluation of medical service performance.Six evaluation indicators were cited in terms of the capacity,efficiency and medical safety of medical service providers,with detailed introduction to the computation process of such indicators.Cases in hand indicate that the first-page data completeness and accuracy of medical records are preconditions for using DRGs in medical service performance evaluation.
ABSTRACT
It is the core of provider payment reform in healthcare that payment methods can be chosen correctly.According to the framework of contract theory,this paper compared the“pricing cost”and“monitoring cost”between diagnosis related groups perspective payment system(DRGs-PPS)and feefor-service.And then,based on contract theory,this paper further turn to analyzed the main management problems during the implementation of DRGs-PPS,and put forward relevant policies key points from the aspects of“monitoring”and“maintaining”.This paper drawn the basic conclusions that,comparing to feefor-services,DRG-s-PPS have relative low transaction; therefore,the transformation from fee-for-service to DRGs-PPS will benefit the virtuous circle of the healthcare market.However,DRGs-PPS is new deal for China,so it need to be pushed forward steadily with the full consideration of healthcare regulations and system maintenance.
ABSTRACT
This article reviewed the connotation,developing process and utilization theory of diagnosis related groups (DRGs).DRGs,which is one of ease mix systems,is now used widely in healthcare management.DRGs classify inpatient based on diagnose and procedure.Practices have shown that it has relative high capacity for the risk adjustment of acute care cases; therefore,it can improve the efficiency of expenditure and performance management of inpatient services.Currently,there are more than 30 countries and regions using DRGs,and the theories and methodologies of DRGs get mature.China's new round healthcare reform have developed in depth.The study and development of DRGs related health management tool will promote China' s healthcare system becoming more scientific,normalized and systematic.
ABSTRACT
Diagnosis related groups (DRGs)have been widely used in many countries and regions.The versions of DRGs in different regions are modified according to the local circumstances and conditions.Beijing version DRGs (BJ-DRGs)is the first DRGs system in Chinese,which was developed locally based on the conditions of medical information system and health relative policies in Beijing.This paper introduced the grouping principles,logic and methodology of BJ-DRGs.Taking“ear,nose,mouth and throat disorders”for example,this paper demonstrated the grouping process of BJ-DRGs.
ABSTRACT
Objective Beijing plans to run a DRGs-PPS pilot.The relative height of each DRG group produced by the price of charge categories.Because of serious distortions of medical services prices,DRGs'weight must be adjusted.Methods Dividing medical service into 5 major class-medical,nursing,technique,drugs and consumables,management,a conversion with currency were established to produce the cost.Results The weight of groups involve intervention from MDCF are drop.ConclusionThe weight regulated can optimize resources allocation and reflect the ture value of medical service.
ABSTRACT
Objective To improve overall value of healthcare industry through setting up critical inpatient medical services strategic plan.Methods Identify major objectives which the local government expects to achieve through strategic map; Standardize inpatient output and assign weight to each group through diagonosis related groups; Translate the objectives of strategic map and result of diagnosis related group to Balanced Score-card; Finally build up strategic map and according action plans.ResultsPreliminarily established 16 objectives、23 measures and 13 tasks in four perspectives including customer,internal work flow,learning and growing and finance.ConclusionThe strategy map and the balanced score-card can help implement full strategic plan of regional inpatient medical services; DRGs is a core management tool of patient-centred service output management; Balanced Score-card is able to realize continuous improvement of Beijing inpatient medical services from macro to micro persoetive.
ABSTRACT
ObjectiveTo evaluate the performance of diagnosis-related groups,Beijing version (BJ-DRGs) which were locally developed in Beijing.MethodA total of 1.3 million inpatient records from 149 hospitals in Beijing in 2008 were drawn from Beijing Public Information Center.Coefficient of variation (CV) was used to measure the performance of DRGs system.ResultsBJ-DRGs produced the best CV results for expenditure.ConclusionsUnder Beijing's medical information condition,BJ-DRGs produced good performance.