Trial of an Experimental Castor Oil Solution for Cleaning Dentures

Denture hygiene is essential because denture biofilm is involved in oral infections and systemic diseases. Although there are chemical agents available on the market, none of them have ideal properties and research on such products is still necessary. The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of a castor bean (Ricinus communis)-based solution for removing denture biofilm, compared to two traditional products (sodium hypochlorite and alkaline peroxide). Fifty maxillary complete denture wearers were instructed to brush their dentures after meals and to immerse their dentures once a day in the following solutions: Saline (20 min; control), Polident alkaline peroxide (3 min), NaOCl (20 min) and 2% castor oil solution (20 min). Participants used each solution for a period of 7 consecutive days, according to a random sequence. After each period, the internal surfaces of maxillary complete dentures were stained with a disclosing solution (1% neutral red), photographed and the disclosed biofilm was quantified with the aid of specific software. The influence of treatments on results was verified by the Friedman test (α=0.05). Tested solutions presented significant difference (Fr=51.67; p<0.001). Saline and NaOCl were significantly different (median: 2.0% and 0.0%) whereas Polident and castor oil presented intermediate results (median: 1.0% and 1.5%, respectively). It can be concluded that the castor oil solution tested in this study was comparable to alkaline peroxide in terms of efficiency in denture biofilm removal.

A higiene de próteses totais é essencial, uma vez que o biofilme da prótese está envolvido com infecções orais e doenças sistêmicas. Apesar de existirem agentes químicos disponíveis no mercado, nenhum deles apresenta propriedades ideais e pesquisas com esses produtos ainda são necessárias. O objetivo neste estudo foi avaliar a eficácia de uma solução de mamona (Ricinus communis) para a remoção do biofilme de prótese total, comparada com dois produtos comerciais (NaOCl e peróxido alcalino). Cinqüenta usuários de próteses totais maxilares foram instruídos a escovar as próteses após as refeições e imergi-las uma vez por dia nas seguintes soluções: soro fisiológico (20 min), Peróxido alcalino Polident (3 min), NaOCl a 1% (20 min) e solução de mamona (20 min). Os participantes utilizaram cada solução por um período de sete dias consecutivos, de acordo com uma sequência aleatória. Após cada período, as superfícies internas das próteses totais superiores foram coradas com solução evidenciadora (vermelho neutro a 1%), fotografadas e o biofilme evidenciado foi quantificado com software. A influência dos tratamentos sobre os resultados foi verificada pelo teste de Friedman (α=0,05). Houve diferença significativa entre as soluções (Fr=51,67;p<0,001). O soro fisiológico e o NaOCl foram significativamente diferentes (mediana: 2,0% e 0,0%), enquanto o Polident e a solução de mamona apresentaram resultados intermediários (mediana: 1,0% e 1,5%, respectivamente). Concluiu-se que a solução de mamona avaliada é comparável ao peróxido alcalino, em termos de remoção do biofilme de prótese total.

The efficacy of denture cleansing agents: A scanning electron microscopic study / 대한치과보철학회지

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare the cleansing performance of a distilled water, a diluted solution of sodium hypochlorite as a household bleaching cleanser and three alkaline peroxide cleansers in vivo plaque deposits by using scanning electron microscope. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five individuals were selected from department of the prosthodontics in Pusan National University Hospital, and each of them was inserted with specimens for plaque accumulation in their temporary dentures for 48 hours. The specimens were removed and cleaned by each cleansing agents for 8 hours. Scanning electron micrographs were made from the specimens at a magnification of x2,000. A panel of ten persons with a dental or paradental background, but not directly involved in the study, was selected to analyze the photomicrographs to determine which denture cleanser was more effective in removing plaque. RESULTS: Diluted solution of sodium hypochlorite was the most effective at removing plaque following Polident(R), Cleadent(R)e, Bonyplus(R) and distilled water in order. But there was no significant difference of cleansing efficacy between diluted solution of sodium hypochlorite and Polident(R), Polident(R) and Cleadent(R)e, Cleadent(R)e and Bonyplus(R), respectively (P > .05). Alkaline peroxide cleansers by themselves cannot adequately remove accumulated plaque deposits, especially if the deposits are heavy. Corrosion could be seen on the surface of non-precious alloy specimens immersed in diluted solution of sodium hypochlorite. CONCLUSION: It is recommended to use of alkaline peroxide type cleansers with brushing whenever possible, since denture cleanliness is often poor due to the relative inefficiency of these cleansers.