ABSTRACT
Resumen: Introducción: Los defectos óseos se asocian a inestabilidad de hombro recidivante. Bankart-Remplissage (B+R) y Latarjet (L) son alternativas de tratamiento. Pocos estudios comparan ambas técnicas. Objetivo: Comparar evolución funcional, complicaciones y tasa de recidiva, entre B+R y L en pacientes con inestabilidad glenohumeral anterior con defecto óseo no crítico. Material y métodos: Estudio retrospectivo de cohortes, en pacientes operados entre 2010 y 2018. Ciento siete pacientes fueron reclutados, de éstos, se obtuvo información desde su ficha clínica. Se midió tamaño de Hill-Sachs (HS) y defecto glenoideo en tomografía axial computarizada (TAC). Se envió encuesta remota evaluando funcionalidad con SSV, WOSI, EVA y qDASH. Cuarenta y ocho pacientes completaron el seguimiento remoto (26 B+R y 22 L). Media de seguimiento de 3.8 años. Resultados: Al comparar ambos grupos no hubo diferencias significativas en WOSI, EVA, qDASH ni SSV. No hubo diferencia en el número de complicaciones (B+R: 13 [18.8%], L: 5 [13.2%], p = 0.16), reoperaciones (B+R: 4 [5.7%], L: 1 [2.6%], p = 0.41) ni reluxación (B+R: 4 [5.7%], L: 1 [2.6%], p = 0.41). En pacientes que realizan deporte de contacto o colisión, L tuvo mejor SSV (92.5 vs 72.5 p = 0.048) y WOSI total (98.3 vs 67.3 p = 0.043). B+R en extremidad dominante presentó mayor tasa de complicaciones (50 vs 9.1% p = 0.038). No se encontró asociación para complicaciones y reluxación según defecto glenoideo o número de luxaciones previo a cirugía. Conclusión: Bankart-Remplissage y Latarjet tienen similar resultado funcional y tasa de reluxación en nuestros grupos estudiados. Latarjet muestra mejor resultado funcional subjetivo en deportistas de contacto y menores complicaciones en extremidad dominante.
Abstract: Introduction: Significant Hill-Sachs lesions are associated with recurrent shoulder instability. Bankart-Remplissage (B+R) and Latarjet (L) are valid treatments for these injuries. Few studies compare both techniques. Objective: To compare functional outcome, complications and recurrent instability rate between B+R and L in patients operated for anterior shoulder instability (ASI) with significant Hill-Sachs (HS) lesions and non critical glenoid bone loss (NC-GBL). Material and methods: Retrospective cohort study with patients operated between 2010 and 2018 for ASI. 107 met inclusion criteria. Demographic data, complications, recurrence rate and subsequent procedures were obtained from their medical records. CT scan imaging was used to assess humeral and glenoid bone loss. Online questionnaires were sent for assesing functional outcomes with SSV, WOSI, VAS and qDASH. 48 patients completed the online assessment (26 B+R, 22 L). The mean follow-up was 3.8 years. Results: Comparing both groups, there were no differences in WOSI, SSV, EVA and qDASH. There was no difference in complication rate (B+R: 13 [18.8%], L: 5 [13.2%], p = 0.16), revisions (B+R: 4 [5.7%], L: 1 [2.6%], p = 0.41) and recurrent instability (B+R: 4 [5.7%], L: 1 [2.6%], p = 0.41). L in subgroup who practiced collision sports had better SSV (92.5 vs 72.5 p = 0.048) and WOSI (98.3 vs 67.3 p = 0.043). B+R in dominant extremity had worst complication rate (50 vs 9.1% p = 0.038). Association was not found between complications and recurrent instabillity according to glenoid bone defect or previous dislocation episodes. Conclusion: Significant Hill-Sachs lesions with NC-GBL, both Bankart-Remplissage and Latarjet achieve satisfactory results, with similar recurrent instability and functional outcomes. Latarjet has better subjetive funtional results in collision sports and less complication in dominant extremity compared to Bankart-Remplissage.
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The aims of this study were to investigate the clinical characteristics of patients with combined anterior instability and superior labrum from anterior to posterior (SLAP) lesions, and to analyze the effect of concomitant SLAP repair on surgical outcomes. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed patients who underwent arthroscopic stabilization for anterior shoulder instability between January 2004 and March 2013. A total of 120 patients were available for at least 1-year follow-up. Forty-four patients with reparable concomitant detached SLAP lesions (group I) underwent combined SLAP and anterior stabilization, and 76 patients without SLAP lesions (group II) underwent anterior stabilization alone. Patient characteristics, preoperative and postoperative pain scores, Rowe scores, and shoulder ranges of motion were compared between the 2 groups. RESULTS: Patients in group I had higher incidences of high-energy trauma (p = 0.03), worse preoperative pain visual analogue scale (VAS) (p = 0.02), and Rowe scores (p = 0.04). The postoperative pain VAS and Rowe scores improved equally in both groups without significant differences. Limitation in postoperative range of motion was similar between the groups (all p-value > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Anterior instability with SLAP lesion may not be related to frequent episodes of dislocation but rather to a high-energy trauma. SLAP fixation with anterior stabilization procedures did not lead to poor functional outcomes if appropriate surgical techniques were followed.
Subject(s)
Humans , Joint Dislocations , Follow-Up Studies , Incidence , Pain, Postoperative , Range of Motion, Articular , Retrospective Studies , Shoulder Dislocation , ShoulderABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The aims of this study were to investigate the clinical characteristics of patients with combined anterior instability and superior labrum from anterior to posterior (SLAP) lesions, and to analyze the effect of concomitant SLAP repair on surgical outcomes. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed patients who underwent arthroscopic stabilization for anterior shoulder instability between January 2004 and March 2013. A total of 120 patients were available for at least 1-year follow-up. Forty-four patients with reparable concomitant detached SLAP lesions (group I) underwent combined SLAP and anterior stabilization, and 76 patients without SLAP lesions (group II) underwent anterior stabilization alone. Patient characteristics, preoperative and postoperative pain scores, Rowe scores, and shoulder ranges of motion were compared between the 2 groups. RESULTS: Patients in group I had higher incidences of high-energy trauma (p = 0.03), worse preoperative pain visual analogue scale (VAS) (p = 0.02), and Rowe scores (p = 0.04). The postoperative pain VAS and Rowe scores improved equally in both groups without significant differences. Limitation in postoperative range of motion was similar between the groups (all p-value > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Anterior instability with SLAP lesion may not be related to frequent episodes of dislocation but rather to a high-energy trauma. SLAP fixation with anterior stabilization procedures did not lead to poor functional outcomes if appropriate surgical techniques were followed.
Subject(s)
Humans , Joint Dislocations , Follow-Up Studies , Incidence , Pain, Postoperative , Range of Motion, Articular , Retrospective Studies , Shoulder Dislocation , ShoulderABSTRACT
Introdução: A instabilidade anterior traumática do ombro é uma doença ortopédica comum que acomete pacientes jovens e/ou atletas. Na maioria das vezes, a lesão de Bankart encontra-se associada. Nesta situação o tratamento cirúrgico é comumente indicado. O objetivo deste estudo é comparar, através de revisão sistemática da literatura, a taxa de insucesso da técnica de Bankart, via artroscópica, com a técnica de Bankart aberta, através da taxa de insucesso de ambas as técnicas nos artigos revisados. Métodos: Através do MEDLINE/Pubmed, pesquisaram-se as palavraschave: a) anterior shoulder instability; b) Bankart lesion; c) traumatic recurrent anterior shoulder instability; d) open Bankart repair; e) arthroscopic Bankart repair; f ) arthroscopic versus open Bankart repair em artigos publicados entre 1998 a 2008, que comparavam a técnica aberta com a técnica artroscópica, exclusivamente operados pela técnica de Bankart. Sete artigos preencheram os critérios de seleção. Entre as variáveis estudadas estavam o número de pacientes e ombros operados por cada técnica, o sexo, o tipo de escore de avaliação e o desfecho. Resultados: Foram abarcados 478 pacientes, 481 ombros, dos quais 54,9% foram operados pela técnica de Bankart contra 45,1% pela técnica aberta. 84,7% (405) eram homens, 15,3% (73) eram mulheres. O escore de Rowe foi mencionado em todos os artigos avaliados. A taxa de insucesso na técnica artroscópica foi de 10,6% contra 7,8% na técnica aberta. Conclusão: As técnicas artroscópica e aberta produziram bons resultados para o tratamento da instabilidade anterior traumática de ombro. Ambas as técnicas apresentaram resultados similares na taxa de insucesso
Introduction: The traumatic anterior instability of the shoulder is a common orthopedic disease that affects young patients and/or athletes. Most often the Bankart lesion is associated. In this situation surgery is usually indicated. The aim of this study is to compare, through a systematic review of the literature, the Bankart technique via arthroscopy with the open Bankart technique through the failure rates of both techniques in the reviewed articles. Methods: Using the MEDLINE/PubMed databases, the following keywords were searched: a) anterior shoulder instability; b) Bankart lesion; c) traumatic recurrent anterior shoulder instability; d) open Bankart repair; e) arthroscopic Bankart repair, and f ) arthroscopic versus open Bankart repair, in articles published from 1998 to 2008 comparing the open technique with the arthroscopic technique performed exclusively with the Bankart technique. Seven articles met the selection criteria. Among the variables studied were the number of patients and shoulders operated by each technique, sex, type of evaluation score, and outcome. Results: The study covered 478 patients, 481 shoulders, of which 54.9% were operated by the Bankart technique against 45.1% by the open technique. 84.7% (405) were men and 15.3% (73) were women. The Rowe score was mentioned in all of the reviewed articles. The failure rate in the arthroscopic technique was 10.6% versus 7.8% in the open technique. Conclusion: The open and arthroscopic techniques have produced good results for the treatment of traumatic anterior shoulder instability. Both techniques showed similar results in the failure rate
Subject(s)
Arthroscopy , General Surgery , Joint Instability/surgery , Review Literature as Topic , Shoulder Dislocation/surgery , Shoulder/surgery , Shoulder/injuriesABSTRACT
PURPOSE: We wanted to evaluate the effectiveness of inferior capsular plication for treating the anterior instability of the shoulder by comparing the prospective outcomes and the incidence of complications of the group (group1) that underwent arthroscopic vertical shift of the anteroinferior capsulo-labral complex and plication of the anterior band of inferior glenohumeral ligament and the group (group2) that underwent inferior capsular plication that was augmentated by the same method. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From March 2005 to August 2007, we compared group 1 (42 cases) that underwent arthroscopic vertical shift of the anteroinferior capsulo-labral complex and plication of the anterior band of the inferior glenohumeral ligament and group 2 (33 cases) that underwent augmentated inferior capsular plication for recurrent anterior instability of the shoulder. The mean age was 22.5 years (range: 17~31 years) in group I, and 21.8 years (range: 16~30 years) in group II. The mean follow up was 23.5 months (range: 12~45 months in group I, and 20.1 months (range: 12~49 months) in group II. We checked the Rowe score and ROM preoperatively and at postoperative 6 months, 1 year and at the last follow up and we compared the incidence of complications. RESULTS: The Rowe score increased from a preoperative mean of 20.6 to the last follow up mean of 86.8 after surgery in group I, and the Rowe score increased from a preoperative mean of 20.5 to the last follow up mean of 94.1 after surgery in group II. For the anterior instability of the shoulder, arthroscopic reconstruction had a good outcome in all of the cases, but group II had better outcomes and less complications than did group I (p<0.05). CONCLUSION: We thought that arthroscopic vertical shift of the anteroinferior capsulo-labral complex and plication of the anterior band of the inferior glenohumeral ligament with inferior capsular plication can lower the complication rate and show better outcomes.
Subject(s)
Arthroscopy , Follow-Up Studies , Incidence , Ligaments , Prospective Studies , ShoulderABSTRACT
PURPOSE: An osseous defect in the glenoid and humeral head is closely associated with recurrence of anterior shoulder instability. The purpose of this article is to describe the open surgical techniques and introduce our experiences with anterior instability with a significant osseous defect. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed the articles that have focused on and/or mentioned the affect of osseous defects on anterior shoulder instability. The open surgical techniques and its related pearls are summarized in this review. RESULTS: Accurate evaluation for the size and location of the osseous defect is critical for preventing recurrence after restoration of the anterior capsulolabral structure. The glenoid bone restoration techniques include the coracoids transfer (the Bristow procedure and the Latarjet procedure) and a structural iliac bone graft. Rotational humeral osteotomy and an osteoarticular allograft could be used for repairing a significant posterosuperior humeral defect (Hill-Sachs lesion). Shoulder arthroplasty may be tried for treating a humeral bone defect, but more study on this is needed. CONCLUSION: Open surgical restoration decreases the risk of recurrence anterior shoulder instability that is combined with a significant osseous defect. Arthroscopic surgery currently has limitations for treating an osseous defect, but it will become useful in proportion to the development of arthroscopic instruments and techniques in the future.
Subject(s)
Arthroplasty , Arthroscopy , Humeral Head , Osteotomy , Recurrence , Shoulder , Transplantation, Homologous , TransplantsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: To evaluate prospectively the results of early active exercise after open Bankart repair of traumatic anterior shoulder instability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January, 2001 to June, 2003, 26 patients who were followed up at least 1 year after open Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability were evaluated. Average age was 23.9 years old (range, 19~43) with 24 males and 2 females. We evaluated them using the functional shoulder scores (modified Rowe score, ASES score), range of motion, VAS pain scale, patient's subjective satisfaction and return to unlimited daily living activity. RESULTS: The shoulder functional scores increased significantly. At last follow up, the final range of motion were flexion in average 5° deficit in comparison to normal side, external rotation in average 10o deficit, and internal rotation in T9. The patient's subjective satisfaction was good in 2l patients (81%). Return to unlimited daily activity was possible in 23 patients (88.5%), and 19 patients (73%) rejoined to sports activity before injury. There were complications including anterior recurrent subluxation in 1 case, weakness of subscapularis muscle in 1 case. CONCLUSION: In traumatic anterior shoulder instability, early active range of motion exercise after open Bankart repair does not decrease shoulder stability. Early exercise can be useful for returning to previous level of sports activity in young active patients.
Subject(s)
Female , Humans , Male , Activities of Daily Living , Follow-Up Studies , Prospective Studies , Range of Motion, Articular , Shoulder , SportsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: This study compared the long-term clinical results of an open Bankart procedure for anterior shoulder instability with those from an arthroscopic procedure, and evaluated the factors influencing the final outcomes and recurrence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred thirty three shoulders with a Bankart repair of a traumatic anterior shoulder instability with a follow-up period of at least 6 years were enrolled in this study. Sixty-seven shoulders had an open repair and sixty-six shoulders, an arthroscopic repair. The mean age at the time of the operation was 27.7 years (range, 17 to 62 years). The mean follow-up period was 100 months (range, 72 to 141 months). RESULTS: At the last follow-up, the pain score during motion improved from 3.86 to 1.36. Forward flexion and external rotation at the side decreased to a mean of 3 degrees, 9 degrees in the open group and a mean of 1 degree, 4 degrees in the arthroscopic group. Sixty-two (93%) and 59 shoulders (89%) in the open and arthroscopic group could return to their pre-injury sports activities, respectively. At a mean 12.5 months after surgery, 14 shoulders (10.5%) experienced a redislocation. There were 6 (9%) and 8 (12%) redislocations in the open and arthroscopic groups, respectively. CONCLUSION: The open group showed relatively better results than the arthroscopic group but there was no significant difference between two groups. Both open and arthroscopic Bankart procedures are effective methods that produce acceptable results when a precise surgical technique and proper postoperative rehabilitation are carried out.
Subject(s)
Follow-Up Studies , Recurrence , Rehabilitation , Shoulder , SportsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: To evaluate the function of the shoulder and the effect of the division of the subscapularis tendon on the strength of the inter-nal rotator after capsular imbrication and Bankart repair. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January, 1996 to December, 2000, we reviewed thirty cases of traumatic anterior shoulder instability, which underwent capsular imbrication and Bankart repair. The follow up period was minimally one year. The clinical results were evaluated using the ASES (American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons) score and the muscle power of the internal rotator as measured by a myometer. RESULTS: All cases showed satisfactory results; nineteen cases (63%) were excellent, and eleven cases (37%) were good. Mean value of ASES score increased from 78.6 (60-82) ponts to 94.5 (84-100) points. Mean value of the score increased was 16 (14-38) points. Postoperatively, the muscle power of the internal rotator compared with contralateral was increased in 12 cases (40%), decreased in 17 cases (57%), and was the same in one case (3%). There was no cases of deterioration of function, recurrence or requiring revision surgery. CONCLUSION: In capsular imbrication and Bankart repair, the division of the subscapularis tendon did not produce a significant adverse effect in the strength of the internal rotator. We believe that this is one of the useful treatment methods in traumatic anterior shoulder insta-bility, because it provides stability and a good range of motion.
Subject(s)
Elbow , Follow-Up Studies , Range of Motion, Articular , Recurrence , Shoulder , TendonsABSTRACT
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to present the usefulness of arthrometer (KT-2000) in patients with anterior knee instability and to assist in evaluating an objective prognosis after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. MATERIAL AND METHOD: We analyzed the manual maximum anterior displacement, passive anterior displacement at 30Ib force and compliance index between 15Ib and 30Ib, measured by KT-2000 in 82 cases of patient who had unilateral anterior knee instability and 40 cases of volunteers, as control group, who had no history of knee injury. We used the Paired and Independent t-test for statistical analysis. RESULTS: In control group, the mean value of manual maximum anterior displacement is 0.8 +/- 0.9mm, passive anterior displacement, 1.4 +/- 1.3mm and compliance index, 1.1 +/- 1.1mm. In patient group, the mean value of manual maximum anterior displacement is 7.1 +/- 2.7mm, passive displacement, 6.1 +/- 2.6mm and compliance index, 3.8 +/- 1.8mm. We found that the patient group was revealed much higher degree of anterior displacement than the control group (p<0.005) . CONCLUSION: KT-2000 is objective and quantitative in diagnosis of anterior knee instability.
Subject(s)
Humans , Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction , Compliance , Diagnosis , Knee Injuries , Knee , Prognosis , VolunteersABSTRACT
Recent advances in arthroscopic surgery have given new options for dealing with anterior glenohumeral instability with less morbidity than the open procedure. The early literature discussing arthroscopic Bankart suture repair is favorable, however limited long-term follow-up studies have yet to prove its success. This study reports our experience with arthroscopic transglenoid Bankart suture repair with a minimum 2-year follow-up. Arthroscopic transglenoid Bankart repair was performed in 23 cases of anterior shoulder instability with some modifications of Caspari's suture technique. First, the suture material was #1 PDS and the number of sutures was 4 or 5. Second, the insertion site of the guide pin was moved to 1 o'clock on the right shoulder and to 11 o'clock on the left shoulder to prevent slippage of the guide pin. With this technique, we obtained 87% satisfactory results analyzed by the Rowe functional grading system. There was no suprascapular or axillary nerve injury. Two patients had redislocations and one patient had recurrent subluxation. Five patients complained of suture-knot irritation problems.
Subject(s)
Adult , Female , Humans , Male , Arthroscopy , Endoscopy , Joint Instability/surgery , Middle Aged , Shoulder Joint/surgery , Suture TechniquesABSTRACT
Various methods have been described for surgical treatment of recurrent shoulder dislocation. Arthroscopic techniques for stabilizing the shoulder have the theoretical advantage of reduced complication, decreased discomfort, and improved motion. The arthroscopic Bankart procedure was performed in 23 cases at Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Yonsei University College of Medicine, from January, 1991 to December, 1993. This study is an attempt to evaluate results of arthroscopic Bankart procedure by Caspari's technique. Results of this study were as follows: l. According to the clinical evaluation of Rowe, results were excellent in 18 cases, good in 2 cases, fair in 1 cases and poor in 2 case. The prognosis was related to the size of Hill-Sachs lesion. 2. Complication after treatment included 5 cases of knot problem, 1 case of subluxation, and 2 cases of redislocation. Redislocation was developed in one patient who played ice hockey at 2 months after operation and in one patient who played soccer at 8 months after operation. Subluxation was developed in one patient who had psychologic problem. Among 5 patients who had knot prob- lem, two patients had a operation of removal. In conclusion, Caspari's suture technique in arthroscopic Bankart procedure needs some modification on the insertion point of the guide pin and suturing technique. And arthroscopic Bankart procedure by Caspari's technique offers good cosmetic results, low perioperative morbidity, low complications except knot irritation, and excellent results by the Rowe's criteria for patients with anterior shoulder instability.
Subject(s)
Humans , Arthroscopy , Hockey , Prognosis , Shoulder , Shoulder Dislocation , Soccer , Suture TechniquesABSTRACT
We performed 15 cases of modified Bristow procedures for recurrent anterior instability of shoulder from january, 1987 to december, 1992 and the following results were obtained. 1. The patient's age at initial dislocation varied from 15 years to 29 years of age. 2. The most common cause of the recurrent anterior instability of shoulder was sport injury(6 cases) and next were traffic accident, hanging with one hand. 3. The average loss of external rotation of shoulder after operation were 10 degrees and internal rotation were 7 degrees. 4. The post-operative complication and recurrence were not observed. 5. End results were excellent in 7 and good in 5 by Rowe's grading system. 6. Strict attention to bone block placement was mandatory and decreased the risk of screw malpo-sition.
Subject(s)
Accidents, Traffic , Joint Dislocations , Hand , Recurrence , Shoulder , SportsABSTRACT
Fifteen shoulders in 15 patients with traumatic recurrent anterior dislocation were performed from Sept. 1993 to April 1994. The position in which the dislocation occurred were abduction and external rotation in 10 cases, but most likely direct injuries in the 13 cases. The average interval between the initial and second dislocation was 5.4 months, and the average frequency of dislocation was 15 times per year. Physically, crank test in 13, fulcrum test in 12, sulcus test in 4, and jerk test in 3 cases were positive. The classic Bankart lesions were 4 cases, the bony Bankart lesions in 11 cases, so all of them had an abnormal tension on the inferior glenohumeral ligament. The Hill-Sachs lesions were associated in 14 cases, the Superior Labrum Anterior Posterior lesion in 1 case. Traditional Bankart procedure in 12 cases, traditional method and shift surgery simultaneously for inferior laxity in 3 cases were performed. In 4 cases of bony Bankart lesion with large bone fragment, anterior capsule and subscapularis muslce was splitted during exposure. Velpeau sling was applied in a daytime for postoperative immobilization, exercise with 90° of flexion but no external rotation was permitted during 3 weeks after operation. After than 140° of flexion and 40° of flexion and averag 57° of external rotation. There was no recurrence in our series. The result at follow up were exellent in 9 cases, good in 6 cases.