Association and Contribution of Patient and Bereaved Family Background to Outcomes of Survivor Surveys

A secondary analysis of data from national bereavement surveys conducted in 2014, 2016, and 2018 was conducted with the aim of identifying the contribution of various patient and bereavement backgrounds to the outcomes of the Bereavement Survey. The data were evaluated in terms of structure and process of care (CES), achievement of a desirable death (GDI), complexity grief (BGQ), and depression (PHQ-9). The large data set and comprehensive analysis of bereavement survey outcomes clarified the need for adjustment of confounding variables and which variables should be adjusted for in future analyses. Overall, the contribution of the background factors examined in this study to the CES (Adj-R2=0.014) and overall satisfaction (Adj-R2=0.055) was low. The contribution of the GDI (Adj-R2=0.105) was relatively high, and that of the PHQ-9 (Max-rescaled R2=0.200) and BGQ (Max-rescaled R2=0.207) was non-negligible.

Complicated grief, unusual perceptual experiences, and hope in widowhood / Luto complicado, experiências perceptivas incomuns e esperança na viuvez / Duelo complicado, experiencias perceptuales inusuales y esperanza en la viudez

The overall objective of this study is to assess grief in religious widows and hope, and the frequency of unusual perceptual experiences after the death of the spouse. It is hypothesized that (H1) religious widows will experience a less complicated grief, (H2) a greater hope, and (H3) a higher frequency of unusual perceptual experiences than non-religious widows. Three instruments, the Complicated Grief Inventory, the Hope Scale, and the Hallucinations Questionnaire were administered to a sample consisting of religious widows and a control group (non-religious widows). The results showed that religious widows experienced less complicated grief than non-religious widows, and fewer feelings of pessimism about the death of the loved one. Religious widows who showed higher feelings of hope, compared to non-religious ones, tended to have fewer indicators of complicated grief. Furthermore, those religious widows who displayed feelings associated with remembering the deceased tended, for example, to hear voices and smell perfumes. It is possible that these occurrences may even be functional and adaptive in order to cope with the negative feelings of grief and loss, rather than resulting in a resource deficit mechanism for dealing with pain and hopelessness.

O objetivo geral deste estudo é avaliar o luto e a esperança em viúvas religiosas, e a frequência de experiências perceptivas incomuns após a morte do cônjuge. A hipótese é que (H1) viúvas religiosas experimentarão um luto menos complicado, (H2) mais esperança e (H3) maior frequência de experiências perceptivas incomuns do que viúvas não religiosas. Três instrumentos, o Inventário do Luto Complicado, a Escala de Esperança e o Questionário de Alucinações, foram administrados a uma amostra composta por viúvas religiosas e um grupo de controle (viúvas não religiosas). Os resultados mostraram que as viúvas religiosas experimentaram um luto menos complicado do que as viúvas não religiosas e menos sentimentos de pessimismo em relação à morte de um ente querido. As viúvas religiosas que mostraram maior senso de esperança, em comparação com as viúvas não religiosas, tendem a ter menos indicadores de luto complicado. Além disso, aquelas viúvas religiosas que demonstravam sentimentos associados à memória do falecido tendiam, por exemplo, a ouvir vozes e cheirar perfumes. É possível que essas ocorrências possam até ser funcionais e adaptativas para lidar com os sentimentos negativos de luto e perda, em vez de ser um mecanismo de déficit de recursos para lidar com a dor e a desesperança.

El objetivo general de este estudio es evaluar el duelo en viudas religiosas y la esperanza, y la frecuencia de experiencias perceptuales inusuales después de la muerte del cónyuge. Se hipotetiza que (H1) las viudas religiosas experimentarán menor grado de duelo complicado, (H2) mayor esperanza y (H3) mayor frecuencia de experiencias perceptuales inusuales que las viudas no religiosas. Se administraron tres instrumentos, el Inventario de Duelo Complicado, la Escala de Esperanza, y el Cuestionario de Alucinaciones a una muestra integrada por viudas religiosas y un grupo control (viudas no religiosas). Los resultados mostraron que las viudas religiosas experimentaban menos duelo complicado que las viudas no religiosas, y menos sentimientos de pesimismo en torno a la muerte del ser querido. Las viudas religiosas que mostraron mayor sentimiento de esperanza, en comparación con las no religiosas, tendieron a menos indicadores de duelo complicado. Además, aquellas viudas religiosas que mostraban sentimientos asociados al recuerdo del difunto tendían, por ejemplo, a oír voces y oler perfumes. Es posible que estas ocurrencias puedan incluso ser funcionales y adaptativas para afrontar los sentimientos negativos del duelo y la pérdida, en lugar de resultar un mecanismo de déficit de recursos para lidiar contra el dolor y la desesperanza.

Factors Associated with Complicated Grief in Students Who Survived the Sewol Ferry Disaster in South Korea

OBJECTIVE: The Sewol ferry disaster caused shock and grief in South Korea. The aim of this study was to identify the factors associated with symptoms of complicated grief (CG) among the surviving students 20 months after that disaster. METHODS: This study was conducted using a cross-sectional design and a sample of 57 students who survived the Sewol ferry disaster. Data were collected using the following instruments: Inventory of Complicated Grief (ICG), the Lifetime Incidence of Traumatic Events-Child, the Child Report of Post-Traumatic Symptoms (CROPS), KIDSCREEN-27, Family Adaptability and Cohesion Evaluation Scales-III, the Peri-traumatic Dissociation–Post-traumatic Negative Beliefs–Post-traumatic Social Support scale, and the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire. A generalized linear model using a log link and Poisson distribution was performed to identify factors associated with symptoms of CG. RESULTS: The mean score on the ICG was 15.57 (standard deviation: 12.72). Being born in 1999, a higher score on the CROPS and a lower score in autonomy and relationship with parents on the KIDSCREEN-27 were related to higher levels of CG. CONCLUSION: Twenty months after the Sewol ferry disaster, 24.5% of surviving students were suffering from CG. This study uncovered a vulnerable population of bereaved children at high risk for CG.

A Retrospective and Prospective Follow-up Study of Psychological Distress in the Danwon High School Survivors of the Sewol Ferry Disaster

OBJECTIVE: We monitored a group of students from Danwon High School who survived the Sewol ferry disaster for 27 months to examine the course of their psychological symptoms. METHODS: We performed a chart review at the Danwon High School Mental Health Center at the following time points (T): 9 months (T1), 12 months (T2), and 15 months (T3) after the disaster. Additionally, we performed a follow-up review at 27 months (T4). Subjects completed the ‘State’ section of the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children, the Center for Epidemiological Studies-Depression assessment, the Child Report of Post-traumatic Symptoms, and the Inventory of Complicated Grief. Data from the 32 subjects who completed all four assessments were used in the statistical analyses. RESULTS: Scores of psychological variables tended to increase until T2 and then slowly decreased until T4. The severity of anxiety and complicated grief symptoms changed significantly over time, but the severity of depression and posttraumatic stress symptoms did not. CONCLUSION: We found that the symptoms of anxiety and complicated grief reported by Sewol ferry survivors from Danwon High School were exacerbated at the first anniversary of the disaster, but these symptoms subsided after the students graduated from high school.

Adaptación del Inventario de Duelo Complicado en población colombiana / Adaptation of the Complicated Grief Inventory to the Colombian Population / Adaptação do Inventário de Luto Complicado na População Colombiana

Resumen Se realizó la adaptación del Inventario de Duelo Complicado (IDC) en población colombiana. Cinco jurados evaluaron el contenido y ajuste cultural del cuestionario y luego éste fue aplicado a una muestra de 120 adultos que experimentaron el fallecimiento de un familiar. Los análisis psicométricos indicaron una consistencia interna similar a la de la prueba original y superior a la de la adaptación española, buena estabilidad temporal, asociaciones positivas con pruebas de depresión y ansiedad usadas para evaluar la validez convergente y tres factores significativos. Se concluye que la versión adaptada del IDC tiene propiedades psicométricas adecuadas por lo que puede ser usada en población colombiana, pero se recomienda realizar una validación con una muestra más grande y usar herramientas como una entrevista clínica para establecer el alcance diagnóstico del inventario.

Abstract The Inventory of Complicated Grief (ICG) was adapted to Colombian people. Five juries evaluated the language and cultural adjustment of the Spanish version and then, the questionnaire was applied to 120 adults who had lost a family member. Psychometrical analysis showed an internal consistency similar to that one found in the original ICG, but higher than the one found in the Spain application. Convergent validity showed positive correlations between ICG and depression and anxiety tests, and three significant factors were identified. In brief, this adapted spanish version of the ICG has good psychometric properties and it can be used with Colombian people, but a validation study with a larger sample and using tools such as a clinical interview to determine the diagnostic power of this inventory is recommended.

Resumo Realizou-se a adaptação do Inventário de Luto Complicado (IDC, em espanhol) na população colombiana. Cinco jurados avaliaram o conteúdo e o ajuste cultural do questionário e, em seguida, este foi aplicado a uma amostra de 120 adultos que experimentaram o falecimento de um familiar. As análises psicométricas indicaram uma consistência interna semelhante à do teste original e superior à da adaptação espanhola, boa estabilidade temporal, associações positivas com testes de depressão e ansiedade usados para avaliar a validade convergente e três fatores significativos. Conclui-se que a versão adaptada do idc tem propriedades psicométricas adequadas, portanto pode ser usada na população colombiana, mas se recomenda realizar uma validação com uma amostra maior e usar ferramentas como uma entrevista clínica para estabelecer o alcance diagnóstico do inventário.

Profissionais Paliativistas e suas Contribuições na Prevenção de Luto Complicado / Palliative care professionals and their contribution to the prevention of complicated grief / Profesionales paliativistas y sus contribuciones en la prevención del duelo complicado

Resumo Os cuidados paliativos buscam qualidade de vida baseada principalmente na prevenção e alívio do sofrimento de pacientes que possuem doenças ameaçadoras de vida, englobando as esferas de ordem física, psicossocial e espiritual. Além disso, estende-se ao pós-morte do paciente, oferecendo suporte à família no processo de luto. Esta pesquisa qualitativa teve como objetivo compreender e analisar a formação dos profissionais em relação ao processo de morrer do paciente e as percepções daqueles em relação às suas contribuições para a prevenção de luto complicado da unidade de cuidado. A Teoria do Apego fundamentou teoricamente este estudo. Participaram voluntariamente profissionais de saúde que integram formalmente equipes de cuidados paliativos. Foi utilizado um questionário autoaplicativo para obtenção de dados acadêmicos, profissionais e de cursos realizados, e uma entrevista semiestruturada. A análise das informações colhidas nas entrevistas foi realizada através de transcrição e categorização das mesmas, seguida de análise de conteúdo. Os resultados confirmaram que a formação dos profissionais em relação ao processo de morrer é escassa. Ademais, observou-se que os profissionais de saúde que trabalham em cuidados paliativos possuem comportamentos de apego, os quais são identificados como naturais nesse contexto, o que acaba por dificultar a percepção de que são importantes contribuições para a prevenção de luto complicado da unidade de cuidado. Diante desses resultados, a presente pesquisa trouxe a relevância sobre a necessidade da inserção das temáticas morte e morrer na educação dos profissionais de saúde, o que pode contribuir para melhor assistência à unidade de cuidado nos seus processos de luto....(AU)

Abstract Palliative care seeks quality of life based primarily on prevention and relief of suffering of patients who have life threatening diseases, encompassing physical, psychosocial and spiritual areas. Furthermore, extending the post-mortem patient, it offers support to the family in the grieving process. This qualitative study aimed to understand and analyze the training of professionals in relation to dying patients and their perceptions regarding their contribution to the prevention of complicated grief in the care unit. The Attachment Theory grounded this research theoretically. Volunteer professionals of the palliative care teams participated in this study. A self-administered questionnaire was used to obtain academic and professional data, besides their courses taken, and a semi-structured interview. The analysis of the collected data was done through transcription and categorization, followed by the content analysis. The results confirmed that the training of professionals in relation to the dying process is scarce. Moreover, it was observed that health professionals working in palliative care have attachment behaviors, identified as natural in this context, and that that ends up making it harder to realize that is an important contribution to prevent grief from becoming complicated in the care unit. The results of this research brought out the relevance of the need of inserting themes such as death and dying in the education of the professionals of this field, which can contribute to a better assistance in the care unit in the grieving process....(AU)

Resumen Los cuidados paliativos buscan la calidad de vida basada principalmente en la prevención y el alivio del sufrimiento de pacientes que poseen enfermedades amenazadoras de la vida, incluyendo las esferas de orden físico, psicosocial y espiritual. Además, se extienden más allá de la muerte del paciente y ofrecen apoyo a la familia en el proceso de luto. Esta investigación cualitativa tuvo como objetivo comprender y analizar la formación de los profesionales con relación al proceso de muerte del paciente y las percepciones de aquellos a propósito de sus contribuciones a la prevención del duelo complicado en la unidad de cuidado. La Teoría del Apego fundamentó teóricamente este estudio. Participaron voluntariamente profesionales de salud que integran formalmente equipos de cuidados paliativos. Se utilizó un cuestionario autoaplicativo para obtener datos académicos, profesionales y de cursos realizados y una entrevista semiestructurada. El análisis de las informaciones recogidas en las entrevistas se llevó a cabo a través de su transcripción, categorización y posterior análisis de contenido. Los resultados confirmaron que la formación de los profesionales con relación al proceso de muerte es escasa. Además, se ha observado que los profesionales de salud que trabajan en cuidados paliativos poseen comportamientos de apego que se identifican como naturales en ese contexto, lo que acaba dificultando la percepción de que suponen importantes contribuciones para la prevención del duelo complicado en la unidad de cuidado. Ante estos resultados, la presente investigación destacó la relevancia de la necesidad de incluir las temáticas muerte y morir en la educación de los profesionales de salud, lo que puede contribuir a una mejor asistencia a la unidad de cuidado en sus procesos de luto....(AU)

Unresolved Bereavement and Other Mental Health Problems in Parents of the Sewol Ferry Accident after 18 Months

OBJECTIVE: This study examined the overall mental health consequences of the bereaved parents after the Sewol ferry accident. METHODS: Eighty-four bereaved parents participated in the study. Self-report scales assessing the severity of psychiatric symptoms and other related psychosomatic problems were used at 18 months following the accident. Univariate descriptive statistics and regression analyses were performed to report the prevalence, severity, and correlates of psychiatric symptoms. RESULTS: 94% of the participants appeared to suffer from complicated grief based on scores on the Inventory of Complicated Grief (ICG). Half of the participants were categorized as having severe depression and 70.2% reported clinically significant post-traumatic symptoms according to scores on the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) and PTSD Check List-5 (PCL-5). No significant differences by gender were observed in the severity of psychiatric symptoms. A higher educational level was associated with more severe psychiatric symptoms in fathers. CONCLUSION: The loss of a child due to a disaster caused by human error may continue to have a substantial impact on parental mental health at 18 months after the event. A longitudinal study following parents' mental health state would be necessary to investigate the long-term effects of the traumatic experience in the future.

Korean Version of Inventory of Complicated Grief Scale: Psychometric Properties in Korean Adolescents

We aimed to validate the Inventory of Complicated Grief (ICG)-Korean version among 1,138 Korean adolescents, representing a response rate of 57% of 1,997 students. Participants completed a set of questionnaires including demographic variables (age, sex, years of education, experience of grief), the ICG, the Children's Depression Inventory (CDI) and the Lifetime Incidence of Traumatic Events-Child (LITE-C). Exploratory factor analysis was performed to determine whether the ICG items indicated complicated grief in Korean adolescents. The internal consistency of the ICG-Korean version was Cronbach's alpha=0.87. The test-retest reliability for a randomly selected sample of 314 participants in 2 weeks was r=0.75 (P<0.001). Concurrent validity was assessed using a correlation between the ICG total scores and the CDI total scores (r=0.75, P<0.001). The criterion-related validity based on the comparison of ICG total scores between adolescents without complicated grief (1.2±3.7) and adolescent with complicated grief (3.2±6.6) groups was relatively high (t=5.71, P<0.001). The data acquired from the 1,138 students was acceptable for a factor analysis (Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of Sampling Adequacy=0.911; Bartlett's Test of Sphericity, chi2=13,144.7, P<0.001). After omission of 3 items, the value of Cronbach's alpha increased from 0.87 for the 19-item ICG-Korean version to 0.93 for the 16-item ICG-Korean version. These results suggest that the ICG is a useful tool in assessing for complicated grief in Korean adolescents. However, the 16-item version of the ICG appeared to be more valid compared to the 19-item version of the ICG. We suggest that the 16-item version of the ICG be used to screen for complicated grief in Korean adolescents.

Effects of Satisfaction with Social Support on Complicated Grief in Bereaved Dementia Caregivers

BACKGROUND: While complicated grief can lead to adverse health outcomes, social support has been shown to be an important protective factor of its negative effects. The present study investigated the relationship between social support including satisfaction with support, received support, and negative interactions and complicated grief in the transitional context from caregiving to bereavement. METHODS: Bereaved caregivers (n=221) who participated in a multi-site study of dementia caregiving were assessed for complicated grief. Social support measured before and after death were used to examine the longitudinal associations among social support and complicated grief. RESULTS: We found that caregivers reporting greater increase in satisfaction with social support were likely to experience lower levels of complicated grief, while the amount of received social support did not significantly impact complicated grief. Negative social interaction was significantly associated with the level of complicated grief after the death of the care recipient. CONCLUSIONS: The relationship between social support and complicated grief suggests that satisfaction with social support may be associated with lower levels of complicated grief. Study findings point to the importance of the type of social support for reducing the level of complicated grief.

Effects of Satisfaction with Social Support on Complicated Grief in Bereaved Dementia Caregivers

BACKGROUND: While complicated grief can lead to adverse health outcomes, social support has been shown to be an important protective factor of its negative effects. The present study investigated the relationship between social support including satisfaction with support, received support, and negative interactions and complicated grief in the transitional context from caregiving to bereavement. METHODS: Bereaved caregivers (n=221) who participated in a multi-site study of dementia caregiving were assessed for complicated grief. Social support measured before and after death were used to examine the longitudinal associations among social support and complicated grief. RESULTS: We found that caregivers reporting greater increase in satisfaction with social support were likely to experience lower levels of complicated grief, while the amount of received social support did not significantly impact complicated grief. Negative social interaction was significantly associated with the level of complicated grief after the death of the care recipient. CONCLUSIONS: The relationship between social support and complicated grief suggests that satisfaction with social support may be associated with lower levels of complicated grief. Study findings point to the importance of the type of social support for reducing the level of complicated grief.

Effects of Satisfaction with Social Support on Complicated Grief in Bereaved Dementia Caregivers

BACKGROUND: While complicated grief can lead to adverse health outcomes, social support has been shown to be an important protective factor of its negative effects. The present study investigated the relationship between social support including satisfaction with support, received support, and negative interactions and complicated grief in the transitional context from caregiving to bereavement. METHODS: Bereaved caregivers (n=221) who participated in a multi-site study of dementia caregiving were assessed for complicated grief. Social support measured before and after death were used to examine the longitudinal associations among social support and complicated grief. RESULTS: We found that caregivers reporting greater increase in satisfaction with social support were likely to experience lower levels of complicated grief, while the amount of received social support did not significantly impact complicated grief. Negative social interaction was significantly associated with the level of complicated grief after the death of the care recipient. CONCLUSIONS: The relationship between social support and complicated grief suggests that satisfaction with social support may be associated with lower levels of complicated grief. Study findings point to the importance of the type of social support for reducing the level of complicated grief.

Complicated grief, depressive symptoms, and suicidial ideation among the bereaved whose family member died at palliative care units

<b>Objectives</b>: The aim of this study is to explore prevalence and determinants of complicated grief, depressive symptoms, and suicide ideation among the relatives whose family members died in palliative care units. <b>Methods</b>: A multicenter questionnaire survey was conducted on a sample of bereaved family members of cancer patients who were admitted to palliative care units in Japan. Participants completed self-report questionnaire including the Center for Epidemiologic Study Depression Scale (CES-D), Inventory of Traumatic Grief (ITG), the item concerning suicide ideation, Care Evaluation Scale (CES), and Good Death Inventory (GDI). <b>Results</b>: Of the 653 questionnaires sent to bereaved family members, 451 responses were analyzed (response rate: 67%). The results showed 10 (2.3%) respondents with complicated grief and 153 (43.8%) with depressive symptoms. Suicide ideation was appeared among 52 (11.9%) respondents. Multiple regression analysis revealed that ITG was signicicantly associated with both CES and GDI. Patiens' age at death and pre-bereavement health contributed to the suicide ideation of the bereaved family members. <b>Conclusion</b>: The prevalence of complicated grief and depressive symptoms among the relatives whose family members died in palliative care units were 2.3% and 43.8%, respectively. The rates of suicide ideation was 11.9% of respondents. The results suggested that the evaluations about structure and process of palliative care, and quality of death contribute to better adjustment of the bereaved.