ABSTRACT
El objetivo del presente estudio fue analizar las características sociodemográficas, metodológicas y diagnósticas de los informes periciales en psiquiatría y psicología realizados en el Centro de Estudios en Derecho y Salud entre 2011 y 2020. Se optó por un enfoque cuantitativo, descriptivo con intención analítica, transversal, con diseño retrospectivo. Se analizó la información obtenida en 145 peritajes. Se adelantó un análisis univariado para todas las variables sociodemográficas, metodológicas y diagnósticas de los informes periciales, según su naturaleza cualitativa o cuantitativa, y un análisis bivariado a través de tablas de contingencia para las variables mencionadas, con intervalos de confianza del 95 % para cada una de las medidas de prevalencia. Se encontró que la mayoría de peritajes fueron solicitados por el área del derecho contencioso-administrativo. Los diagnósticos más prevalentes fueron el trastorno adaptativo, el trastorno por estrés postraumático y el trastorno depresivo. Si bien los informes revisados cumplen con los lineamientos mínimos de ley, se encontraron algunas falencias relacionadas con la ausencia de información. Se espera que estos hallazgos permitan la reflexión por parte de los auxiliares de la justicia sobre los requerimientos de los informes periciales con miras a la humanización de la justicia y el apoyo a la toma de decisiones legales.
The aim of this study was to analyse the socio-demographic, methodological and diagnostic characteristics of the expert reports in psychiatry and psychology carried out at the Centre for Law and Health Studies between 2011 and 2020. We opted for a quantitative, descriptive approach with analytical, cross-sectional, retrospective design. The information obtained from 145 expert opinions was analysed. A univariate analysis was carried out for all sociodemographic, methodological and diagnostic variables in the expert reports, according to their qualitative or quantitative nature, and a bivariate analysis through contingency tables for the aforementioned variables, with confidence intervals of 95 % for each of the prevalence measures. It was found that the majority of expert opinions were requested by the area of contentious-administrative law. The most prevalent diagnoses were adjustment disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder and depressive disorder. Although the reports reviewed comply with the minimum legal guidelines, there were some shortcomings related to the absence of information. It is hoped that these findings will allow for reflection on the part of justice officials on the requirements of expert reports with a view to the humanisation of justice and support for legal decision-making.
O objetivo deste estudo foi analisar as características sociodemográficas, metodológicas e diagnósticas dos laudos periciais em psiquiatria e psicologia realizados no Centro de Estudos em Direito e Saúde entre 2011 e 2020. Optou-se por uma abordagem quantitativa e descritiva com desenho analítico, transversal e retrospectivo. Foram analisadas as informações obtidas de 145 pareceres de especialistas. Foi realizada uma análise univariada para todas as variáveis sociodemográficas, metodológicas e diagnósticas dos laudos periciais, de acordo com sua natureza qualitativa ou quantitativa, e uma análise bivariada por meio de tabelas de contingência para as variáveis mencionadas, com intervalos de confiança de 95 % para cada uma das medidas de prevalência. Verificou-se que a maioria dos pareceres foi solicitada pela área de direito contencioso-administrativo. Os diagnósticos mais prevalentes foram transtorno de ajustamento, transtorno de estresse pós-traumático e transtorno depressivo. Embora os relatórios analisados estejam em conformidade com as diretrizes legais mínimas, houve algumas deficiências relacionadas à ausência de informações. Espera-se que esses resultados permitam uma reflexão por parte dos envolvidos no sistema judiciário sobre os requisitos dos laudos periciais, com vistas à humanização da justiça e ao apoio à tomada de decisões legais.
Subject(s)
HumansABSTRACT
RESUMEN A partir de una revisión bibliográfica de la literatura se ha planeado y desarrollado un consenso de expertos internacionales sobre la utilización de las vitaminas B1, B6, B12 en sus déficits y en la neuropatía periférica que puede estar asociada a la misma, como tema que precia de esa aproximación aclaratoria para optimizar su manejo. Se plantearon varias cuestiones de discusión que se consideraron importantes y dignas de ser abordadas y aclaradas, conservando nueve de ellas para su discusión ulterior buscando el consenso en tres rondas consecutivas. Se han propuesto 41 recomendaciones sobre el manejo de estas condiciones, con unanimidad por parte de los participantes en el consenso. Con ellas se ha intentado aclarar puntos oscuros o controvertidos, facilitando la actitud del clínico ante ellos en la práctica médica actual.
ABSTRACT Based on a bibliographic review of the literature, a consensus of international experts has been carried out on the use of vitamins B1, B6, B12, in their deficiencies, and in the peripheral neuropathy that may be associated with them, to optimize the management of these conditions. Several questions considered important and worthy of being addressed and clarified were raised, retaining nine of them for further discussion to achieve consensus. Forty one recommendations on the management of these conditions have been proposed, with unanimity of the participants in the consensus. This has been an attempt to clarify controversial points, assisting the clinician's attitude in current medical practice.
ABSTRACT
ObjectiveTo explore the current status and issues regarding the application of ancient books in clinical practice guidelines and expert consensus of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） published in China， and to provide methodological recommendations for the incorporation of ancient books in the development of TCM guidelines. MethodsWe searched China National Knowledge Infrastructure （CNKI）， WanFang Data， VIP， SinoMed， PubMed， Embase， as well as six industry websites including China Association of Chinese Medicine， National Group Standards Information Platform， and Chinese Association of the Integration of Traditional and Western Medicine，etc. TCM clinical practice guidelines or expert consensus issued during January 1st， 2017， to November 26th， 2022 were searched. Clinical practice guidelines or expert consensus that explicitly referred to ancient books were included， and the content regarding the searching for ancient books， sources of access to ancient books， methods of evaluating the level of evidence， methods of evaluating the level of recommendation， and methods of evaluating the evidence for the ancient books were analysed. ResultsA total of 1,215 TCM clinical practice guidelines or expert consensus were retrieved， with 442 articles explicitly mentioning the application of ancient books， including 300 （67.87%） clinical practice guidelines and 142 （32.13%） expert consensus. Sixty of the 442 publications explicitly reported that ancient books searching had been conducted （13.57%）； among these 60 publications 27 （45.00%） explicitly reported ancient books searching strategies， and the most frequent method was manual searching with a total of 24 articles （40.00%）. The most popular search source was Chinese Medical Dictionary， a TCM classics database， with a total of 18 articles. 197 articles （44.57%） explicitly reported the evaluation criteria for the level of evidence， of which 141 articles （71.57%） involved the evaluation criteria for the ancient books； 413 articles （93.44%） mentioned ancient books in the recommendations， and only the source of formula name was mentioned in 409 （99.03%） of the publications. ConclusionThe current application of ancient books in TCM clinical practice guidelines and expert consensus is limited， with issues of non-standard searching and evaluation methods. Standar-dization and uniformity are needed in evidence grading and recommendation standards. Future research should clarify the scope and methods of applying ancient book， emphasize their integration with modern research evidence， and enhance their value and quality in the development of TCM clinical practice guidelines.
ABSTRACT
Unexpected red blood cell antibodies refer to antibodies except for anti-A and anti-B in normal ABO blood group, and are widely present in patients with pregnancy, transfusion, transplantation, injection of immunogenic substances, or autoimmune diseases, leading to difficulties in blood type identification and cross matching test, which seriously affect transfusion safety and efficacy. This consensus aims to further standardize the requirements, operating procedures and clinical significance of antibody screening, thus improving the safety and efficacy of blood transfusion.
ABSTRACT
The Asian expert working group completed the 2022 consensus on vernal keratitis (VKC), which provides detailed information on the definition, classification, clinical manifestation, diagnosis and treatment of VKC in Asia and identifies unmet treatment needs, including: (1) lack of clear criteria for the diagnosis and treatment of patients with VKC.The pathogenesis of the disease is unclear, and anti-allergy therapy is often ineffective in patients with moderate or severe VKC; (2) the need for standardized treatment and management strategies.Treatment and management of patients with the same severity varies widely among Asian countries, with a lack of clear, standardized guidelines and grading systems; (3) safety and iatrogenic complications; (4) optimal dosing regimen for pharmacologic treatment.In this article, the aspects mentioned above were interpreted and analyzed in the context of the Expert Consensus on the Diagnosis and Treatment of Allergic Conjunctivitis in China ( 2018), with a view to helping the prevention and treatment of VKC in China.
ABSTRACT
Objective To establish the argatroban drug use evaluation(DUE)criteria and provide reference for the rational use of argatroban in clinical practice.Methods Based on the domestic and foreign drug instructions of argatroban,referring to relevant guidelines and literature,the DUE standard rules were established by expert consultation.Using the established standard rules,the medical records of argatroban in the Fuzhou First Hospital Affiliated with Fujian Medical University from August 2020 to August 2022 were evaluated for the rationality of medication.Results A total of 368 medical records were included,the rational rate of drug use was 48.64％,and the irrational drug use was mainly without indications(46.19％)and inappropriate combination of drugs(4.35％).Conclusion The rational rate of argatroban clinical use in the hospital is not high,and the problems mainly include off-indication drug use and unreasonable combination drug use.Through the establishment and clinical application of DUE standard rules,the clinical use of argatroban can be further standardized and the ability of rational drug use can be improved.
ABSTRACT
Objective To establish the drug use evaluation(DUE)standard of fibrinogenase for injection and provide a reference for the rational clinical application of fibrinogenase for injection.Methods Based on the specification of fibrinogenase for injection,the DUE standard was established from three aspects:drug indication,drug process and drug results,with reference to relevant guidelines and literature,and through discussion with clinical experts.A retrospective survey was conducted to evaluate the inpatients using fibrinogenase for injection from January 2021 to December 2021 in Ningde Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine,Fujian Province.Results A total of 256 patients were included,with a medication reasonable rate of 61.72％.The irrational use of drugs was mainly including the inappropriate usage and dosage(3.91％),off-label medication(1.95％),no skin test(8.98％),too long or inadequate course of medication(25.00％).Conclusion The DUE standard established of fibrinogenase for injection is scientific,practical and feasible.The use of fibrinogenase for injection in contraindications and high blood coagulation state,and off-label medication can be further optimized.
ABSTRACT
The Chinese Journal of Interventional Cardiology,Volume 31,Issue 6,published the Chinese expert consensus on the clinical application of drug coated balloon(2nd Edition)in June 2023.The new consensus incorporates the evidence-based medicine evidence of drug-coated balloons in the field of interventional therapy for coronary heart disease in recent years,updating the indications,standardized operations,intracoronary imaging,and the application of coronary functional studies in the treatment of drug-coated balloons.Based on clinical diagnosis and treatment practices and evidence-based medicine evidence,this article interprets the highlights of the new guidelines,aiming to provide references for clinical practice.
ABSTRACT
Scrub typhus is a type of natural focal disease caused by a bacteria called Orientia tsutsugamushi and mainly en-demic in East and Southeast Asia.The most common clinical symptoms of scrub typhus include fever,eschar,ulcer,lymph node enlargement and rash,which are not typical on early stage and could easily lead to misdiagnosis and missed diagnosis.By reviewing relevant guidelines and references at home and abroad,combining clinical diagnosis and treatment experiences in Chi-na,the experts from Biodiagnostic Technology Branch of China Medical Biotechnology Association and Chinese Society of Mi-crobiology Committee on Zoonotic Pathogens formed this consensus on the clinical diagnosis and treatment of scrub typhus.
ABSTRACT
In recent years， the incidence of pulmonary nodules has kept rising. To give full play to the advantages of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） in the treatment of pulmonary nodules and identify the breakthrough points of integrating TCM with Western medicine， the China Association of Chinese Medicine organized medical experts in TCM and western medicine to carry out in-depth discussion regarding this disease. The discussion encompassed the modern medical advances， TCM theories of etiology and pathogenesis， the role and advantages of TCM in the whole course management of pulmonary nodules， contents and methods of research on pulmonary nodules， and science popularization work， aiming to provide a reference for clinical practice and scientific research. After discussion， the experts concluded that the occurrence of pulmonary nodules was rooted in the deficiency of the lung and spleen and triggered by phlegm dampness， blood stasis， and Qi stagnation. TCM can treat pulmonary nodules by controlling and reducing nodules， improving physical constitution， ameliorating multi-system nodular diseases， reducing anxiety and avoiding excessive diagnosis and treatment， and serving as an alternative for patients who are unwilling or unfit for surgical treatment. At present， the optimal diagnosis and treatment strategy for pulmonary nodules has not been formed， which needs to be further studied from multiple perspectives such as clinical epidemiology， biology， and evidence-based medicine. The primary task of current research is to find out the advantages， effective prescriptions， and target populations and determine the effective outcomes of TCM in the treatment of pulmonary nodules. At the same time， basic research should be carried out to explore the etiology and biological behaviors of pulmonary nodules. The expert consensus on the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary nodules with integrated TCM and Western medicine needs to be continuously revised to guide clinicians to conduct standardized， scientific， and accurate effective diagnosis and treatment.
ABSTRACT
@#OBJECTIVE To provide reference for guiding the individualized drug therapy management of imatinib for gastrointestinal stromal tumor （GIST）， with the goal of enhancing patient survival rates and improving their quality of life. METHODS Using a nominal group technique， a multidisciplinary （clinical， pharmaceutical and evidence-based） expert panel was formed to create the Consensus of Chinese Experts on Individualized Medication Management of Imatinib for Gastrointestinal Stromal Tumors outline through joint discussions. The expert panel conducted systematic retrieval， analysis， and summarization of the outline’s content， and reached relevant consensus based on China’s current situation， clinical needs， and research evidence. An external expert panel was also formed， comprising experienced multidisciplinary experts in clinical practice. Delphi method questionnaire was employed to openly collect the external experts’ opinions， which were then organized， summarized， analyzed， provided with feedback， revised， and finally formed into a consensus. RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS The drafting of this consensus included the clinical application of imatinib in neoadjuvant therapy for GIST patients， adjuvant therapy for adult patients with significant risk of recurrence after surgical resection， and drug therapy for patients with recurrent， metastatic， or unresectable tumors； pharmaceutical monitoring and long-term medication management. This consensus provides standardized processes and methods for medical institutions in individualized drug therapy management for GIST patients and holds significant importance in improving the clinical efficacy of imatinib and ensuring drug safety.
ABSTRACT
Cryoablation therapy with explicit anti-tumor mechanisms and histopathological manifestations has a long history.A large number of clinical practice has shown that cryoablation therapy is safe and effective,making it an ideal tumor treatment method in theory.Previously,its efficacy and clinical application were constrained by the limitations of refrigerants and refrigeration equipment.With the development of the new generation of cryoablation equipment represented by argon helium knives,significant progress has been made in refrigeration efficien-cy,ablation range,and precise temperature measurement,greatly promoting the progression of tumor cryoablation technology.This consensus systematically summarizes the mechanism of cryoablation technology,indications for oral mucosal melanoma(OMM)cryotherapy,clinical treatment process,adverse reactions and management,cryotherapy combination therapy,etc.,aiming to provide reference for carrying out the standardized cryoablation therapy of OMM.
ABSTRACT
In the field of dental aesthetics,digital aesthetic design plays a crucial role in helping dentists to predict treatment outcomes vis-ually,as well as in enhancing the consistency of knowledge and understanding of aesthetic goals between dentists and patients.It serves as the foundation for achieving ideal aesthetic effects.However,there is no clear standard for this digital process currently in China and abroad.Many dentists lack of systematic understanding of how to carry out digital aesthetic design for treatment.To establish standardized processes for dental aesthetic design and to improve the homogeneity of treatment outcomes,Chinese Society of Digital Dental Industry(CSD-DI)convened domestic experts in related field to compile this consensus.This article elaborates on the key aspects of digital aesthetic data collection,integration steps,and the digital aesthetic design process.It also formulates a decision tree for dental aesthetics at macro level and outlines corresponding workflows for various clinical scenarios,serving as a reference for clinicians.
ABSTRACT
The procurement demonstration process for large-scale medical equipment is a time-intensive and laborious system project,necessitating more effective methods to enhance efficiency.This study introduces a fuzzy decision-making expert system to optimize the procurement process of medical equipment for large hospitals,thereby elevating procurement efficiency and lowering costs.Firstly,an expert database is established using a natural language fuzzy preference scoring method tailored to the characteristics of the hospital's experts.Secondly,weights are assigned to expert decisions,and both subjective and objective in-dices describing equipment characteristics are developed.Lastly,a discriminant function is constructed for decision-making.An application analysis of a particular procurement process yielded a series of rational outcomes based on the overall design,data configuration,and discriminant function.The decisions proposed by the scheme and validated through on-site demonstration and comprehensive assessment,are deemed appropriate.This method has proven to some degree its potential to enhance the efficiency of medical equipment procurement and reduce costs,warranting further research.
ABSTRACT
At present， there is no consensus on the diagnosis， treatment， and management of pulmonary nodules with integrated traditional Chinese and Western Medicine in China. To establish the clinical management strategy of pulmonary nodules with integrated medicine， a consensus was formed after full discussion by the experts from the Cancer Committee of Chinese Association of Integrative Medicine and the Cancer Committee of Beijing Association of Chinese Medicine according to the guidelines for pulmonary nodules issued in recent years and the clinical practice of multiple hospitals in the treatment of cancers with integrated Chinese and Western medicine. This consensus involves the existing clinical management guidelines of pulmonary nodules and the intervention methods of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM）. Considering the therapeutic positioning and value of TCM， this consensus standardizes the whole-process management of pulmonary nodules with integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine， which will help more patients.
ABSTRACT
Fibromyalgia syndrome （FMS） is a refractory， chronic non-articular rheumatic disease characterized by widespread pain throughout the body， for which there are no satisfactory therapeutic drugs or options. There are rich Chinese medical therapies， and some non-drug therapies， such as acupuncture， Tai Chi， and Ba-Duan-Jin， have shown satisfactory efficacy and safety and definite advantages of simultaneously adjusting mind and body. FMS is taken as a disease responding specifically to traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） by the National Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine in 2018. In order to clarify the research progress in FMS and the clinical advantages of TCM/integrated Chinese and Western medicine， the China Academy of Chinese Medicine organized a seminar for nearly 20 experts in Chinese and Western medicine， including rheumatology， psychology， acupuncture and moxibustion， and encephalopathy， with the topic of difficulties in clinical diagnosis and treatment of FMS and advantages of TCM and Western medicine. The recommendations were reached on the difficulties in early diagnosis and solutions of FMS， mitigation of common non-specific symptoms， preferential analgesic therapy， TCM pathogenesis and treatment advantages， and direction of treatment with integrated Chinese and Western medicine. FMS is currently facing the triple dilemma of low early correct diagnosis， poor patient participation， and unsatisfactory benefit from pure Western medicine treatment. To solve the above problems， this paper suggests that rheumatologists should serve as the main diagnostic force of this disease， and they should improve patient participation in treatment decision-making， implement exercise therapy， and fully utilize the holistic and multidimensional features of TCM， which is effective in alleviating pain， improving mood， and decreasing adverse events. In addition， it is suggested that FMS treatment should rely on both TCM and Western medicine and adopt multidisciplinary joint treatment， which is expected to improve the standard of diagnosis and treatment of FMS in China.
ABSTRACT
Recommendation formation is a key component of clinical practice guidelines for Chinese patent medicine （CPM）， and should encompass the determination of the strength and direction of the recommendation， the rationale for the recommendation， and the methodology for implementing the recommendation. Recommendations can be formed through formal consensus and informal consensus. The strength and direction of recommendations for CPM guidelines should be determined by considering the quality of evidence for CPMs， the priority of the clinical questions， the pros and cons of efficacy and adverse effects， patient acceptance， the feasibility of the recommendation and the availability of resources， social fairness， economic benefits， and other influencing factors. In order to better guide guideline developers to consider these factors more rationally， this article provideed a detailed explanation of each factor in the context of the characteristics of TCM.
ABSTRACT
ObjectiveTo evaluate the methodological and reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines for Chinese patent medicine （CPM） with internationally recognized tools the appraisal of guidelines for research and evaluation （AGEREE） Ⅱ and reporting items for practice guidelines in healthcare （RIGHT）， thereby providing refe-rence for the clinical application and future development of CPM guidelines. MethodsDatabases including CNKI， VIP， Wanfang and Sinomed were searched for CPM guidelines， as well as medlive.cn， websites of China Association of Chinese Medicine and Chinese Medical Association， and reference lists of the included papers. The quality of the guidelines was evaluated using the AGREE Ⅱand RIGHT tools， and consistency tests were performed using Interclass Correlation Coefficient， and descriptive analysis and chi-square test were used to analyze the reporting rate for each domain and the average score for each item. ResultsFinally， 140 CPM guidelines were included， of which 51 were disease-oriented and 89 were drug-oriented， all of which were issued by China. For 51 disease-oriented CPM guidelines， the highest average score of all six AGREE Ⅱ domains was 73.32% for clarity， and the lowest was 26.80% for application； for 89 drug-oriented CPM guidelines， the highest average score was 55.62% for scope and purpose， and the lowest was 31.32% for rigour of development. In terms of the seven domains of the RIGHT checklist， the highest reporting rate was 68.26% for background， and lowest was 27.45% for other areas regarding the disease-oriented CPM guidelines； the highest reporting rate was 61.31% for background， and the lowest was 4.49% for other areas regarding drug-oriented CPM guidelines. The average reporting rate was higher for disease-oriented than drug-oriented CPM guidelines in three domains of AGREE Ⅱ （rigour of development， clarity of presentation， editorial independence）， as well as four domains of RIGHT checklist （basic information， evidence， funding and declaration and management of interests， and other areas）. ConclusionThe overall methodology and reporting quality of the current CPM guidelines still need to be improved. It is recommended that future guideline development teams should strictly refer to the AGREE Ⅱ and RIGHT checklist， and take into account of the characteristics of CPM guidelines and relevant methodo-logical suggestions in the development and reporting of CPM guidelines， thereby guiding the clinical use of CPM in a better way.
ABSTRACT
@# In recent years, the number of lung surgeries has increased year by year, and the number of patients with postoperative cough has also increased gradually. Chronic cough after lung surgery seriously affects patients' quality of life and surgical outcome, and has become one of the clinical problems that clinicians need to solve. However, there is currently no guideline or consensus for the treatment of chronic cough after lung surgery in China, and there is no standardized treatment method. Therefore, we searched databases such as PubMed, Web of Science, CNKI, and Wanfang databases ect. from 2000 to 2023 to collected relevant literatures and research data, and produced the first expert consensus on chronic cough after lung surgery in China by Delphi method. We gave 11 recommendations from five perspectives including timing of chronic cough treatment, risk factors (surgical method, lymph node dissection method, anesthesia method), prevention methods (preoperative, intraoperative, postoperative), and treatment methods (etiological treatment, cough suppressive drug treatment, traditional Chinese medicine treatment, and postoperative physical therapy). We hope that this consensus can improve the standardization and effectiveness of chronic cough treatment after lung surgery, provide reference for clinical doctors, and ultimately improve the quality of life of patients with chronic cough after lung surgery.
ABSTRACT
Threatened abortion is a common disease of obstetrics and gynecology and one of the diseases responding specifically to traditional Chinese medicine （TCM）. The China Association of Chinese Medicine organized experts in TCM obstetrics and gynecology， Western medicine obstetrics and gynecology， and pharmacology to deeply discuss the advantages of TCM and integrated Chinese and Western medicine treatment as well as the medication plans for threatened abortion. After discussion， the experts concluded that chromosome， endocrine， and immune abnormalities were the key factors for the occurrence of threatened abortion， and the Qi and blood disorders in thoroughfare and conception vessels were the core pathogenesis. In the treatment of threatened abortion， TCM has advantages in preventing miscarriages， alleviating clinical symptoms and TCM syndromes， relieving anxiety， regulating reproductive endocrine and immune abnormalities， personalized and diversified treatment， enhancing efficiency and reducing toxicity， and preventing the disease before occurrence. The difficulty in diagnosis and treatment of threatened abortion with traditional Chinese and Western medicine lies in identifying the predictors of abortion caused by maternal factors and the treatment of thrombophilia. Recurrent abortion is the breakthrough point of treatment with integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine. It is urgent to carry out high-quality evidence-based medicine research in the future to improve the modern diagnosis and treatment of threatened abortion with TCM.