Comparison of lcp and intramedullary nail osteosynthesis in calcaneal fractures / Comparação entre placa de osteossíntese e haste intramedular em fratura do calcâneo

ABSTRACT Objective: This study compared groups of patients with calcaneal fractures of Sanders types II and III. One group was treated with ORIF using an LCP (plate), while the second was treated with a minimally invasive method using a C-Nail. Methods: The study included 217 patients in the ORIF group and 19 patients in the minimally invasive nail osteosynthesis group. Results: In the LCP group, the outcomes were excellent for 35.7% of the patients; good, 38.9%; satisfactory, 19.7%; and poor, 5.7%. In the C-Nail group, the outcomes were excellent for 36.9% of the patients; good; 31.6%; satisfactory, 21%; and poor, 10.2%. The mean values of the restoration of Böhler's angle from post-injury were 6.8° to 32.3° in the LCP group and 7.1° to 33.3° in the C-Nail group. After 12 months, there was only a minimal decrease in Böhler's angle to 29.2° in both the LCP and C-Nail groups. Conclusion: The outcomes obtained with C-Nail fixation are statistically identical to those obtained with LCP fixation. We conclude that osteosynthesis with a C-Nail is suitable as the first-choice treatment for Sanders types II and III fractures. Level of evidence IV, retrospective observational study.

RESUMO Objetivo: Comparar grupos de pacientes com fratura intra-articular do calcâneo tipos II e III de Sanders. Métodos: Estudo retrospectivo que incluiu 217 pacientes no grupo tratado por redução aberta e fixação interna com placa de compressão (Grupo PC) e 19 pacientes que seguiram um método minimamente invasivo com C-Nail. Resultados: No Grupo PC, os resultados foram excelentes em 35,7%, bons em 38,9%, satisfatórios em 19,17% e ruins em 5,7%. Os resultados registados no grupo que recebeu implante de unha foram excelentes em 36,9%, bons em 31,6%, satisfatórios em 21% e ruins em 10,2% Os valores médios do restauro do ângulo de Böhler desde o pós-ferimento variaram entre 6,8° e 32,3°, no Grupo PC, e entre 7,1° e 33,3°, no grupo tratado com C-Nail. Ao fim de 12 meses, apenas se observou redução mínima do ângulo de Böhler para 29,2° nos dois grupos. Conclusão: Os resultados do método recentemente introduzido de osteossíntese minimamente invasiva com C-Nail são estatisticamente idênticos aos obtidos pela redução aberta e fixação interna com placa de compressão. Assim, o novo tipo de osteossíntese com C-Nail é adequado como primeira escolha em fraturas do tipo Sanders II e III. Nível de evidência IV, Estudo retrospectivo de observação.

The value of the calcaneal tubercle joint angle measurement in the joint surface after calcaneal fractures / 中国基层医药

Objective To explore the surgical treatment of intra -articular calcaneal fractures with bone nodules joint angle in the preoperative and intraoperative evaluation of prognosis of postoperative analysis.Methods 22 cases of affected joint surface after calcaneal fractures,open reduction and internal fixation with steel plate in the operation treatment.Used Sanders classification:preoperative,intraoperative,postoperative again calcaneal tubercle joint angle measurement.According to the Maryland foot scoring system to evaluate postoperative effect.Results All patients were followed up for 8 to 20 months.The excellent and good rate of the patients was 90%,the postoperative complications:heel broadening,subtalar arthritis in 2 cases,poor healing in 2 cases (after the treatment and healing). Conclusion It has high value of the calcaneal tubercle joint angle measurement in the joint surface after calcaneal fractures.