ABSTRACT
Objective:To compare the curative efficacy in the treatment of humeral surgical neck fractures between open reduction and locking plating versus closed reduction and interlocking intramedullary nailing.Methods:From July 2018 to July 2020, 60 patients with humeral surgical neck fracture were treated at Department of Orthorpaedic Trauma, Jiangmen Wuyi Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine. They were 24 males and 36 females, aged from 40 to 70 years and injured at the left side in 35 cases and at the right side in 25 ones. Of them, 30 underwent open reduction and locking plating (open group) and the other 30 closed reduction and interlocking intramedullary nailing (closed group). The 2 groups were compared in terms of operation time, intraoperative blood loss, surgical incision length, fracture healing time, Neer shoulder function scoring 3 months after surgery, and postoperative complications.Results:There were no statistically significant differences between the open and closed groups in preoperative general data, showing they were comparable ( P>0.05). The length of surgical incision [(5.2±1.1) cm], operation time [(34.3±12.7) min], intraoperative blood loss [(52.5±7.3) mL] and fracture healing time [(9.2±1.5) weeks] in the closed group were significantly better than those in the open group [(11.1±2.5) cm, (69.4±21.4) min, (123.5±5.2) mL and (14.2±3.4) weeks)] ( P<0.05). The excellent and good rate by Neer shoulder function scoring at 3 months after operation in the closed group (93.3%, 28/30) was significantly higher than that in the open group (66.7%, 20/30) ( P<0.05). There were no postoperative complications in either group. Conclusion:In the treatment of humeral surgical neck fractures, the curative efficacy of closed reduction and interlocking intramedullary nailing is better than that of open reduction and locking plating.
ABSTRACT
Objective To summarize the methods and results of treatment of displaced humeral su rgical neck fractures with closed reductio n and percutaneous pin fixation.Methods We reviewed 46patients who had been diagnosed as the displaced hume ral surgical neck fractures and trea ted with closed reduction and percut aneous pin fixation using?2.5mm Kirschner wire with terminal t hread from January 2001to December 2002in our hospital.Results34patients received a complete follow-up.The mean follow-up time was 22months(10to 34months).Evaluation was done with Constant-M urley rating system.The mean absolu te Constant-Murley score was 92(76～100).86%(29/34)of the cases were excellent or good,14%(5/34)were fair,and none were poor.All the fractures united 6to 8weeks after operation,a nd no fixation failure or humeral hea d necrosis was found.Conclusion Treatment of displaced humeral surg ical neck fractures with closed reduction and percutaneous pin fixation can shorten operation time,lead to minimal soft tissue lesion and reliable fixation,and allow early functional exercis e after op-eration and easy removal of the wire. [