High-Intensity Zone on L-spine MRI: Clinical Relevance and Association with Trauma History

STUDY DESIGN: This is a retrospective study. PURPOSE: We wanted to investigate the clinical relevance of the lumbar high intensity zone (HIZ) on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and the relationship of trauma history to internal disc disruption (IDD). OVERVIEW OF LITERATURE: HIZs on lumbar spine (L-spine) MRI have been suggested as a reliable marker of IDD by some authors. The prevalence and type of spinal trauma in IDD have not yet been carefully analyzed. METHODS: L-spine MRIs of 737 patients with low back pain with or without associated leg pain were reviewed for the presence of HIZs. HIZs on T2-weighted MR images were determined according to the Aprill and Bogduk criteria. A review of medical records and a telephone interview were performed for further analyses of pain. RESULTS: HIZs were found in 117 patients and 153 discs among a total of 737 patients who met the inclusion criteria. Both a medical record review and a telephone interview were possible with 99 patients. Among these, 42 patients had had an episode of trauma. Seventeen of these had a relatively high-energy injury such as a traffic accident or a fall. Regarding back pain, 27 patients complained of typical discogenic back pain. Only 11 patients had both a trauma history and typical discogenic pain and 41 patients (42%) had neither a trauma history nor typical natural pain. CONCLUSIONS: Given the low incidence of discogenic pain, a HIZ on an L-spine MRI appears less meaningful than often assumed as a specific marker of IDD. Trauma, such as a traffic accident, seems unlikely to be the main cause of IDD.

The diagnosis of internal disc disruption with CT discography / 介入放射学杂志

Objective To study the value of diagnosis for internal disc disruption(IDD)with CT discography(CTD).Methods 42 discs of 32 patients showing no disc herniation on CT or MRI,but suffering from chronic low back pain,were undertaken CTD to work out the types of CTD with correlation between contrast medium dosages and the induction of pain.Results CTD demonstrated 4 types of IDD which was individually correlated with the contrast dosages and induced pain.furthermore the dosages for positive and negative disc cases showed significant differece(P

Nerve Ingrowth into Intervertebral Disc in Internal Disc Disruption / 대한척추외과학회지

STUDY DESIGN: The ingrowth of the nociceptive nerve ending into intervertebral disc was examined using immunohistochemistry and quantified using western blotting. OBJECTIVES: To determine if the nociceptive nerve innervates into the intervertebral discs of internal disc disruption (IDD). SUMMARY AND LITERATURE REVIEW: Nociceptive nerve ending and vessel ingrowth into intervertebral disc is associated with IDD and HNP. Substance P is a neurotransmitter that is found in the nociceptive nerve endings. Immunohistochemistry has confirmed the presence, and western blot has isolated the target. The localization of novel nociceptive innervation, and a quantitative comparison was made according to the original pathology is of interest. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 10 specimens of intervertebral disc were collected from IDD during total disc replacement surgery , and another 10 specimens of intervertebral disc from HNP were collected during discectomy. The control samples of intervertebral disc were obtained from 3 adolescent patients with idiopathic scoliosis, and 2 patients with a lumbar bursting fracture. Standard immunohistochemical techniques were used to test for the nociceptive neurotransmitter (substance P), which is a protein expressed during axonogenesis (growth-associated protein 43, GAP43), and a general nerve marker (protein gene produce 9.5, PGP9.5). The expression of substance P protein was quantified using western blot for its polyclonal antibody. RESULTS: In IDD (n=10), substance P was expressed in 6 cases of outer annulus fibrosus (AF), 5 cases of inner AF, and 3 cases of nucleus pulposus (NP). In HNP (n=10), substance P was expressed in 4 cases of outer AF, 3 cases of inner AF, and 2 cases of NP. In the control group, only 2 cases expressed substance P in outer AF. GAP43 was only positive in outer AF as follows: IDD 3 cases, HNP 1 case, and control 1 case. None of the specimens showed localized PGP 9.5. Substance P was localized significantly in larger quantities in IDD than in the control group (p=0.002). In HNP, the expression level was larger than the control and lower than the IDD group but this was not statistically significant (p=0.158, p=0.108). CONCLUSIONS: Innervation of nociceptive nerve endings was identified at the degenerative intervertebral disc of IDD, which may contribute to back pain.

Intradiscal Electrothermal Treatment for Chronic Lower Back Pain Patients with Internal Disc Disruption

Chronic lower back pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal problems; it is also the most expensive industrial injury. Not surprisingly, many treatments have been developed to combat this expensive and debilitating condition. One of these, intradiscal electrothermal treatment (IDET), was developed for patients with chronic discogenic lower back pain who failed to improve with any of the wide variety of non- surgical treatments. The present study sought to evaluate the efficacy of IDET for patients with chronic lower back pain. Twenty-five patients were enrolled in this prospective study; the patients received IDET between June 2001 and June 2003. MRI was used to confirm the diagnosis of internal disc disruption in all patients. The patients then underwent a pre-operative provocative test and discography. The follow-up duration was at least 1 year in all cases, and the visual analogue scale, recovery rate, and satisfaction of each patient were evaluated. The average age of the patients was 32 years (age range 18 to 49 years), and the patient group was 33% male and 67% female. Of the 25 patients, 5 underwent lumbar fusion surgery within 1 year of IDET. After IDET, 8 patients (32%) reported more pain than before, 14 patients (56%) reported less pain, and 3 patients (12%) experienced no change. Twelve patients (48%) were satisfied with IDET, 11 (44%) were dissatisfied, and 2 (8%) were undecided about the treatment. At least 1 year after IDET, nearly half the study patients were dissatisfied with their medical outcome. Consequently, 5 patients (20%) underwent fusion surgery at 1 year after IDET. Although other studies have shown good results with IDET for at least 2 years, this investigation suggests the IDET may be somewhat less effective. In order to firmly establish the efficacy of IDET for treating chronic discogenic lower back pain, additional studies with larger numbers of patients evaluated over longer time periods are recommended.

Clinical Symptoms of Internal Disc Disruption of the Cervical Spine / 대한척추외과학회지

STUDY DESIGN: This study reviewed 20 patients who were diagnosed as internal disc disruption (IDD) of the cervical spine. Clinical symptoms were analyzed retrospectively. OBJECTIVES: To assess the various symptoms of IDD of the cervical spine. Summary of Literature Review : Several studies have demonstrated the symptoms of lumbar spine IDD. No studies have attempted to show the symptoms of cervical spine IDD. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A group of patients, who showed chronic neck pain and referred pain to upper limbs after a certain trauma, was materials of this study. All these patients were examined with simple X-ray, flexion-extension views, magnetic resonance image (MRI). When intractable pain was prolonged over 6months in spite of conservative treatment, patient was admitted and performed discogram and computed tomograpy (CT) for a definite diagnosis. There were 20 patients who were diagnosed as IDD from July 1996 to June 2001, and clinical symptoms were analyzed retrospectively. RESULTS: The various symptoms of the IDD of the cervical spine were chronic neck pain (100%), shoulder pain (95%), headache (90%), interscapular pain (80%), arm pain and paresthesia (75%), insomnia (75%), hand pain and paresthesia (60%), periocular pain (60%), forearm pain and paresthesia (50%), chin pain (50%), subjective weakness of upper extremity (45%), periauricular pain (40%) and tinnitus (30%). CONCLUSION: We are led to believe that patients who have chronic neck pain, shoulder pain, interscapluar pain, and other symptoms after a certain trauma of cervical spine are clinically diagnosed as IDD of the cervical spine, although X-ray and MRI are normal. Definite diagnosis of these patients would be made by a discogram, if similar or identical pain is provocated.

Significance of the High-intensity Zone(HIZ) on Magnetic Resonance Imaging for Diagnosis of the Internal Disc Disruption / 대한척추외과학회지

STUDY DESIGN: Analysis of correlation of high-intensity zone in magnetic resonance image and pain provocation in discography. OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the relationship of the high-intensity zone to the results of discography in identifying the painful intervertebral disc. SUMMARY OF LITERATURE REVIEW: There is some disagreement in validity of high-intensity zone on MRI for diagnosis of discogenic pain. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Magnetic resonance images were obtained in 52 patients who were considered for surgical intervention after failing to respond to conservative treatment. The presence of a high-intensity zone was specially looked for within anulus fibrosus. Each patient subsequently underwent discography; and types of provocative pain and image were recorded. Statistical analysis was used to evaluate the correlation of high-intensity zone and concordant pain response and disc disruption. RESULTS: The interobserver reliability for detecting a high-intensity zone in a given disc was substantial(kappa=0.646). The sensitivity of high-intensity zone for concordant pain was 47% but its specificity was relatively high(81%). Posttest odds was not so high(68%). CONCLUSION: These results suggest that the usefulness of high-intensity zone is limited by low sensitivity and a high-intensity zone is not indicative of exactly painful disc disruption.

Diagnostic Value of Image Findings of MRI and Discography for the Internal Disc Disruption / 대한정형외과학회잡지

In the investigation of patients with internal disc disruption, a discography has been the best method to decide whether intervertebral disc is normal or abnormal. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the spine is a new technique which offers an alternative method of obtaining this information. Some authors have reported MRI was more accurate than discography, but other reports have indicated discography was more useful test in symptomatic lumbar disc disease. The authors performed retrospective study to evaluate the diagnostic value of the image findings of MRI and discography in the internal disc disruption. Image findings of MRI and discography were analyzed comparing to pattern of provocative pain during discography. The concordant pain at discography was considered as a gold standard for evaluation of the diagnostic value of these modalities. The image findings of MRI and discography for 60 discs of 21 patients were graded and compared with the pain response at discography. The validity and predictive value (PV) of these modalities were calculated and the correlation between these image findings was evaluated. The sensitivities of discography and MRI were 83.3% and 90.9% respectively. The specificities of these findings were 47.1% and 46.7%. The positive PV of discography and MRI were 52.6% and 55.6%, and the negative PV were 80% and 87.5% respectively. There was no statistical significance in these discrepancies. The determinations of symptomatic disc level based on image findings are unreliable. The MRI can be considered as a screening test for internal disc disruption since it is non-invasive and sensitive diagnostic tool. The fusion level should be decided by the pain pattern at discography.