ABSTRACT
@#Background: Orthorexia nervosa (ON) is an eating disorder characterized by an obsession with eating healthy foods, which has physical, psychological, and social impacts. The use of social media platform such as Instagram is suspected to be one of the risk factors of ON, as health information on Instagram can reach thousands of people despite the fact that its source is frequently unreliable. Objective: To determine the correlation between the intensity of Instagram usage and ON among Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM) students, as well as the correlation between confounding variables (gender, monthly income, age, faculty cluster, and nutritional knowledge) and ON. Methods: The research design used is an observational study with cross-sectional design that involved 529 students. Samples were taken by stratified random sampling, and data was collected online. Chi square test with ꭤ = 0.05 was used in this study. Results: The results showed that as many as 55% of students were diagnosed with ON and most of the students had moderate intensity of using Instagram. There is a correlation between the intensity of using social media Instagram and ON in UGM students (p value = 0.037<0.05) and there is no correlation of confounding variables (gender, monthly income, age, faculty cluster, and nutritional knowledge) with ON. Conclusion: There is a positive correlation between the intensity of Instagram use and ON in UGM students, and no confounding variables were found in this study. Keywords: Orthorexia Nervosa, Instagram, Social Media, Eating Disorders
ABSTRACT
Introducción: Existe una creciente evidencia investigativa sobre la relación entre el síndrome ortoréxico y el perfeccionismo. Objetivo: Se efectúa un análisis descriptivo interpretativo e integrador acerca de la relación entre el perfeccionismo con la ortorexia nerviosa, destacando los aspectos clínicos, etiopatogénicos y nosológicos. Método: Se realizó una búsqueda bibliográfica sobre la relación entre el síndrome ortoréxico y el perfeccionismo mediante las bases de datos Medline/PubMed, SciELO y textos especializados. Resultados: El término ortorexia se ha concebido como una fijación patológica hacia una alimentación equilibrada y saludable (Bratman, 1997), implicando restricciones dietéticas drásticas, con interferencia significativa en las relaciones sociales e insatisfacciones afectivas, que, además favorecen la conducta alimentaria desadaptativa. Etiopatogénicamente, existe controversia respecto a si es un mero estilo de vida, o puede incluirse definitivamente como un trastorno en los espectros alimentario u obsesivo-compulsivo. De hecho, posee similitudes, diferencias e incluso traslapes con ambas entidades psicopatológicas. Se destaca como rasgo relevante común, el perfeccionismo, orientado hacia sí mismo, hacía los demás, y socialmente prescrito, que favorece la tendencia a desarrollar conductas ortoréxicas elevadas. Conclusiones: El perfeccionismo surge como una característica sobresaliente, positivamente correlacionada con el síndrome ortoréxico, cuya presencia se superpone con los ámbitos, tanto alimentario (especialmente la anorexia nerviosa) como obsesivo-compulsivo.
Background: There is a growing research evidence on the relationship between orthorexic syndrome and perfectionism. Objective: An interpretive and integrative descriptive analysis on the relationship between perfectionism and orthorexia nervosa, highlighting the clinical, etiopathogenic and nosological aspects is carried through. Method: A bibliographic search on the relationship between orthorexic syndrome and perfectionism using the Medline/PubMed, SciELO and specialized text databases was carried out. Results: The term orthorexia has been conceived as a pathological fixation towards a balanced and healthy diet (Bratman, 1997), implying drastic dietary restrictions, with significant interference in social relationships and affective dissatisfactions, which also favor maladaptive eating behavior. From an etiopathogenic perspective, it is controversial if orthorexia nervosa is a mere lifestyle, or definitively must be included as a disorder in the eating or obsessive-compulsive spectrum. In fact, the orthorexic syndrome has similarities, differences and even overlaps with both psychopathological entities. Perfectionism stands out as a common relevant trait, oriented towards oneself, towards others, and socially prescribed, which favors a tendency to develop high orthorectic behaviors. Conclusions: Perfectionism emerges as an outstanding characteristic, positively correlated with the orthorexic syndrome, overlapping with both eating (especially anorexia nervosa) and obsessive-compulsive areas.
ABSTRACT
RESUMEN Introducción: Numerosos estudios han proporcionado evidencia sobre la ortorexia nerviosa, síndrome caracterizado por un extremo y drástico patrón alimentario saludable, que ha sido foco de creciente interés. Sin embargo, existe un debate científico sobre si es simplemente un fenómeno del comportamiento o un estilo de vida o un trastorno mental. Objetivo: Se realizó un análisis descriptivo de la evidencia acerca de la ortorexia nerviosa en sus aspectos epidemiológicos, nosológicos, clínicos y terapéuticos. Método: Se efectuó una búsqueda bibliográfica narrativa cualitativa sobre ortorexia nerviosa y otros trastornos alimentarios mediante las bases de datos Medline/PubMed, SciELO y en textos especializados. Resultados: Existe controversia si la ortorexia nerviosa es un trastorno alimentario único o una consecuencia del desenlace de éste o un proceso obsesivo-compulsivo. Puede preceder, sobrevenir o coexistir con trastornos alimentarios y también afectar los hábitos del comer. El antecedente de trastorno alimentario es un factor predictivo significativo para el desarrollo de la ortorexia nerviosa. Algunos autores han diferenciado entre una ortorexia orientada hacia el interés en una alimentación sana (ortorexia saludable) y otra relacionada a una preocupación patológica por comer saludablemente (ortorexia nerviosa). Conclusiones: Muchos aspectos psicológicos y conductuales de los trastornos alimentarios son compartidos por los ortoréxicos. Son necesarios estudios longitudinales en el futuro que investiguen la relación temporal entre estos u otros tópicos para incluir a la ortorexia nerviosa dentro del espectro de los trastornos alimentarios.
ABSTRACT Background: Several studies have provided evidence on orthorexia nervosa, a syndrome characterized by an extreme and drastic healthy eating pattern, which has been the focus of growing interest. However, there is a scientific debate as to whether it is simply a behavioural phenomenon, a lifestyle or a mental disorder. Objective: A descriptive analysis of the evidence about orthorexia nervosa: epidemiological, nosological, clinical and therapeutic aspects were discussed. Method: A narrative qualitative bibliographic search on orthorexia nervosa and other eating disorders was carried out using Medline/PubMed, SciELO databases and specialized texts. Results: It is controversial whether orthorexia nervosa is a unique eating disorder or a consequence of its outcome or an obsessive-compulsive process. It can precede, occur, or coexist along with eating disorders and also may affect eating habits. A history of eating disorder is a significant predictive factor for the development of orthorexia nervosa. Some authors have differentiated between an orthorexia oriented towards the interest in a healthy diet (healthy orthorexia) and another related to a pathological concern about eating healthy (orthorexia nervosa). Conclusions: Many psychological and behavioural features of eating disorders are shared by orthorexics. Future longitudinal research is needed to analyse the temporal relationship between these and other issues to include orthorexia nervosa within the spectrum of eating disorders.
ABSTRACT
@#Eating disorders are often underdiagnosed. Orthorexia nervosa (ON), a new type of eating disorder, is defined as excessive preoccupation with healthy eating, causing significant nutritional deficiencies and social and personal impairments. The ORTO-15 is a 15-item instrument widely used to evaluate orthorexia nervosa. It was developed by Donini et al (2005) in Italian and has been translated and adapted in other languages. In this study, the validity and reliability of the Indonesian version of ORTO-15 were assessed. The Indonesian version of the instrument was then reviewed by experts after translation. The back-translation was assessed for consistency with the original instrument. The instrument was then statistically-tested for validity and reliability on 50 randomly selected subjects. The subjects were balanced in gender and the mean age was 19.4 + 0.8 years. The reliability was tested using Cronbach’s alpha. The validity was tested using Pearson's product-moment correlation and confirmatory factor analyses (CFA). The Pearson product moment verified good validity for the instrument (r = 0.369 – 0.881). CFA analyses confirmed good communalities (extraction > 0.5) and revealed three components construct (cumulative 73.5%). Reliability test confirmed that the instrument had good reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.915). The ORTO-15 Indonesian version is a valid and reliable instrument for the assessment of ON.
Subject(s)
Reproducibility of Results , Feeding and Eating DisordersABSTRACT
RESUMO Objetivo Identificar a prevalência de comportamentos com tendência a ortorexia nervosa (ON) e suas associações com o estado nutricional, satisfação corporal e período cursado em estudantes de nutrição. Métodos Participaram do estudo 141 estudantes (com idade média de 21,5 ± 3,5 anos). A tendência à ON foi avaliada por meio do questionário para identificação da ON (ORTO-15) e a satisfação corporal, pelo Body Shape Questionnaire. A classificação do estado nutricional foi feita pelo IMC (kg.m-2). Associações entre as variáveis foram avaliadas pelo teste do qui-quadrado (p < 0,05). Resultados Comportamentos alimentares com tendência a ON foram identificados em 87,2% dos estudantes. Os estudantes com ON apresentaram mais insatisfação corporal (χ2 = 7,48; p = 0,005) e excesso de peso (χ2 = 6,56; p = 0,010). Não foi observada associação entre a ON e o período cursado. Conclusão Os resultados demonstram que os estudantes de nutrição parecem ser uma população especialmente em risco para tendência à ON, independentemente do período cursado. A maior frequência de estudantes com ON e excesso de peso e insatisfação corporal pode sugerir que tais condições, que comumente cursam com preocupações com alimentação saudável, podem facilitar o início do desenvolvimento de comportamentos alimentares associados a ON.
ABSTRACT Objective To identify the prevalence of orthorexia nervosa (ON)'s risky behaviors and their association with nutritional status, body satisfaction and coursed period in nutrition students. Methods The study included 141 students (mean age 21.5 ± 3.5 years). The risk behavior to ON was assessed by using the questionnaire to identify ON (ORTHO-15) and body satisfaction with the Body Shape Questionnaire. The classification of nutritional status was evaluated by BMI (kg.m-2). Association between variables was evaluated by chi-square test (p < 0.05). Results Eating behaviors at risk for ON were identified in 87.2% of students. Students with ON had more body dissatisfaction (χ2 = 7.48; p = 0.005) and overweight (χ2 = 6.56; p = 0.010). No association was observed between the ON and coursed period. Conclusion The results show that Nutrition students seem to be a population at a particular risk for ON, regardless of the coursed period studied. The higher frequency of students with ON and overweight and body dissatisfaction may suggest that such conditions, which commonly occur with concerns about healthy eating, may facilitate the initiation of the development of eating behaviors associated with ON.
ABSTRACT
Ortorexia nervosa é o termo descrito para o comportamento obsessivo patológico caracterizado pela fixação por saúde alimentar. O quadro ainda não foi oficialmente reconhecido como um transtorno alimentar, mas discute-se o conceito, suas características, interações e sintomas. No presente trabalho foi realizada uma revisão dos vinte e um artigos publicados desde 1997, quando o comportamento da ortorexia nervosa foi inicialmente descrito. Foram apontadas semelhanças e diferenças entre o comportamento alimentar observado na ortorexia nervosa e nos transtornos alimentares mais frequentes (anorexia e bulimia nervosa). Um instrumento foi desenvolvido e validado para detecção do quadro ortoréxico. Os estudos apontam alguns grupos vulneráveis à ortorexia nervosa: estudantes de medicina, médicos, nutricionistas, pessoas com sintomas de ansiedade, obsessivo-compulsivos e aqueles que supervalorizam o corpo perfeito. A ortorexia nervosa é situada a partir de uma análise dos conceitos de atitude alimentar e alimentação saudável, procurando um foco biopsicossocial para a alimentação adequada e não apenas um foco fisiológico. Não existem estudos investigativos sobre a ortorexia nervosa no Brasil, mas o tema deve ser discutido para alertar os profissionais da área da saúde sobre a existência desse comportamento inadequado e suas possíveis consequências não só para a saúde física e emocional, mas também para a visão de alimentação saudável.
Orthorexia nervosa is a new term described as an obsessive pathological behavior characterized by fixation on healthy eating. It has not yet been officially recognized as an eating disorder, but its concept, characteristics, interactions and symptoms have been discussed. This work presents a review of the articles published on the theme since 1997, when orthorexic behavior was first described. Similarities and differences between orthorexic behavior and the more common eating disorders, such as anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa, are discussed. To date, one instrument was developed and validated to detect orthorexic behavior. Studies indicate that some groups are more vulnerable to orthorexia nervosa: medical students, physicians, dietitians, individuals with anxiety symptoms, obsessive-compulsive individuals and those who overvalue a perfect body. The discussion on orthorexia nervosa is based on analyzing the concepts of eating attitude and healthy eating, and seeks a biopsychosocial focus for proper eating in addition to a physiological focus. To date, there are no studies about orthorexia nervosa in Brazil. Nevertheless, this subject is worthy of discussion since health professionals should be made aware of the existence of this deviant behavior and its possible consequences, not only for someone's physical and emotional health, but also for the understanding of healthy eating.
Subject(s)
Feeding Behavior , Feeding and Eating Disorders/psychology , Feeding Behavior/psychologyABSTRACT
30-year-old male was admitted with general weakness and drowsy mental status. He had eaten only 3-4 spoons of brown rice and fresh vegetable without salt for 3 months to treat his tic disorder, and he had been in bed-ridden state. He has had weight loss of 14 kg in the last 3 months. We report a patient with orthorexia nervosa who developed hyponatremia, metabolic acidosis, subcutaneous emphysema, mediastinal emphysema, pneumothorax, and pancytopenia and we will review the literature. Also, we mention to prevent refeeding syndrome, and to start and maintain feeding in malnourished patients.