ABSTRACT
Objective: This study intended to clarify whether healthcare professionals provide palliative care and the factors associated with such care. Methods: An anonymous self-administered questionnaire survey was conducted of healthcare professionals in in an acute care hospital in order to investigate their practice and understanding of palliative care as well as their personal attributes. A multivariate logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors associated with their palliative care practice. Results: 605 of 955 respondents (response rate: 63%) answered. Twenty-three percent of all respondents answered that they were involved in palliative care practice. A multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed understanding the concept and practical components of palliative care, including the functions of palliative care, differences between primary and specialized palliative care, and advance care planning, were factors associated with palliative care practice. Conclusion: Palliative care specialists should provide the educational support for healthcare professionals to enable them to deepen their understanding of palliative care. Such support from the palliative care specialist may promote the health care professionals’ awareness of their own roles in palliative care.
ABSTRACT
Resumo Competências foram definidas como o conjunto de conhecimentos, habilidades e atitudes que um profissional deverá adquirir para exercer determinada atividade de trabalho. O objetivo deste estudo foi avaliar as competências em cuidados paliativos entre os estudantes matriculados em um curso de medicina brasileiro. Todos os estudantes matriculados foram convidados para participar e preencheram a ferramenta Palliative Competence Tool. Os dados obtidos foram calculados em escores entre zero e 100 e comparados entre as dez competências e os ciclos acadêmicos. Os resultados mostraram quatro padrões, sendo o mais frequente a redução dos escores entre estudantes dos ciclos básico e intermediário, com recuperação parcial no estágio. Apenas a competência ética e tomada de decisão mostrou elevação no estágio. Concluiu-se que a aquisição de competências em cuidados paliativos na graduação médica ainda é frágil. Novas estratégias de ensino poderão ser adotadas com intenção de aprimorar a aquisição de competências no futuro.
Abstract Competencies have been defined as the set of knowledge, skills and attitudes that a professional should acquire to perform a certain work activity. This study aimed to assess competencies in palliative care among students enrolled in a Brazilian medical course. All enrolled students were invited to participate and answer the Palliative Competence Tool. The data obtained were calculated in scores between zero and 100 and compared between the ten competencies and academic cycles. The results showed four patterns, the most frequent being a reduction in scores among students in the basic and intermediate cycles, with partial recovery in the internship. Only ethical competence and decision-making increased in the internship. It was concluded that the acquisition of palliative care competencies in undergraduate medical education remains fragile. New teaching strategies could be adopted to improve their acquisition in the future.
Resumen Las competencias son un conjunto de conocimientos, habilidades y actitudes que debe adquirir el profesional para desempeñar una actividad laboral. Este estudio pretende evaluar las competencias en cuidados paliativos entre los estudiantes de medicina matriculados en el grado de medicina en Brasil. Todos los inscritos recibieron invitación a participar y completaron la Palliative Competence Tool. Los datos obtenidos se calcularon en puntuaciones entre 0 y 100 y se compararon entre las diez competencias y los ciclos académicos. Los resultados mostraron cuatro patrones; el más frecuente fue la reducción de la puntuación entre los estudiantes de ciclos básico e intermedio, con recuperación parcial en las prácticas. Solo la competencia ética y la toma de decisiones presentaron una alta puntuación en las prácticas. Sigue siendo débil la adquisición de competencias en cuidados paliativos en medicina. La adopción de nuevas estrategias de enseñanza puede mejorar la adquisición de las competencias en el futuro.
Subject(s)
Professional CompetenceABSTRACT
1）Palliative care education by means e–learning was performed from December 3 to 25, 2009, for 1256 hospital medical staff. We used the same true–or–false questions to assess their understanding before and after the e–learning course.<br>2）Regardless of the staff member’s experience, the total scores on the test were higher after the course than before the course. Therefore, this e–learning course had an effect on basic knowledge for multiple types of medical staff.<br>3）The percentage of correct answers was particularly improved for questions about topics we had emphasized: drug dependence and side effects.
ABSTRACT
In Kyoto, we held the first “Palliative care workshop for physicians engaged in clinical practice for cancer treatment” in Japan on June 7-8, 2008 under the directive of the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare. There were 163 participants in the workshop, including 56 physicians and 107 voluntarily participating healthcare professionals (77 nurses, 23 pharmacists and 7 other medical professionals). We analyzed the results of tests consisting of 25 questions classified into 7 categories based on their contents. Tests were administered before and after the workshop (pre-test and post-test), and the educational effects of our conference were evaluated by examining changes in test scores. Participants other than physicians, nurses and pharmacists were excluded from analysis of the test scores because comprehensive medical knowledge was required to solve the questions. The mean rates of correct answers on pre- and post-test were 87.9% for physicians (total 78.9%) and 94.6% for physicians (total 89.1%), respectively. The scores were markedly increased after the workshop, showing practical significance of our attempt. However, the percentage of correct answers regarding psychological symptoms was lowest for physicians as well as for other healthcare professionals on both pre- and post-test. These findings strongly suggest that the workshops produced a sufficient educational effect, but improvement in individual training systems is considered necessary, especially in fields related to psychological manifestations. Palliat Care Res 2010; 5(2): 152-161