Influencia de la COVID-19 en la enseñanza de la Medicina

RESUMEN El presente artículo tiene como propósito develar las principales modificaciones generadas por la epidemia de COVID-19 en el proceso de enseñanza-aprendizaje de la carrera de Medicina. La información se obtuvo mediante la revisión documental de textos, artículos, tesis, apoyada en los métodos inherentes a la investigación científica. El estudio se realizó en el Hospital Universitario Ginecobstétrico Provincial Ana Betancourt de Mora, de Camagüey durante el período comprendido entre marzo de 2021 y abril de 2022 y deriva del acercamiento a los antecedentes y resultados teóricos y metodológicos relacionados con el tratamiento de la temática que ya se acumulan en la educación superior.

ABSTRACT The purpose of this article is to reveal the main changes generated by the COVID-19 epidemic in the teaching-learning process of the Medicine career. The information was obtained through documentary review of texts, articles, theses, supported by the methods inherent to scientific research. The study was carried out at the Ana Betancourt de Mora Provincial Gynecobstetric University Hospital, in Camagüey during the period between March 2021 and April 2022 and derives from the approach to the background and theoretical and methodological results related to the treatment of the theme that already accumulate in higher education.

Enseñanza asistida por pares en una facultad de medicina de Lima, Perú. El caso de la Sociedad Estudiantil de Ciencias Clínicas

La enseñanza asistida por pares es una metodología educativa donde interactúan grupos de estudiantes. Una parte toma el rol de educador, y la otra toma el rol de alumno. Esto trae varios beneficios a ambas partes. Se presenta el caso de un programa donde se utiliza esta metodología, en el cual estudiantes de una facultad de Medicina en Lima, Perú toman el rol de tutores de estudiantes de años menores de la misma facultad. Se describen también sus actividades y los recursos académicos utilizados.

SUMMARY Peer teaching is an educational methodology in which groups of students interact among each other. One group takes on the role of the educator and the other one takes on the role of the student, which benefits both of them. We report here the case of a program where this methodology was used by students in a medical school in Lima, Peru, who were tutors of junior students from the same faculty. The activities and resources used in this methodology are also described.

Evaluation of critical thinking course for premedical students using literature and film / 한국의학교육

PURPOSE: Premedical education is one stage in which various educational approaches are used to promote critical thinking. Given that critical thinking ability could be regarded as one of the intended outcomes of social science and humanities education, this study explored the effectiveness of a course to promote critical thinking in a premedical curriculum using both literature and film. METHODS: Fifty-one 2nd year premedical students enrolled in a 'Critical Thinking for Premeds' course. Students were required to read or watch a selected material, submit group discussion agendas, attend five group discussion sessions, and write critical essays. Five tutors facilitated the group discussions, observed and assessed the students' performance and critical essay. Students' critical thinking disposition and opinion on assigned reading materials were examined before and after the course. A program evaluation survey was conducted to investigate the students' reaction after the course. RESULTS: On average, students appreciated 78.6% of the total assigned materials. The students indicated that group discussions and the narrative comments of facilitators contributed the most to develop critical thinking. After the course, the students' tendency preferring cheaper price books, as well as medicine-related books decreased significantly. Students who had critical essay scores greater than or equal to the median demonstrated a significant improvement in critical thinking disposition scores. CONCLUSION: The course was well-accepted by premedical students and had several positive outcomes. A more effective use of the course could be anticipated with a clearer explanation of the purpose, the consideration of previous reading experience, and use of complementary learning activities.

Effects of Academic Relationships on Academic Burnout in Health Professions Students / 의학교육논단

There are several dimensions of academic burnout experienced by medical and health science college students. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of academic relationships on academic burnout. Data was collected from 476 Eulji University students using an online survey over 4 days in April of 2018. Of the 264 respondents, 111 studied medicine (42.0%), 105 studied nursing (39.8%), and 48 studied clinical pathology (18.1%). The questionnaire was composed of the following sections: demographics (four questions), general life characteristics (seven questions), academic enthusiasm (eight questions), academic relationships (15 questions), and academic burnout sub-dimensions (partially revised Maslach Burnout Inventory-Student Survey Scale) (11 questions). T-tests and one-way analysis of variance were performed to illustrate the differences among the three departments. The effects of academic relationships and academic enthusiasm on academic burnout were analyzed using linear regression. Comparing the three departments, academic burnout was not found to be statistically significant (p=0.296). However, medical students' academic enthusiasm was significantly lower (p<0.001) and academic relationships were significantly higher (p<0.001) than nursing and clinical pathology students. The difference in academic burnout among the three departments was not significant. However, medical students have stronger academic relationships, while nursing and clinical pathology students were more focused on academics. Relationships and academic enthusiasm contribute to reducing academic burnout. Therefore, strategies need to be developed to deal with academic burnout considering relationship factors.

Factors That Influence Educational Effectiveness and Learning Satisfaction in Biomedical Research Programs during Premedical School / 의학교육논단

Although student research programs have been implemented worldwide, research programs during premedical school have unique characteristics. The purpose of this study is to evaluate factors that influence the effects of premedical school research programs. Eighty second-year premedical students at Pusan National University were included in the study. Effect elements and influential factors were extracted through reference reviews and in-depth individual interviews. A Likert scale questionnaire was developed using the extracted elements and factors, and Cronbach's alpha coefficient was used to analyze the reliability of the survey. The mean value and the standard deviation for each question were calculated to evaluate education effectiveness and learning satisfaction, and the influence of each factor on effect was analyzed using correlation analysis. Students' research skills and knowledge were improved in the short term; however, interest in research or in a career as a researcher did not increase. Student interest, participation, and contributions were important factors. Among professors, passion, considerateness, and teaching method including the level of lesson were influential factors. Implementation of curriculum and support and guidance were influential as well, whereas evaluation system was not a factor. To improve student research programs, several factors that influence education effectiveness and learning satisfaction should be considered.

Verification of learner’s differences by team-based learning in biochemistry classes / 한국의학교육

PURPOSE: We tested the effect of team-based learning (TBL) on medical education through the second-year premedical students’ TBL scores in biochemistry classes over 5 years. METHODS: We analyzed the results based on test scores before and after the students’ debate. The groups of students for statistical analysis were divided as follows: group 1 comprised the top-ranked students, group 3 comprised the low-ranked students, and group 2 comprised the medium-ranked students. Therefore, group T comprised 382 students (the total number of students in group 1, 2, and 3). To calibrate the difficulty of the test, original scores were converted into standardized scores. We determined the differences of the tests using Student t-test, and the relationship between scores before, and after the TBL using linear regression tests. RESULTS: Although there was a decrease in the lowest score, group T and 3 showed a significant increase in both original and standardized scores; there was also an increase in the standardized score of group 3. There was a positive correlation between the pre- and the post-debate scores in group T, and 2. And the beta values of the pre-debate scores and “the changes between the pre- and post-debate scores” were statistically significant in both original and standardized scores. CONCLUSION: TBL is one of the educational methods for helping students improve their grades, particularly those of low-ranked students.

A Study of the Historical Development and Directions of Premedical Education / 의학교육논단

Despite the importance of how the premedical education curriculum is organized, the basic direction of the curriculum has not been evaluated at a fundamental level. In order to explore the basic directions of the premedical education curriculum, this study examined medical education as a university education, the historical basis of premedical education, and the direction of the premedical education curriculum. Historically, as medical education was incorporated into the university education system, premedical education developed based on basic science and liberal arts education. Accordingly, the direction of the premedical education curriculum began to split into two approaches: one believing in a basic science-based education intended to serve as the foundation of medical training, and the other believing in a liberal arts-based education intended to cultivate the qualities of a doctor. In recent years, however, the binary division in the direction of premedical education has ceased to exist, and the paradigm has now shifted to an agreement that premedical education must cultivate the basic scientific competence required for learning medical knowledge as well as the social qualities that a doctor should have, which are cultivated through the liberal arts. Furthermore, it has been asserted that the direction of premedical education should move toward the qualities that will be required in the future. With the fourth industrial revolution underway, the role of doctors is now being re-examined. This means that today's medical education must change in a future-oriented way, and the direction of the premedical education curriculum must be on the same page.

How Can We Improve Premedical Education in Korea? / 의학교육논단

When a new educational system for college students in South Korea was established in 1946, the National Committee for Educational Planning adopted a 6-year curriculum of medical education, consisting of a 2-year premedical component and a 4-year medical component. For more than half a century, the premedical curriculum has received little attention. However, it is very important for premedical students to have a range of experiences that could be useful in their future medical careers. In 2005, another change was made to the system of medical education, in which medical schools without a 2-year premedical curriculum were established. This began to stimulate interest in premedical education, and more and more professors have become interested in premedical education as 6-year medical colleges have become more popular than before. Since 2015, the Education and Cultural Center of the Korean Association of Medical Colleges has annually hosted a workshop for redesigning premedical education; these workshops quickly fill up with registrants, reflecting the participants' lively interest in premedical education. The problems of premedical education are mostly due to students' and educators' attitudes. A more effective approach will be needed in the educational system of the future to train highly competent medical doctors. To judge whether an educational program is successful, its aims must be clearly articulated. For this reason, medical colleges must prepare premedical education curricula based on their educational aims. It is expected that the system of premedical education will be strengthened in the future due to the growing awareness of its importance.

Introduction of Premedical Curriculum at the College of Medicine, The Catholic University of Korea / 의학교육논단

Premed education in the college of medicine at the Catholic University of Korea aims to promote student creativity and excellence in accordance with the mission of the college: to have a sense of calling, leadership, and competency. The Catholic Medical College premed curriculum includes 75 credits which are composed of 65 credits for required courses and 10 credits for elective courses. It consists of courses in basic science, medical science, liberal arts and humanities (premedical OMNIBUS). It also involves community programs in ‘Vision and Mission,’ ‘Leadership Training,’ and ‘Academic Conference.’ In addition, students are allowed self-directed choice of their courses and learning for one quarter.

Consensus Statement; Behavioral and Social Sciences in Medical Education / 医学教育

<p>The Consensus of this Committee is:</p><p>1) To change the name of the present committee from "Premedical Education Committee" to "Committee on Behavioral and Social Science" ; accordingly to discuss theoretical foundations, clinical application, learning objectives and outcomes of behavioral and social science in Japanese medical schools.</p><p>2) To collect actual case studies of teaching behavioral and social sciences in Japanese medical schools and create a database for such practices.</p><p>3) To develop behavioral and social science curriculum content in Japanese medical schools.</p><p>4) To organize training courses for teaching methods for behavioral and social science curricula and develop standardized teaching methods and materials.</p>

Bacharelado interdisciplinar: uma proposta inovadora na educação superior em saúde no Brasil / Interdisciplinary Bachelor's degree in Health: an innovative proposal in higher education in Health in Brazil

Este artigo descreve e analisa o contexto político-institucional e o processo de elaboração e implantação do Bacharelado Interdisciplinar em Saúde (BIS) no período 2006-2011. A metodologia utilizada incluiu revisão documental e análise dos registros pessoais dos pesquisadores envolvidos. A partir dos conceitos de "janela de oportunidade" e "organização hipercomplexa", verificou-se que foram criadas estruturas gerenciais e organizativas, elaborados documentos-mestres e desencadeadas ações para a implantação do curso, ligadas à conformação do corpo docente e do Colegiado do curso, elaboração do Projeto Pedagógico, planejamento, execução e acompanhamento do processo ensino-aprendizagem nos diversos componentes curriculares. A análise dos desafios e perspectivas do curso aponta que o maior problema enfrentado é a tensão entre o modelo de formação superior, profissional e disciplinar, existente até então e o modelo interdisciplinar proposto pelo BI, tensão que pode ser superada pela implantação do regime de ciclos, com a institucionalização do BI como primeiro ciclo da formação profissional na área de saúde.

This article describes and analyzes the political and institutional context and the process of implementation of the Interdisciplinary Bachelor's degree in Health (IBH) during the 2006-2011 period. The methodology included document review and analysis of personnel records of the researchers involved. By using the concepts of "window of opportunity" and "hypercomplex organization," it was revealed that managerial and organizational structures were created and master-documents were prepared. In addition to this, actions for implementation of the course, related to the structure of the faculty and the academic council, preparation of the pedagogical project, planning, implementation and monitoring of the teaching-learning process in the various curriculum components offered since 2009 was conducted. Analysis of the challenges and prospects of the course indicates that the major problem is the tension between the traditional model of vocational and discipline-based higher education existing hitherto and the interdisciplinary model proposed by IBH. This tension can be overcome by the full implementation of learning cycles with the institutionalization of IBH as the first cycle of professional health education.

Comparison of Volunteer Activities at Saga University and the University of Hawaii / 医学教育

Influenced by a favorable environment, volunteer activities are integrated into medical education in the United States. Volunteer activities by medical students in hospitals are also becoming more common in Japan. With this background in mind, we performed a survey examining the nature of medical students' volunteer activities at the University of Hawaii in the United States and Saga University in Japan. By analyzing the percentages of students participating in volunteer activities and the location and content of the activities, we found that volunteer activities of medical students in Japan and the United States are strongly influenced by differences in the respective premedical education systems. We found that a premedical education that includes volunteer activities plays an important role in the United States. We suggest that further debate on premedical education that includes volunteer work is necessary for Japan to develop its own methods of medical education.

A Tutorial System in Premedical Education / 医学教育

Eight years ago the problem-based learning tutorial system was introduced for premedical education at Kinki University School of Medicine. We evaluated this unique education system with questionnaires for students in 1997 and 2000. The suitability of the problem-based learning tutorial system for medical education was 72% in 1997 and 92% in 2000. Approximately 90% students were satisfied with the tutorial system in both years, indicating that this system was widely accepted by even first-year students. However, group differences and differences due to tutors were still observed in the activities of students or the achievement of general instructional objectives or both. The content of the tutorial system and tutor training should be continuously evaluated.