Comparison of Treatment Methods in Lumbar Spinal Stenosis for Geriatric Patient: Nerve Block Versus Radiofrequency Neurotomy Versus Spinal Surgery

OBJECTIVE: The incidence of spinal treatment, including nerve block, radiofrequency neurotomy, instrumented fusions, is increasing, and progressively involves patients of age 65 and older. Treatment of the geriatric patients is often a difficult challenge for the spine surgeon. General health, sociofamilial and mental condition of the patients as well as the treatment techniques and postoperative management are to be accurately evaluated and planned. We tried to compare three treatment methods of spinal stenosis for geriatric patient in single institution. METHODS: The cases of treatment methods in spinal stenosis over than 65 years old were analyzed. The numbers of patients were 371 underwent nerve block, radiofrequency neurotomy, instrumented fusions from January 2009 to December 2012 (nerve block: 253, radiofrequency neurotomy: 56, instrumented fusions: 62). The authors reviewed medical records, operative findings and postoperative clinical results, retrospectively. Simple X-ray were evaluated and clinical outcome was measured by Odom's criteria at 1 month after procedures. RESULTS: We were observed excellent and good results in 162 (64%) patients with nerve block, 40 (71%) patient with radIofrequency neurotomy, 46 (74%) patient with spinal surgery. Poor results were 20 (8%) patients in nerve block, 2 (3%) patients in radiofrequency neurotomy, 3 (5%) patient in spinal surgery. CONCLUSION: We reviewed literatures and analyzed three treatment methods of spinal stenosis for geriatric patients. Although the long term outcome of surgical treatment was most favorable, radiofrequency neurotomy and nerve block can be considered for the secondary management of elderly lumbar spinals stenosis patients.

The Efficacy of Repeated Radiofrequency Medial Branch Neurotomy for Lumbar Facet Syndrome

OBJECTIVE: Radiofrequency (RF) medial branch neurotomy is an effective management of lumbar facet syndrome. However, pain may recur after period of time. When pain recurs, it can be repeated, but the successful outcome and duration of relief from repeated procedures are not clearly known. The objective of this study was to determine the success rate and duration of pain relief from repeated radiofrequency medial branch neurotomy for lumbar facet syndrome. METHODS: A retrospective review of medical records was done on 60 consecutive patients, from March of 2006 to February of 2009, who had an initial successful RF neurotomy but subsequently underwent repeated procedures due to recurrence of pain. All procedures were done in carefully selected patients after at least two responsive medial branch nerve blocks. C-arm fluoroscopic guide, impedance, sensory and motor threshold monitoring tools were used for the precise placement of electrodes. Responses of repeated procedures were compared with initial radiofrequency neurotomy for success rates and duration of pain relief. RESULTS: There were 48 females and 12 males. Mean age was 52.4 years (range, 26-83). RF medial branch neurotomy was done on one side in 38 and both sides in 22 patients, each covering at least three segments. Average visual analog scale at last procedure was 6.8. Twelve patients had previous lumbar operations, including 4 patients with instrumentations. Fifty-five patients had two procedures and five patients had three procedures. Mean duration of successful pain relief (> 50% of previous pain for at least 3 months period) after initial radiofrequency neurotomy was 10.9 months (range, 3-28) in 51 (85%) patients. From repeated procedures, successful pain relief was seen in 50 (91%) patients with average duration of 10.2 months (range, 3-24). Five patients had third procedure, which was successful in 4 (80%) patients with mean duration of 9.8 months (range, 5-16). This was not statistically different from initial results. There were no permanent neurological complications from the procedures. CONCLUSION: Results of this study indicate that the frequency of success and durations of relief from repeated RF medial branch neurotomy for lumbar facet syndrome are similar to initial results that provided relatively prolonged period of pain relief without major side effects. Each procedure seems to provide successful pain relief for about 10 months in more than 85% of carefully selected patients when properly done.

Clinical Efficacy of Radiofrequency Cervical Zygapophyseal Neurotomy in Patients with Chronic Cervicogenic Headache

The purpose of the present study was to assess the clinical efficacy of radiofrequency (RF) cervical zygapophyseal joint neurotomy in patients with cervicogenic headache. A total of thirty consecutive patients suffering from chronic cervicogenic headaches for longer than 6 months and showing a pain relief by greater than 50% from diagnostic/prognostic blocks were included in the study. These patients were treated with RF neurotomy of the cervical zygapophyseal joints and were subsequently assessed at 1 week, 1 month, 6 months, and at 12 months following the treatment. The results of this study showed that RF neurotomy of the cervical zygapophyseal joints significantly reduced the headache severity in 22 patients (73.3%) at 12 months after the treatment. In conclusion, RF cervical zygapophyseal joint neurotomy has shown to provide substantial pain relief in patients with chronic cervicogenic headache when carefully selected.

Usefulness of Pain Distribution Pattern Assessment in Decision-Making for the Patients with Lumbar Zygapophyseal and Sacroiliac Joint Arthropathy

There are currently no initial guides for the diagnosis of somatic referred pain of lumbar zygapophyseal joint (LZJ) or sacroiliac joint (SIJ). We developed a classification system of LZJ and SIJ pain, the "pain distribution pattern template (PDPT)" depending on the pain distribution patterns from a pool of 200 patients whose spinal pain source was confirmed. We prospectively applied the PDPT to determine its contribution to clinical decision-making for 419 patients whose pain was presumed to arise from the LZJs (259 patients) or SIJs (160 patients). Forty-nine percent (128/259) of LZJ and 46% (74/160) of SIJ arthopathies diagnosed by PDPT were confirmed by nerve blocks. Diagnostic reliabilities were significantly higher in Type A and C patterns in LZJ and Type C in SIJ arthropathies, 64%, 80%, and 68.4%, respectively. For both LZJ and SIJ arthropathies, favorable outcome after radiofrequency (RF) neurotomies was similar to the rate of positive responses to diagnostic blocks in Type A to Type D, whereas the outcome was unpredictable in those with undetermined type (Type E). Considering the paucity of currently available diagnostic methods for LZJ and SIJ arthropathies, PDPT is useful in clinical decision- making as well as in predicting the treatment outcome.

Radiofrequency Neurotomy of the Gray Ramus Communicans for Lumbar Osteoporotic Compression Fracture

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to determine the efficacy of percutaneous radiofrequency neurotomy(RFN) of grayramus communicans nerve in patients suffering from severe low back pain due to osteoporotic compression fracture. METHODS: Twenty two patients with lumbar osteoporotic compression fracture who had intractable back pain for less than two weeks and were performed with RFN at L1-L4 from May 2004 to December 2005 were retrospectively analyzed. Clinical outcome using visual analogue scale(VAS) pain scores and modified MacNab's grade was tabulated. Complications related to the procedure were assessed. RESULTS: Twenty-two female patients (age from 63 to 81 years old) were included in this study. The mean VAS score prior to RFN was 7.8, it improved to 2.6 within postoperative time of 48 hours, and the mean VAS score after 3 months was 2.8, which was significantly decreased. Eighteen of 22 patients were graded as excellent and good according to modified MacNab's criteria at final follow up. All patients recovered uneventfully, and the neurologic examination revealed no deficits. Two patients showing poor results worsened in symptom. Percutaneous was performed eventually resulting in symptom improvement. There were no significant complications related to the procedure such as sensory dysesthesia, numbness or permanent motor weakness. CONCLUSION: RFN is safe and effective in treating the painful osteoporotic compression fracture. In patients with intractable back pain due to lumbar osteoporotic compression fracture, RFN of gray ramus communicans nerve should be considered as a treatment option prior to vertebroplasty.

Lumbar Sympathetic Radiofrequency Neurotomy in Plantar Hyperhidrosis

OBJECTIVE: Surgical treatment of focal plantar hyperhidrosis is often unsatisfactory compared to palmar hyperhidrosis. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effect of lumbar sympathetic radiofrequency neurotomy on plantar hyperhidrosis. METHODS: From February 2004 to December 2005, 10 patients (mean age 24.3 male 1, female 9) with the clinical diagnosis of plantar hyperhidrosis were treated by bilateral lumbar sympathetic radiofrequency neurotomy of L3 and L4. Patients' symptom relief, satisfactory rate and side effects related to the procedure were analyzed. RESULTS: Radiofrequency neurotomy was effective in the treatment of focal plantar hyperhidrosis showing excellent (more than 75% improved) outcome in 70% of the patients and good (more than 50% improved) in 30%. Complications related to the surgical procedure, such as sensory dysesthesia and compensatory hyperhidrosis were not detected in any case. CONCLUSION: The use of radiofrequency neurotomy to ablate the lumbar sympathetic ganglion is a safe and effective treatment option for patients with plantar hyperhidrosis.

The Effect of Radiofrequency Neurotomy on Chronic Low Back Pain

STUDY DESIGN: A prospective study. PURPOSE: To determine the success rate and duration of relief of radiofrequency neurotomy for lumbar facet joint pain. OVERVIEW OF LITERATURE: There is a lack of effective treatment for chronic low back pain. Radiofrequency denervation appears to be an emerging technology, with substantial variations in use. METHODS: Fifty-eight patients underwent radiofrequent neurotomy on the posterior primary ramus for chronic low back pain. All patients with low back pain of more than 3 months duration, with or without non-radicular radiation to the buttock and hip, were included in the study. From October 2005 to December 2006, eligible patients underwent a standardized diagnostic work-up, which included the use of a visual analog scale (VAS), physical examination, review of imaging studies, and diagnostic blockades. Pain relief was assessed on the third day, and at 3 months and 6 months post-treatment, using the visual analog scale. RESULTS: There were 44 women and 14 men included in the study. The mean age was 57.7 years (range, 20~80 years). Radiofrequency neurotomy denervated three segments and a bilateral lesion in all patients. The visual analogue scale (VAS) scores on the third day (mean VAS score: 1.48) and 3 months (mean VAS score: 1.79) after treatment decreased significantly when compared with the pre-treatment scores (mean VAS score: 6.56). However, the final values of the VAS scores after 6 months were slightly increased as compared to the VAS scores measured at the beginning of the study (mean VAS score: 2.91). No cases of infection, new motor deficits, or new sensory deficits were identified. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that radiofrequency neurotomy offers an effective palliative management of lumbar facet pain. However, there is limited evidence that radiofrequency neurotomy offers short-term relief for chronic low back pain. Further high-quality randomized controlled trials are needed with larger patient numbers and more data on the long-term effects, for which current evidence is inconclusive.

Radiofrequency Neurotomy for Remnant Pain after Vertebroplasty as the Treatment of Severe Compression Fracture

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to evaluate the feasibility, safety and effectiveness of radiofrequency neurotomy(RFN) for remnant pain after vertebroplasty for the treatment of severe compression fracture. METHODS: 25 patients with remnant pain after vertebroplasty for one level severe compression fracture were treated by RFN. The severe compression fractures were defined to the vertebrae which less than 50% of their original heights have collapsed. Pain relief was evaluated at 2 weeks, 6 weeks and 3 months after the procedure using a visual analog scale(VAS). RESULTS: Successful outcome was determined if pain reduction exceeded 50% on the VAS at 6 weeks. Six of the 25 patients did not respond favorably to RFN (pain reduction less than 50%), and nineteen patients showed successful responses. Mean VAS score was decreased from 5.48 to 2.96 at 6 weeks. CONCLUSION: The radiofrequency neurotomy may be both feasible and useful treatment for the remnant pain after vertebroplasty. However long-term follow up is needed to confirm the effectiveness.

Burn Wound along the Guide Needle Trajectory as a Complication of Radiofrequency Neurotomy of the Lumbar Medial Branch: A case report / 대한통증학회지

Radiofrequency neurotomy of the lumbar medial branch, via a caudal approach, is a representative interventional procedure for lumbar zygapophysial joint pain, which can be performed more accurately and easily using a guide needle technique. We experienced a case of burn wound formation along the guide needle trajectory, where heat conduction through the guide needle was suggested to have resulted in the burn wound.

Radiofrequency Facet Denervation for Low Back Pain after Microscopic Discectomy

OBJECTIVE: There were few reports about statistically significant factor which contribute to low back pain(LBP) after microscopic discectomy. We analyzed the result of percutaneous radiofrequency neurotomy(PRN) for low back pain after microscopic discectomy in lumbar disc herniation. METHODS: Forty four patients with LBP after microscopic discectomy who were treated by one level microscopic discectomy from January 2003 to March 2004 were included in this study. They were divided into two groups by the presence of preoperative LBP into preoperative back pain group (group I) and postoperative back pain group (group II). Radiofrequency procedures were performed in the usual manner, targetting the medial branch of L4, L5 and Sl. Pain relief was estimated at 1 week, 1 month and 6 months following the procedure, using the visual analogue scale. Above 50% pain relief was defined as the positive response. RESULTS: Positive responders were 16 patients (73%) at 1 week, 12 patients (55%) at 1 month, and 7 patients (32%) at 6 months after PRN in group I. In Group II, 18 patients, 15 patients and 13 patients responded positively after 1 week, 1 month and 6 months after PRN, respectively. CONCLUSION: PRN is an effective treatment for newly developed low back pain after microscopic discectomy. There was no morbidity in our series, but long-term follow up is necessary.

Prognostic Factors of Percutaneous Radiofrequency Neurotomy on the Posterior Primary Ramus

OBJECTIVE: We report our experience of percutaneous radiofrequency neurotomy(PRN) on the posterior primary ramus with at least two years follow up. METHODS: Two hundred and twenty-eight patients were underwent PRN on the posterior primary ramus for refractory low back pain during last three years. One hundred and twenty-eight patients were met all inclusion criteria indicating facetal originated pain(group II), and 100 patients were not(group I). Radiofrequency procedures were done in usual manner. Pain reliefs were estimated at 1 week, 1 month, 6 months and 2 years using visual analog scale. RESULTS: Positive responders were 56% at 1 week, 46% at 1 month, 18% at 6 months, and 13% at 2 years after PRN in group I, and 78.9% at 1 week, 75.4% at 1 month, 62.5% at 6 months, and 54.7% at 2 years in group II. Prominent local tenderness, percussion tenderness, pain on getting up, extension and transitional movement, radiating pain on buttock and/or posterior thigh, and good immediate response were found to be significantly related to outcome. And age, sex, symptom duration, bilateral symptoms, favorable imaging study results, previous lumbar surgery, and degrees of pain relief from diagnostic block were not. CONCLUSION: Percutaneous radiofrequency neurotomy on the posterior primary ramus has long-term beneficial effect, without any morbidity in our series. And the long-term good results will be anticipated after proper selection among patients with facet joints related low back pain.

The Efficacy of Radiofrequency Neurotomy of the Ramus Communicans Nerve for Intractable Chronic Discogenic Pain / 대한마취과학회지

BACKGROUND: Chronic discogenic pain is commonly intractable to various conservative treatments and anatomic correction through operation. Nowadays, a radiofrequency thermocoagualation technique applying the pathophysiologic mechanism that cause discogenic pain and the pathways of transmission of discogenic pain have been successfully tried. This study was performed to evaluate the efficacy of radiofrequecy thermocoagulation of the ramus communicans nerve in patients who suffered from intractable discogenic pain even after intradiscal electrothermal therapy. METHODS: The authors evaluated 13 cases in which radiofrequency thermocoagulation of the ramus communicans nerve was used for patients suffering from chronic discogenic pain even after intradiscal electrothermotherapy. Ten weeks after the procedure, we compared VAS scores of the pre- procedure and post-procedure state. RESULTS: Fifty-four percent of patients had an excellent decrease in the VAS score (VAS < 3). One patient complained of a mild motor weakness of the lower extremity but recovered completely by postoperative day 26. CONCLUSIONS: In the cases of intractable chronic discogenic pain, it is valuable to perform a rhizotomy of the ramus communicans nerve with radiofrequency.