Selective Peripheral Denervation for the Treatment of Spasmodic Torticollis

OBJECTIVE: Various methods of treatment for idiopathic cervical dystonia have been tried in the past with unsatisfactory results. The authors report cases of five patients who underwent selective peripheral denervation for spasmodic torticollis. METHODS: Between July 2002 and December 2003, 5 patients underwent surgery at St. Mary's Hospital for spasmodic torticollis. Age of the patient at the onset of symptoms ranged from 29 to 56years (mean 43.75years). Selective peripheral denervation(SPD) was performed at 7 to 11months after the onset of symptoms (mean 8.75 months). A patient was considered to be the candidate for surgery if conservative methods were unsuccessful and symptoms persisted for longer than 7months. In addition, 2patients who refused treatment with botulinum toxin were also enrolled in this study. RESULTS: Although one patient underwent reoperation, all of the five patients' symptoms were improved after the operation. Clinically, patients with retrocollis showed better improvement than laterocollis patients. CONCLUSION: Although injection of botulinum toxin is the first-choice in treatment modality, when surgery is required, selective peripheral denervation provides good results with minimum side effects.

Effectiveness of Selective Peripheral Denervation for the Treatment of Spasmodic Torticollis

OBJECTIVE: The Bertrand's method of selective peripheral denervation for spasmodic torticollis has already been established as being an effective and safe method. However, such effectiveness has not yet been established in Korea. The authors have performed several cases of selective denervation for the treatment of spasmodic torticollis and we hereby describe the details of the operative method to determine the effectiveness of the method. METHODS: Ten patients who had the selective denervation for the spasmodic torticollis from October 1997 to December 2003, were analyzed. There were 4 rotational and 6 combined types (3 rotational plus retrocollis, 3 rotational plus laterocollis). We performed preoperative electromyograms and neck muscle tonograms in all cases. The technique was used to involve denervation of the ipsilateral posterior paraspinal muscles. Denervation of the sternocleidomastoid muscle was performed on the contralateral side for rotational torticollis and on the ipsilateral side for laterocollis combined type. The surgery was followed by a rigorous physical therapy program. RESULTS: The surgical results were divided into 4 groups labeled excellent, good, fair, and poor. There were 5 excellent patients who showed no detectable abnormal movements, 4 good patients who showed slight residual deviations or slight residual abnormal movements, and 1 fair patient with appreciable residual abnormal movements. Postoperative pain was well tolerated. There was no significant surgical complications. CONCLUSION: The study confirms that selective peripheral denervation for the treatment of spasmodic torticollis is a very useful and safe surgical technique.

Effects and Complications of the Upper Cervical Rhizotomy in Spasmodic Torticollis

To determine the effects and its complications of ventral cervical and selective spinal accessory nerve rhizotomy in the spasmodic torticollis, 14 patients who had undergone surgery between 1989 and 1997 were reviewed retrospectively. In overall twenty four operations were performed. The ventral cervical rhizotomy with spinal accessory nerve rhizotomy were performed in nine patients and the ventral cervical rhizotomy without spinal accessory nerve rhizotomy were done in two patients. Five cases of sternocleidomastoid myotomy with or without peripheral accessory neurectomy, and the five cases of peripheral accessory neurectomy were also performed. In two patients, the selective peripheral denervations were performed. In overall thirteen patients(93%) showed improvement in their condition. Of the eleven patients with the ventral cervical rhizotomy and spinal accessory nerve rhizotomy, nine patients(82%) improved. Five patients suffered from dysphagia or dysphonia postoperatively for several months, but one patient is having more than two years. Of these six patients, five patients had undergone the bilateral upper cervical rhizotomy and bilateral accessory nerve rhizotomy. Therefore to reduce the postoperative dysphagia or dysphonia, the authors recommend to save the unilateral cervical ventral roots or unilateral accessory nerve root. The authors also stress that the selective peripheral denervation would be the choice of operation in cases with the spasmodic torticollis because of its effectiveness and rarity of complications.