ABSTRACT
Objective:To empirically evaluate the impact of the reform of separating drug sales from medical services reform on the operation of public hospitals in Beijing. Methods:Taking R hospital as a case study,Twenty-six clinical departments were selected as samples, and the indicators which have significant change after medical reform were analyzed by descriptive statistics,Pairing test,Correlation test and Spearman correlation test. 24 tested indicators included workload,cost and medication behavior. Results:After the Beijing medical reform between May to September 2017,and from May to September 2016, R hospital workload and cost indicators changed in varying degrees. There were differences between the two groups in terms of the internal medicine and surgery,and the medi-cation behavior had no significant change. Conclusion:The effect of Beijing's healthcare reform policy is obvious. R hospital has the trend of decreasing outpatient volume, drug proportion and medical insurance costs. The medical reform policy may have a profound impact on the development of the clinical subject.
ABSTRACT
objective:To analyze the policy impact of separating drug sales from medical services on a certain oncology hospitals in Beijing,and provide the basis for further development and adjustment of the reform. Methods:Using interrupted time series segmented regression model to analyse the instant change and trend change of medical service utilization by outpatient(including tumor-specified outpatient) and overall inpatient services,especially in in-dicators of drug proportion,self-pay ratio,and so on after the reform. Results:Tumor treatment is a relative specific-ity. The proportion of previous inpatients in tumor specialized hospitals ranged between 49.31% and 49.96%, and the actual compensation rates were between 57.05% and 63.57%. In our case analysis, the expenditure of outpa-tients dropped after this reform,with RMB 4.33 monthly decline on average cost and with 2.32 percentage monthly decrease on a self-pay rate. Drug proportion was declined expectedly,and the proportion of outpatient and inpatient drugs immediately decreased by 4.63% and 2.98% respectively after the reform. Therewith consumptive material proportion was raised, and the proportion of outpatient and inpatient materials instantly increased by 0.22% and 1.17% respectively. Conclusion:As per the results of this study,the reform has weakened the economic dependence on drug income in sample hospital and reduced the burden on patients. However,tumor treatment is on rigid demand and brings about a relatively great impact on hospital's finance and medical insurance fund. The rationality regards of cost-shifting should be investigated in the long run.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To evaluate the impact and analyze the mechanism of separating drug sales from medical services reform on the total medical expenditure containment of outpatient services in Beijing. Methods:The monitoring data and historical data from 89 third-level,78 second-level public hospitals,and 206 primary health institutions and community health service agencies,which participated in the reform,were analysed to estimate the impacts on outpa-tient service utilization and service price. The analysis was based on the data of the first and second quarters of 2016 outpatient and emergency department fee changes,and analysis of service utilization and service price factors on the im-pact of changes in outpatient and emergency services mechanism. Results:The total outpatients'expenditure in Beijing in the second quarter of 2017 was 17.38 billion yuan,representing a slight decrease of 1.14% than the expenditure in 2016. The growth rate reduced by 2.46%. Expenditure in third-level and second-level hospitals decreased by 2.82% and 3.02%,respectively,with reductions in growth rates of 4.06% and 3.74% respectively. Expenditure in primary institutions increased by 17.09%. The increase rate in the second quarter of 2017 was 26.28%,representing a remark-able increase compared to the rate in 2016(15.84%). The contribution from the medical institution service prices and service utilization to the change of outpatient and emergency medical expenditure containment was 6.98% and -7. 65%,respectively. For third-level hospitals,the contribution was 10.37% and -12.00%,respectively;second-level hospitals were 0.72% and -3.35%,respectively;and the primary health institutions was 6.08% and 9.57%. Con-clusions:Beijing's comprehensive reform of separating drug sales from medical services reform has effectively controlled the rising medical expenditure of outpatient services,mainly by adjusting outpatients service utilization between differ-ent level healthcare institutions.
ABSTRACT
Objective:To evaluate the effect of separating drug sales from medical services on hospital revenue and medical services in the county-level public hospitals of Guangxi. Methods:The controlled before and after study design was employed. 2009 to 2012 was the pre-intervention period;2013 was the intervention period. Pilot people’s hospitals were included in the intervention group;non-pilot people’s hospitals were included in the control group. Da-ta came from hospitals and new rural cooperative medical statistics from 2009 to 2013 and the Guangxi Statistical Yearbook from 2010 to 2014. The analysis method of difference-in-differences based regression was employed. Re-sults:Separating drug sales from medical services included cancelling medicine markups, increasing price of inspec-tion and nursing services, reducing price of large equipment inspection services and increasing financial assistance. In terms of hospital revenue, compared with non-pilot hospitals, for pilot hospitals, the reform reduced medicine rev-enues by 3. 326 million yuan and increased medical revenue by 10. 75 million yuan. There was no significant change in financial assistance. In terms of medical expenses, compared with non-pilot hospitals, the reform reduced per-visit outpatient drug expenses in pilot hospitals by 3. 51 yuan, increased per-visit outpatient inspection fees by 2. 23 yuan, reduced per-visit inpatient drug expenses by 133. 5 yuan, increased per-visit inpatient inspection fees by 62. 01 yuan, and increased per-visit inpatient nursing fees by 69. 72 yuan. There were no significant change in outpatient and inpa-tient visits, length of stay, outpatient expenses per-visit and inpatient expenses per-visit. Conclusion:County hospi-tals can offset losses due to cancelling medicine markups by medical service pricing adjustment in inpatient departments;in outpatient departments, they can offset losses due to cancelling medicine markups by both medical service pricing ad-justments and medical service utilization adjustments beyond policy adjustments. The reform did not reduce the operating revenue of pilot hospitals or the medical expenses per visit. The reform had little effect on hospital and doctor incentives.