ABSTRACT
Resumo Introdução A modificação físico-química da superfície de mini-implantes utilizados no suporte de overdentures pode influenciar o desempenho mecânico dos mesmos. Objetivo Avaliar a influência de um tratamento de superfície do tipo nanométrico no desempenho mecânico de novos designs de mini-implantes. Material e método Foram utilizados 40 mini-implantes (Ti-6Al-4V), com Ø 2 mm × 10 mm de comprimento e dois designs diferentes, rosqueado e helicoidal, divididos em quatro grupos (n=10), de acordo com o modelo e a presença ou a ausência de tratamento superficial. O desempenho mecânico foi avaliado por meio de torque de inserção e ensaio de arrancamento em cilindros ósseos suínos. Análise de variância ANOVA e teste de Tukey, com significância de 5%, foram utilizados para análise estatística dos dados. Resultado Foi observada diferença estatisticamente significante entre os grupos com e sem tratamento para torque de inserção (p<0,001), e ensaio de arrancamento (p=0,006), sendo a maior média para o grupo com tratamento, independentemente do design. Na comparação entre os designs, o rosqueado apresentou média significativamente maior (p<0,001) que o helicoidal. Conclusão: O tratamento de superfície nanométrico viabilizou melhor desempenho mecânico dos mini-implantes avaliados. Com relação aos novos designs testados, o rosqueado apresentou resultados superiores ao helicoidal.
Abstract Introduction The physical-chemical modification of the surface of mini-implants used in the support of overdentures can influence the mechanical performance and survival of the same. Objective To evaluate the influence of a nanometric surface treatment on the mechanical performance of new mini-implant designs. Material and method 40 mini-implants (Ti-6Al-4V) with Ø 2 mm x 10 mm in length and two different designs, threaded and helical, were divided into four groups (n = 10) according to model, presence or absence of surface treatment. The mechanical performance was evaluated by means of insertion torque and pullout test in swine bony cylinders. Analysis of variance ANOVA and Tukey test, with significance of 5% were used for statistical analysis of the data. Result A statistically significant difference was observed between the groups with and without treatment for insertion torque (p <0.001) and pullout test (p = 0.006), being the highest mean for the treatment group, regardless of the design. In the comparison between the designs, the thread presented a significantly higher average (p <0.001) than the helicoid. Conclusion The nanometric surface treatment enabled better mechanical performance of the mini-implants evaluated. With respect to the new designs tested, the thread presented superior results to the helicoidal one.
Subject(s)
Dental Implants , Torque , Efficiency , Surface Properties , Denture, OverlayABSTRACT
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Wear as a result of repeated closing/opening cycles may decrease the friction coefficient of screw head, threads, and other mating components and, consequently, resistance to opening gradually decreases. It may cause screw loosening, which is one of the most common failures in implant prosthesis. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the changes on the head and thread surface of the abutment screws after repeated closing and opening through the examination of tested screws in SEM(scanning electron microscope). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five species of abutments were selected (3i-three, Avana- two) respectively by two pieces. The implant fixtures were perpendicularly mounted in liquid unsaturated polyesther(Epovia, Cray Valley Inc.) with dental surveyor. Each abutment was secured to the implant fixture by each abutment screw with recommended torque value using a digital torque controller. The abutment screws were repeatedly tightened and removed 20 times with a digital controller. FESEM (field emission scanning electron microscope, Netherland, Phillips co., model:XL 30 SFEG) was used to observe changes of each part caused by repeatedly closing/opening expeiment. First, the Photomicrographs of pre-test screws provided by each manufacturer were taken. The changes of each screw were investigated after every fifth closing and opening experiment with FESEM. Scaning electron microscope photomicrographs of each screw were taken four times. RESULTS: As the number of closing and opening was increased, the wear or distortion of hexed or squared slot that contacted with the driver tip was more severely progressed. Wear or distortion of hexed slot was more severe than that of squared slot and it was more remarkable in the titanium screw than in the gold screw. All the tested screws showed that the width in the crest of their screw thread decreased gradually as the test was proceeded. CONCLUSIONS: Conclusively, we recommend the clinical use of gold screw, a periodic exchanges of abutment screws and avoiding repeated closing/opening unnecessarily. We also suggest a more careful manipulation of the abutment screw and screw-driver and using of abutment screw with an acute-angled slot design rather than an obtuse-angled one. Finally, it is suggested that the new slot design and the surface treatment for enduring wear or distortion should be devised.
Subject(s)
Friction , Head , Prostheses and Implants , Titanium , TorqueABSTRACT
STATEMETN OF PROBLEM: Surface alteration of the implant screws after function may be asso-ciated with mechanical failure. Theses metal fatigue appears to be the most common cause of structural failure. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate surface alteration of the implant screws after function through the examination of used and unused implant screws in SEM(scanningelectron microscope). MATERIAL AND METHODS: In this study, abutment screws(Steri-oss, 3i), gold retaining screw(3i) and titanium retaining screw(3i) were retrieved from patients. New, unused abutment and retain-ing screws were prepared for control group. Each of the old, used screws was retrieved with a screwdriver. And retrieved implant complex of Steri-oss system was prepared for this study. Then, SEM investigation and EDS analysis of abutment and retaining screws were per-formed. And SEM investigation of cross-sectioned sample of retrieved implant complex was performed. RESULTS: In the case of new, unused implant screws, as maunfactured circumferential grooves are regularly examined and screw thread are sharply remained. Before ultrasonic cleans-ing of old, used implant screw, a lot of accumulation and corrosion products were existed. After ultrasonic cleansing of old, used implant screws, circumferential grooves as examined before function were randomly deepened and scratches increased. Also, dull screw thread was examined. More surface alterations after function were examined in titanium screw than gold screw. And more surface alteration was examined when retrieved with driver than retrieved without driver. CONCLUSIONS: These surface alteration after function may result in the screw instability. Regularly cleansing and exchange of screws was recommended. We recommend the use of gold screw rather than titanium screw, and careful manipulation of the driver.