Predictors of Long Term Prognosis of Dysphagia in Tonsil Cancer Patients / 대한연하장애학회지

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the factors affecting long-term prognosis for dysphagia in tonsil cancer patients, after treatment. METHOD: This was a retrospective study of subjects who underwent a videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS) following treatment for stage 3 or 4 tonsil cancer. Data including sex, age, cancer characteristics, and methods of cancer treatment were collected. To evaluate the swallowing-related outcome, we collected data including findings regarding the last VFSS, method of feeding, and history of aspiration pneumonia requiring in-patient care. We evaluated the correlation between these data and the characteristics of cancer and treatment methods. RESULT: Among 32 subjects included in this study, eight had aspiration or penetration confirmed by the last VFSS. There were no significant differences in swallowing-related factors according to the presence of aspiration or penetration in the last VFSS. Patients who underwent curative tonsillectomy retained more residues on the last VFSS than those who did not. CONCLUSION: Among subjects with tonsil cancer, history of curative tonsillectomy was correlated with more pharyngeal residue. However, other cancer- or treatment-related factors did not affect the outcome of swallowing.

Diagnosis of Spasmodic Dysphonia Manifested by Swallowing Difficulty in Videofluoroscopic Swallowing Study

Spasmodic dysphonia is defined as a focal laryngeal disorder characterized by dystonic spasms of the vocal cord during speech. We described a case of a 22-year-old male patient who presented complaining of idiopathic difficulty swallowing that suddenly developed 6 months ago. The patient also reported pharyngolaryngeal pain, throat discomfort, dyspnea, and voice change. Because laryngoscopy found no specific problems, an electrodiagnostic study and videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS) were performed to find the cause of dysphagia. The VFSS revealed continuous twitch-like involuntary movement of the laryngeal muscle around the vocal folds. Then, he was diagnosed with spasmodic dysphonia by VFSS, auditory-perceptual voice analysis, and physical examination. So, we report the first case of spasmodic dysphonia accompanied with difficulty swallowing that was confirmed by VFSS.

The Effect of Balloon Dilatation through Video-Fluoroscopic Swallowing Study (VFSS) in Stroke Patients with Cricopharyngeal Dysfunction

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate an effect of balloon catheter dilatation on post-swallow laryngeal elevation, total pharyngeal transit time and pharyngeal remnant in stroke patients with cricopharyngeal dysfunction. METHOD: The 20 stroke patients with cricopharyngeal dysfunction in videofluoroscopic swallow study were recruited for the study. Using 16 Fr foley catheter, balloon was positioned across the upper esophageal sphincter under video-fluoroscopy. Balloon catheter dilatation was done for 3 minutes and each ballooning was repeated 6 times for a minute. We compared pre-balloon dilatation and post-balloon dilatation values. 3 factors were evaluated, which were laryngeal elevation, total pharyngeal transit time, and post-swallow pharyngeal remnant. RESULTS: There was no significant difference in laryngeal elevation after balloon dilatation. However, total pharyngeal transit time (p<0.01) and pharyngeal remnant (p<0.001) were significantly reduced after balloon dilatation. CONCLUSION: There were significant decrements of post-swallow total pharyngeal transit time and pharyngeal remnant after balloon dilation procedure. Balloon dilation of upper esophageal sphincter can produce relief of dysphagia in stroke patients with cricopharyngeal dysfunction.

Clinical Usefulness of Schedule for Oral-Motor Assessment (SOMA) in Children with Dysphagia

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the clinical usefulness of the Schedule for Oral-Motor Assessment (SOMA) in children with dysphagia by comparing findings of SOMA with those of the videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS). METHOD: Both SOMA and VFSS were performed in 33 children with dysphagia (21 boys and 12 girls; mean age 17.3+/-12.1 months) who were referred for oropharyngeal evaluation. Ratings of oral-motor functions indicated by SOMA were based upon the cutting score of each specific texture of food (puree, semi-solids, solids, cracker, liquid-bottle, and liquid-cup). Abnormalities of either the oral phase, or the pharyngeal phase as indicated by VFSS were assessed by a physician and a speech-language pathologist. RESULTS: There was significant consistency between the findings of SOMA and the oral phase evaluation by VFSS (Kappa=0.419, p=0.023). SOMA reached 87.5% sensitivity, 66.6% specificity, and 95.4% positive predictive value when compared with the oral phase of the VFSS. We were able to evaluate oral-motor function by using SOMA in 6 children who were unable to complete the oral phase evaluation by VFSS, due to fear and crying during the study. The findings of SOMA failed to show any consistency with the pharyngeal phase evaluation by VFSS (Kappa=-0.105, p=0.509). CONCLUSION: These results suggest that SOMA is a reliable method for evaluation of oral-motor function in children with dysphagia. In particular, SOMA is recommended for children that were unable to complete the oral phase evaluation by VFSS due to poor cooperation.

Rick Factors Associated with Aspiration in Patients with Head and Neck Cancer

OBJECTIVE: To determine the major risk factors and abnormal videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS) findings associated with aspiration in patients with head and neck cancer (HNC). METHOD: Risk factors associated with aspiration were investigated retrospectively in 241 patients with HNC using medical records and pre-recorded VFSS. Age, gender, lesion location and stage, treatment factors, and swallowing stage abnormalities were included. RESULTS: Aspiration occurred in 50.2% of patients. A univariate analysis revealed that advanced age, increased duration from disease onset to VFSS, higher tumor stage, increased lymph node stage, increased American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) stage, operation history, chemotherapy history, and radiotherapy history were significantly associated with aspiration (p<0.05). Among them, advanced age, increase AJCC stage, operation history, and chemotherapy history were significantly associated with aspiration in the multivariate analysis (p<0.05). Delayed swallowing reflex and reduced elevation of the larynx were significantly associated with aspiration in the multivariate analysis (p<0.05). CONCLUSION: The major risk factors associated with aspiration in patients with HNC were advanced age, higher AJCC stage, operation history, and chemotherapy history. A VFSS to evaluate aspiration is needed in patients with NHC who have these risk factors. Delayed swallowing reflex and reduced elevation of the larynx were major abnormal findings associated with aspiration. Dysphagia rehabilitation should focus on these results.

Digital Image Motion Analysis of the Pharyngeal Movement during Swallowing in Dysphagia Patients

OBJECTIVE: To reveal basic mechanism regarding the swallowing difficulty in stroke and inflammatory myopathy patients, and to compare this with normal persons. METHOD: Five volunteers without any swallowing problems, three inflammatory myopathy patients and five stroke patients with swallowing difficulty and a similar movement of the hyoid bone were included in this study. Videofluoroscopic swallowing studies were performed in all subjects, and their videofluoroscopic motions were analyzed through 2-dimensional motion analysis using the APAS (Ariel Performance Analysis System). RESULTS: The motions of the hyoid bone and the epiglottis of the inflammatory myopathy patients were much smaller than those of the volunteers but their pattern was similar to the volunteers. Although the difference in the displacement of the hyoid bone and epiglottis between the stroke patients and volunteers was low, the movement pattern between them was different. During an excursion of the hyoid bone, there was an interruption in its motion, which may be due to the spasticity of the cricopharyngeal muscle. CONCLUSION: In inflammatory myopathy patients, the cause of the dysphagia is a weakness of the swallow-related muscles but in stroke patients, spasticity of the upper esophageal constrictor muscle, i.e. the cricopharyngeal muscle, may be another cause. Relieving the spasticity of the cricopharyngeal muscle as well as strengthening of the swallow-related muscles should be considered when treating stroke patients with dysphagia.

Pattern of Post-Stroke Swallowing Disorder according to the Brain Lesion

OBJECTIVE: Post-stroke dysphagia occurs in the form of lingual discoordination, pharyngeal dysmotility, and delayed swallowing reflex. The purpose of this study is to define the pattern of post-stroke swallowing disorder according to the location of brain lesion. METHOD: Thirty-nine post-stroke patients and ten normal persons participated to perform the videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS) with fluid and semisolid gastrograffin. Brain lesions were classified by cortical, subcortical, or brainstem groups and by the involved hemisphere. RESULTS: There was no difference of swallowing pattern between the cortical and subcortical lesions. However patients with brainstem lesion more frequently showed incomplete laryngeal elevation, prolonged pharyngeal transit time, failure of cricopharyngeal muscle relaxation, and aspiration than with cortical and subcortical lesions (p<0.01). In the patients with cortical and subcortical lesions, aspiration occurred before the laryngeal elevation due to discoordination of laryngopharynx. Whereas in the brainstem lesion, aspiration occurred after the laryngeal elevation due to incomplete laryngeal closure. Premature posterior spillage (p<0.05), poor laryngeal elevation(p<0.05), and tracheal aspiration (p<0.01) were more frequently seen in the patients with right hemispheric dysfunction than the left. CONCLUSION: Discoordination of the tongue, oropharynx, and laryngopharynx is predominant in the cortical and subcortical lesion, whereas incomplete laryngeal closure and failure of cricopharyngeal muscle relaxation are predominant in the brianstem lesion.

Swallowing Disorders Following Head and Neck Cancer Surgery

OBJECTIVE: This study was designed to examine swallowing function of 16 head and neck surgical patients who had postoperative swallowing difficulties and to identify the relationship between the physiologic causes of aspiration and the surgical procedure in each patient. METHOD: Group A was five patients who had partial pharyngolaryngectomy due to hypopharyngeal cancer, Group B was nine patients who had wide excision due to oral cavity cancer, and Group C was two patients who had supraglottic horizontal laryngectomy due to supraglottic laryngeal cancer. Their swallowing function was evaluated with videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS). RESULTS: Aspiration occurred in 40% of patients with partial pharyngolaryngectomy, 44% of patients with wide excision, and 100% of patients with supraglottic horizontal laryngectomy. Group A showed swallowing difficulty because of reduced laryngeal closure and reduced pharyngeal peristalsis. Group B showed swallowing difficulty because of reduced pharyngeal peristalsis, reduced laryngeal function, and impaired tongue control. Group C showed swallowing difficulty for impaired tongue control, reduced laryngeal function, reduced pharyngeal peristalsis, and late swallowing reflex. Most of the patients who had had head and neck cancer surgery can regain normal swallowing function after adequate swallowing rehabilitation. CONCLUSION: Each group of head and neck surgical patients had different cause of swallowing difficulty. The knowledge of the determinant component of swallowing pathophysiology is important for successful swallowing rehabilitation.