ABSTRACT
In recent years， as people's diets have changed and diversified， the incidence of dental arthritis has increased year by year， seriously affecting the quality of life of patients. Therefore， the prevention and treatment of dental arthritis should be emphasized. To further study the pathogenesis of dental arthritis and the development and screening of therapeutic drugs， this paper summarized and analyzed the modeling methods， mechanisms， as well as the advantages and disadvantages of the existing animal models of dental arthritis. The clinical diagnostic criteria of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） and western medicine was established， and the compatibility of TCM and western medicine anastomosis in animal models was evaluated. The results showed that the gel perfusion model had a good match between TCM and western medicine， with simple operation and short cycle. By combining the pathogenic factors of TCM and western medicine， the models of kidney deficiency and stomach heat with kidney deficiency in TCM were obtained， which fully reflected the clinical syndrome characteristics of TCM and western medicine， thus simulating the pathogenesis of human natural dental arthritis. Besides， ligation line model， as the most commonly-used animal model of dental arthritis with a good match to western medicine， was mature and highly repeatable， and had a high success rate. Ligation line model was widely used in various periodontal disease studies， but it did not involve the pathogenic factors of TCM. The current animal model of dental arthritis is given priority to western medicine disease model， and the combination of disease and model is rare， which cannot meet the requirements of the syndrome characteristics of TCM. Only an animal model of dental arthritis with TCM syndrome that conforms to the clinical syndrome characteristics effectively assists to study the nature of TCM syndrome and develop innovative Chinese medicine. Therefore， the establishment of an accurate and standardized animal model of dental arthritis combined with TCM and western medicine is still the focus of future study on the pathogenesis of dental arthritis. This study is intended to provide a certain basis for the discovery， screening， and evaluation of medicines for the treatment of dental arthritis.
ABSTRACT
Based on the clinical characteristics of multiple sclerosis （MS） in traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） and western medicine and literature analysis， this paper aims to formulate the diagnostic criteria of TCM and western medicine for MS. Moreover， the modeling methods of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis （EAE）， animals for the modeling， and characteristics of the models were analyzed and summarized， and the consistency between the EAE models and the diagnostic criteria of TCM and western medicine was evaluated. The results showed that animal models had low consistency with the clinical characteristics in TCM （highest consistency 68%） and western medicine （highest consistency 60%）. Pathological models account for the majority of animal models for MS research， but there is a lack of intuitive performance indicators. Thus， it is difficult to comprehensively evaluate the models. The mental state， limb numbness， lack of strength， loss of muscle tone， tremor， and balance disorders of the mice are among the diagnostic criteria in western medicine. In TCM diagnostic criteria， the major symptoms which are reflected in animal behavior， such as physical fatigue， lack of strength， mental fatigue， distinclination to talk， and weak heavy numb limbs， are consistent with the western diagnostic criteria. The minor symptoms， including mental decline， bitter taste in mouth， frequent and urgent urination， fecal incontinence， and aggravated fever， are not well reflected in the models. According to TCM， MS is caused by deficiency of kidney essence and external contraction of pathogen， but no index is available for evaluating the external contraction of pathogen in existing animal models. The key to experimental research on MS is to establish an appropriate animal model based on the clinical pathogenesis and characteristics. However， there is a lack of MS animal model with TCM characteristics for syndrome classification. Therefore， renewed efforts should be made to prepare animal models with both TCM and western medicine characteristics that can be used in both basic experiments and clinical research.
ABSTRACT
This study summarized and analyzed the modeling methods， modeling mechanisms， and advantages and disadvantages of existing animal models of acute pancreatitis （AP） with the purposes of replicating animal models more in line with the clinical syndrome characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine （TCM） and Western medicine， improving the basic research of AP， and promoting its in-depth research. Further， the clinical diagnostic criteria of TCM and Western medicine were drawn up， and the agreement was evaluated between animal models of AP and clinical syndrome characteristics of TCM and Western medicine. The results demonstrated that the AP model induced by choline-deficient ethionine-supplemented diet （CDE）-supplemented diet was highly consistent with the clinical syndromes of TCM and Western medicine， which was simple in operation and small in mortality. However， the modeling did not involve the pathogenic factors of TCM. Although many approaches have been proposed to establish animal models of AP so far， most of the models meet the diagnostic criteria of Western medicine but， lacking the manifestation of TCM symptoms， less agree with the clinical syndromes of TCM. At present， animal models of AP alone are mostly used to study the pharmacodynamics and mechanisms of Chinese and Western medicines， which fail to meet the requirements of syndrome differentiation and treatment in TCM theories. Only the animal models of AP which conform to the TCM syndrome characteristics and are basically consistent with clinical syndromes greatly contribute to the essence study of TCM syndromes and the development of innovative Chinese medicines. Therefore， establishing animal models that can simultaneously reflect the clinical syndrome characteristics of AP in both TCM and Western medicine and replicating more realistic， accurate and comprehensive animal models of AP are worthy of further research.