A Tailored Approach for Recurrent Groin Hernias

PURPOSE: Recurrent groin hernias are a significant problem with high recurrence rates. There is a great deal of controversy regarding their management. This study examined the outcome of patients who had undergone a repair of recurrent groin hernias. METHODS: This study examined retrospectively the medical records of all patients who underwent repairs of recurrent groin hernias (a total 239 cases) between January 1998 and December 2006. The repair was tailored to the previous operation and the patients' medical condition. The types of previous operations, present operation, complications and re-recurrence rate were analyzed. RESULTS: Of the 2,542 groin hernias operated on, 239 cases (9.4%) were treated for recurrent groin hernias. The types of previous surgery were conventional open tissue repair in 199 cases (83.3%), Lichtenstein repair in 28 cases (11.7%), open mesh repair (PHS, Perfix plug) in 6 cases (2.5%) and laparoscopic repair in 6 cases (2.5%). The recurrent groin hernias were repaired using a laparoscopic method in 123 cases (51.4%), open mesh repair in 92 cases (38.4%), Lichtenstein repair in 18 cases (7.5%) and a conventional open tissue repair in 6 cases (2.5%). Postoperative complications occurred in 40 cases (16.7%), which included 10 seromas, 4 wound infections, 3 hematomas, 2 wound swellings, 8 scrotal swelling, 5 dysurias, 2 chronic neuralgias. There were 6 cases of re-recurrence in the 239 cases of recurrent groin hernias (2.5%). CONCLUSION: A tailored approach based on the previous repair and the medical condition of the patients with recurrent groin hernias is associated with a decrease in the incidence of major postoperative complications and a low recurrence rate (2.5%).

Experience of Open Herniorrhaphy Using the PerFix(R) Plug for Patients with Recurrent Groin Hernias

PURPOSE: The recurrence of a groin hernia presents few surgical options for repair. We investigated the safety and efficacy of herniorrhaphy using PerFix(R) plug for patients with recurrent groin hernias. METHODS: Between October 2000 and December 2004, 30 herniorrhaphies for recurrent groin hernia were performed and followed-up. The operation time, length of hospital stay, time of analgesic use, complication rates, and recurrence were investigated. RESULTS: Surgery had been initially performed in 26 patients with the non-mesh method, and with mesh in 4 patients; 12 patients had a direct recurrence at the medial side of the inguinal area near the pubic tubercle, 7 patients had a direct recurrence at other sites, and 11 patients had an indirect recurrence. Eight patients had urinary retention and 2 patients had minor wound complications. Hospital stays and analgesic use were comparable to non-recurrent groin hernia operations, although operation time was significantly longer in recurrent group, and there were no recurrences during the 70 months of followup. CONCLUSION: Comparing open or laparoscopic preperitoneal approach, the PerFix(R) plug method is simple and effective for recurrent groin hernia repair.