ABSTRACT
La infección tuberculosa (TB) se determina por la prueba tuberculínica (PTC) con PPD, un extracto de proteínas/péptidos de Mycobacterium tuberculosis, algunos compartidos con otras micobacterias como BCG, lo cual origina falsos resultados positivos en vacunados/no infectados. La nuevas pruebas ex vivo miden el interferón ? (IFN- ?) liberado en sangre, o la cantidad de células que lo producen, en presencia de los péptidos ESAT-6 y CFP-10 de M. tuberculosis. Como estos antígenos no existirían en BCG, las pruebas IFN-? diferenciarían infección TB de vacunación. Numerosos estudios han comparado estas pruebas con la PTC con resultados aún no concluyentes. Las pruebas IFN-? tendrían menor sensibilidad que la PTC, aunque su menor positividad en poblaciones vacunadas podría interpretarse como mayor especificidad. Por otra parte, la vacunación BCG, si no es reciente, no es causa de falsos positivos a la PTC: reacciones =10 mm o =15 mm indican infección TB con altísima probabilidad. Donde la incidencia de TB es mediana o alta, la PTC aventaja en costo-eficiencia a las pruebas IFN-?, siempre que se emplee PPD de calidad garantizada, disponible en todos los centros de salud del país, con aplicación, lectura e interpretación estandarizadas. Como existen en la Argentina problemas de abastecimiento de PPD importado, es preciso producirlo localmente y asegurar su control de calidad. También es necesaria la investigación aplicada al desarrollo de nuevos métodos y la evaluación de su capacidad de predecir la evolución de infección a TB activa, es decir, de identificar las personas que más se beneficiarían con quimioprofilaxis.
Tuberculosis (TB) infection is currently being diagnosed by the tuberculin skin test (TST) with PPD. Some Mycobacterium tuberculosis PPD components are present in BCG, which can be the cause of false positive TST results in BCG vaccinated persons. New IFN-? release assays (IGRAs) are based on the ex vivo release of IFN-? by peripheral blood cells in presence of M. tuberculosis antigens ESAT-6 and CFP-10, which should be absent in BCG. These assays consist in either quantifying released IFN-? or enumerating IFN-? producing cells. In principle, IGRAs should differentiate true TB infection from vaccination and results of several studies suggest that these assays display lower positivity than TST. Whether the lower positivity could be attributed to higher specificity or to lower sensitivity as compared with PPD is still unclear. BCG vaccination, if not recently applied, cannot be blamed for false positive TST reactions. Strong TST reactions (=10 mm or =15 mm) are highly correlated with TB infection. In settings where TB continues being a serious health problem, cost-effectiveness evaluations would privilege TST under certain conditions: supply of quality-assured PPD reagent, standardized criteria for TST application, reading and interpretation, and regular availability in health centers countrywide. In view of current limitations in the supply of imported PPD in Argentina, its production/quality assurance should be considered a public health priority. Still, key questions remain to be addressed concerning the role of IGRAs and TST in predicting risk of TB disease, in other words, in identifying persons who will benefit most from chemoprophylaxis.
Subject(s)
Humans , Interferon-gamma/blood , Mycobacterium tuberculosis/immunology , Tuberculin Test , Tuberculosis, Pulmonary/diagnosis , Antigens, Bacterial/immunology , BCG Vaccine/immunology , Cost-Benefit Analysis , Sensitivity and Specificity , Tuberculin Test/economics , Tuberculosis, Pulmonary/bloodABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE To evaluate the clinical application of T-cell based IFN-? release assays(IGRA) for the rapid diagnosis of active tuberculosis.METHODS IFN-? and HIV antibody were detected by using ELISA.Antibody to Mycobacterium tuberculosis was detected by colloidal gold.At the same time,the M.tuberculosis DNA loads were examined by FQ-PCR.Statistical analysis were performed to analyze the correlation of IFN-? with M.tuberculosis antibody and DNA,respectively.RESULTS The sensitivity of TB-IGRA was 90.24%,specificity was 93.34%;the positive rate of TB-IGRA in 82 tuberculosis patients was higher than from sputum smear(64.63%),TB-PCR(76.83%) and tuberculosis antibody(40.24%).CONCLUSIONS As a replacement of TB-PCR,IFN-? can be used as a valued index to evaluate tuberculosis infectin.