Construction of clinical efficacy evaluation system based on optimal clinical experience / 中国中药杂志

Evidence-based medicine plays an important role in promoting the scientific nature of clinical decision-making. Howe-ver, there is a problem where evidence derived from clinical research may not necessarily be applicable to individual patients. Evidence-based medicine has been introduced into the field of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) for over 20 years, and although certain achievements have been made, the overall level of clinical research evidence based on the principles of evidence-based medicine in TCM is not high. The acceptance of TCM diagnosis and treatment guidelines developed based on evidence-based medicine methods is generally low. As revealed by the analysis of the problems in the application of evidence-based medicine in the field of TCM, it is found that there is a structural contradiction between clinical randomized controlled trial(RCT) of TCM and the characteristics of TCM clinical practice. They cannot comprehensively, objectively, and truthfully reflect the clinical efficacy and safety of TCM. Conducting clinical RCTs of TCM in pursuit of "evidence" actually means giving up the advantages of TCM in clinical treatment based on syndrome differentiation, prescription changes along with syndromes, and treatment in accordance with three categories of disease cause, which leads to sacrificing some clinical effectiveness of TCM. Based on the concept of evidence-based medicine, this article proposed the construction of "clinical syndrome-based medicine" based on the optimal clinical experience, which was suitable for the characteristics of TCM clinical practice. The key to clinical syndrome-based medicine is the optimal clinical experience, and the core elements of the optimal clinical experience are regularity and reproducibility. Real-world research methods are recommended as a reference for obtaining the optimal clinical experience. Clinical syndrome-based medicine, combining the characteristics of TCM clinical practice and incorporating the concept of evidence-based medicine, is the product of integrating TCM into evidence-based medicine. It is dedicated to improving the clinical efficacy of TCM along with evidence-based medicine.

Quality requirements of human use experience research on traditional Chinese medicine / 中国中药杂志

The human use experience of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) is of great significance for the development of new traditional Chinese medicine. In 2023, the National Medical Products Administration(NMPA) issued the Special Regulations on Registration Management of Traditional Chinese Medicine, which explicitly encouraged the conduct of high-quality human use experience research on TCM clinical practice to obtain sufficient evidence for registration support. It also required that human use experience research should comply with relevant requirements and undergo registration verification. The quality of human use experience research on TCM directly determines the reliability of the evidence. This article discussed the quality requirements for human use experience research on TCM from the perspectives of basic requirements, organizational management, key pharmaceutical information, scientific research, risk management, ethical compliance, and study implementation and proposed differential treatment in quality requirements and registration verification focus based on different research purposes, stages, and types of studies. While ensuring the authenticity of data, retrospective studies should pay particular attention to the integrity of the data, and prospective studies should focus on the normativity of the data, which may affect the research conclusions. Human use experience research, as part of drug registration materials, falls within the scope of relevant regulatory oversight. Researchers should have a strong awareness of regulations to avoid serious quality issues. The standardized conduct of human use experience research on TCM requires joint efforts from regulatory authorities, applicants, research institutions, and researchers to establish a research quality management system based on the clinical characteristics of TCM.