RESUMEN
Objective:To evaluate the therapeutic effect and the prognosis of the laryngeal function preserving surgery (LFPS) and total laryngectomy in hypophngeal carcinoma.Method:Ninety-three cases of laryngopharynx carcinoma were retrospectively analyzed from September 1974 to September 2006.Among which 57 cases were primary pyriform sinus cancer,20 cases were postero-cricoid cancer and 16 cases were postero-pharyngeal wall cancer.53 cases were treated by LFPS,and 40 cases were treated by total laryngectomy.The treatment effectiveness,complication,survival rate and repair materials were analysed.Result:Adopting Kaplan-Meier survival analysis,the 3-year survival rates were 69.9%and 5-year survival rates were 43.0%.The 3-year survival rates of LFPS and Non-LFPS were 73.6% and 67.5%, and the 5-yenr survival rates of LFPS and Non-LFPS were 49.1% and 32.5%. There was no significant difference between the two groups(χ~2=2.566,P>0.05). Single element analysis indicated survival rates concerned with T-stage(χ~2=9.764,P<0.05), neck lymphatic transfer(χ~2=10.472,P<0.01) and the degree of pathological differentiation(χ~2=25.894,P<0.01).Cox regression analysis suggested that T-stage,the degree of pathological dfferentiaton and wheather going through the surgical operation were the independent elemant of the patient's prognosis.There was no significant difference between LFPS and No-LFPS in the neoplasms location, complication,neoplasms residuum and neoplasms recurrence.Conclusion:LFPS did not affect the survival rates and LFPS was feasible.LFPS can increase the living quality of laryngopharynx careinoma patients.
RESUMEN
OBJECTIVE@#To evaluate the therapeutic effect and the prognosis of the laryngeal function preserving surgery (LFPS) and total laryngectomy in hypopharyngeal carcinoma.@*METHOD@#Ninety-three cases of laryngopharynx carcinoma were retrospectively analyzed from September 1974 to September 2006. Among which 57 cases were primary pyriform sinus cancer, 20 cases were postero-cricoid cancer and 16 cases were postero-pharyngeal wall cancer. 53 cases were treated by LFPS, and 40 cases were treated by total laryngectomy. The treatment effectiveness, complication, survival rate and repair materials were analysed.@*RESULT@#Adopting Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, the 3-year survival rates were 69.9% and 5-year survival rates were 43.0%. The 3-year survival rates of LFPS and Non-LFPS were 73.6% and 67.5%, and the 5-year survival rates of LFPS and Non-LFPS were 49.1% and 32. 5%. There was no significant difference between the two groups (chi2 = 2.566, P > 0.05). Single element analysis indicated survival rates concerned with T-stage (chi2 = 9.764, P < 0.05), neck lymphatic transfer (chi2 = 10.472, P < 0.01) and the degree of pathological differentiation (chi2 = 25.894, P < 0.01). Cox regression analysis suggested that T-stage, the degree of pathological differentiation and whether going through the surgical operation were the independent element of the patient's prognosis. There was no significant difference between LFPS and No-LFPS in the neoplasms location, complication, neoplasms residuum and neoplasms recurrence.@*CONCLUSION@#LFPS did not affect the survival rates and LFPS was feasible. LFPS can increase the living quality of laryngopharynx carcinoma patients.