The Barriers and Facilitators of Family-Witnessed Resuscitation (FWR) in Adult Patients in the Emergency Department (EDS): A Systematic Review

@#Aims: Aims: When attending family members, the procedure for the resuscitation of cardiac arrest patients remains controversial. There have been conflicts on why healthcare professionals, should include the family during resuscitation. This systematic review seeks to identify the barriers and facilitators related to the FWR of adult patients at Emergency Department. Design: A systematic review was conducted on ten studies. This review utilized a clearly formulated research question then the data was gathered and analysed from the included studies. Data Source: Studies on the barriers and facilitators related to allowing family members to attend were included during January 2020 to May 2020. Methods: A systematic review of studies that investigate the barriers and facilitators of the FWR of adult patients at emergency department. All studies evaluated the barriers and facilitators related to allowing family members to attend cardiopulmonary resuscitation. This systematic review was registered in PROSPERO with the registration number CRD42020169383. Results: This review has demonstrated that the facilitators reduce conflict and provide a supportive presence that builds the emotional adequacy and closure related to the resuscitation. These policies can eliminate barriers, such as conflicts in EDs and negative attitudes, and expedite the accommodation of the professional as well as individual staff’s needs during witnessed resuscitation.

Enfermeria basada en la evidencia: revisión de alcance

RESUMEN Objetivos: Identificar la evidencia científica sobre el concepto, desarrollo y función, de la Enfermería Basada en la Evidencia (EBE) y analizar críticamente esta herramienta, sus elementos facilitadores y barreras para su implementación. Material y Método: Revisión de alcance según propuesta del Joanna Briggs Institute. Se consideró el rango de tiempo entre 1997 y 2019 para recuperar artículos y revisiones en inglés, portugués y español. Se utilizaron descriptores del tesauro Medical Subject Headings y términos booleanos para aplicar las estrategias de búsqueda en 4 bases de datos: PubMed, EBSCOhost, Scopus y Science Direct. Se complementó la búsqueda con la técnica de bola de nieve aplicada a la lista de referencias de los artículos relevantes seleccionados. Para evaluar la validez y el impacto de los resultados de los artículos de revisión y cualitativos se aplicó el Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Español (CASPE), y para estudios observacionales el Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE). Para establecer los niveles de evidencia se utilizó Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTPFCHC). Resultados: De 163.074 manuscritos iniciales, fueron seleccionados 44 para análisis y extraer datos referentes a: Historia de la EBE; Concepto y función de EBE; Etapas, barreras y facilitadores. Conclusiones: El concepto de EBE pone de manifiesto la necesidad de utilizar esta herramienta para planificar los cuidados mediante el uso del pensamiento crítico y reflexivo; la importancia de realizar el cuidado a la cabecera del paciente y cultivar un cuidado basado en la mejor evidencia, enmarcado, todo ello, en un contexto de humanización, así como considerar las barreras y facilitadores de esta herramienta.

ABSTRACT Objective: To identify the scientific evidence on the concept, development and function of Evidence-Based Nursing (EBN) and to critically analyze this tool, its facilitating elements and barriers for implementation. Material and Method: Scoping review according to the proposal of the Joanna Briggs Institute. The period between 1997 and 2019 was considered to retrieve articles and reviews in English, Portuguese and Spanish. Medical Subject Headings thesaurus descriptors and Boolean operators were used to apply search strategies in 4 databases: Pubmed, EBSCOhost, Scopus, Science Direct. The search was complemented with the snowball technique applied to the reference list of the relevant selected articles. The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Español (CASPE) was used to assess the validity and impact of the articles review and qualitative results, and the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) was used for the observational studies. To establish the levels of evidence, The Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTPFCHC) was used. Results: Out of 163,074 initial manuscripts, 44 were selected for analysis and data extraction regarding history of EBN; concept and function of EBN; stages, barriers and facilitators. Conclusions: The concept of EBN highlights the need to use this tool to plan nursing care through critical and reflective thinking; the importance of providing direct patient care and promoting care based on the best evidence, in a context of humanization and considering the tool's barriers and facilitators.

RESUMO Objetivo: Identificar as evidências científicas sobre o conceito, desenvolvimento e função da Enfermagem Baseada em Evidências (EBE) e analisar criticamente esta ferramenta, seus elementos facilitadores e as barreiras para sua implementação. Material e Método: Revisão do escopo de acordo com a proposta do Instituto Joanna Briggs. Considerou-se o período entre 1997 e 2019 para recuperar artigos e revisões em inglês, português e español. Foram utilizados descritores do tesauro Medical Subject Headings e operadores booleanos para aplicar estratégias de pesquisa en 4 bancos de dados diferentes: Pubmed, EBSCOhost, Scopus, Science Direct. A pesquisa foi complementada com a técnica de bola de neve aplicada à lista de referência dos artigos selecionados relevantes. O Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Español (CASPE) foi usado para avaliar a validade e o impacto da revisão dos artigos e os resultados qualitativos, e para os estudos de observação utilizou-se o Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE). A Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTPFCHC) foi utilizada para establecer os níveis de evidência. Resultados: Dos 163.074 manuscritos iniciais, 44 foram selecionados para análise e extração de dados referentes à história da EBN; conceito e função da EBN; etapas, barreiras e facilitadores. Conclusões: O conceito de EBN destaca a necessidade de utilizar esta ferramenta de planejamento de cuidado, através do uso do pensamento crítico e reflexivo; a importância de realizar o cuidado à beira do leito do paciente e promover cuidados baseados nas melhores evidências, em um contexto de humanização e considerando as barreiras e facilitadores desta ferramenta.

Evaluación de una intervención educativa para mejorar el consumo de frutas, vegetales y la actividad física de docentes en tres centros educativos públicos en Costa Rica / Evaluation of an educational intervention to improve teachers' fruit and vegetable intake and physical activity practice in three public schools in Costa Rica

Resumen: Introducción: El modelo Póngale Vida ® para la prevención de la obesidad infantil reconoce a docentes de las escuelas como actores clave para esta labor, pero para ello se requiere fortalecer los conocimientos y las prácticas para la promoción de la alimentación saludable y la actividad física de los escolares. Objetivo: Evaluar los resultados de la intervención educativa para mejorar la autoeficacia en consumo de frutas y vegetales y en actividad física en docentes de tres centros educativos públicos urbanos de Costa Rica. Metodología: Se aplicó y evaluó la propuesta educativa de Jara y Rivera (2011) con 70 docentes. Hubo evaluaciones antes y después de la aplicación de la intervención. Las variables evaluadas fueron demográficas, de estilo de vida y medición de la autoeficacia para actividad física y consumo de frutas y vegetales, valoraciones bioquímicas y antropométricas. A través de grupos focales, se identificó tanto facilitadores como barreras a nivel personal, familiar y laboral. Resultados: Posterior a la intervención, casi 25 % de docentes incrementó la práctica de actividad física y la autoeficacia para las prácticas de actividad física y consumo de frutas y vegetales. Las barreras identificadas fueron la doble carga de trabajo asociada al rol de género femenino, creencias limitantes y la falta de urgencia para la prevención de enfermedades. Conclusiones: La propuesta educativa favoreció el aumento de la autoeficacia en el consumo de frutas y vegetales, así como la práctica de actividad física de la población docente.

Abstract: Introduction: The Póngale Vida ® model for the prevention of childhood obesity recognizes schoolteachers as key actors in this work, but this requires strengthening their knowledge and practices to promote healthy eating and physical activity for school children. Objective: To evaluate an educational intervention to increase teacher's self-efficacy for fruit and vegetable consumption and physical activity, within three public schools in Costa Rica. Methods: Jara and Rivera's educational proposal for intervention (2011) was implemented and evaluated with 70 teachers. There were evaluations before and after the intervention, it had demographic characteristics, lifestyle variables, self-efficacy measurements for physical activity and fruit and vegetables consumption; also, biochemical and anthropometric measures. Focus groups were used to identify facilitators and barriers at personal, family and work levels. Results: After the intervention, almost 25% of teachers increased their physical activity practices, as well as self efficacy for physical activity practice and fruits and vegetables consumption. The main barriers were a double work burden linked with feminine gender roles, limiting beliefs, and, lack of urgency in preventing diseases. Conclusions: The educational intervention contributed in increasing self-efficacy regarding eating fruit and vegetables and the practice of physical activity of participating teachers.

Barreiras e facilitadores para a atividade física em pessoas com déficit intelectual / Barriers and facilitators to physical activity people with intellectual disability

O objetivo deste estudo foi descrever as barreiras e os facilitadores da prática de atividade física (AF) no tempo livre e sua associação com essa prática em pessoas maiores de seis anos de ambos os sexos com déficit intelectual (DI) inseridas nas Associações de Pais e Amigos dos Excepcionais (APAES). A amostra foi composta por 1.191 pessoas com DI representadas pelos seus responsáveis. As barreiras e facilitadores para a prática de AF foram identificadas com questões fechadas em que o responsável respondia se o fator influenciava sempre (1), influenciava às vezes (2) ou não influenciava (3) na prática de AF. As questões foram separadas em três dimensões que correspondiam a onze fatores de ordem pessoal, sete de ordem ambiental e dez de ordem social. Verificou-se no aspecto pessoal sete facilitadores e duas barreiras, nos quais destaca-se o fato de sentir-se capaz como facilitador associado com a prática de AF e não possuir dinheiro como barreira; no aspecto ambiental seis facilitadores e uma barreira, sendo a companhia de pessoas próximas o principal facilitador pela associação com a prática de AF e a ausência de projetos sociais como barreira; e no aspecto social cinco facilitadores e uma barreira, no qual encontram-se a existência de locais próximos de casa e os profissionais estarem preparados para trabalhar com pessoas com DI os principais facilitadores e a falta de companhia como barreira. Conclui-se que as barreiras e facilitadores de AF para as pessoas com DI podem estar ligados ao estímulo que recebem, pois a companhia de outra pessoa foi o principal facilitador associado com a prática, isto pode ocorrer devido às limitações que a maioria possui no aspecto social. Oferta de locais com qualidade para prática de AF também facilitam a prática de AF, o que pode ser amenizado com o investimento em políticas públicas e projetos sociais de qualidade.

The objective of this study was to describe the barriers and facilitators of free time physical activity (PA), their influence both in this practice of people with intellectual deficit (ID) inserted in APAES / RS. The sample consisted of 1191 ID individuals represented by their legal representatives. The barriers and facilitators for the practice of PA were identified with closed questions in which the respondent answered whether the factor always influences (1), so-metimes influences (2) or does not influence (3) the practice of PA. The issues were separated into three dimensions: personal, environmental and social. As a result, seven facilitators and two barriers were observed in the personal aspect, in which the fact that they feel capable as a facilitator associated with the practice of PA and lack of money as a barrier; In the environmental aspect, six facilitators and a barrier, the company of close people being the main facilitator by the association with the practice of PA and non-existence of social projects as a barrier; And in the social aspect five facilitators and a barrier in which the existence of places close to their homes and professionals prepared to work with people with ID appear as the main facilitators and lack of companion as a barrier. It is concluded that some barriers and facilitators are linked to the stimulus that the people receive, since they can arouse the taste for PA if there is company, providing conditions for the practice due to the limitations that the majority has in the social aspect. Offering quality PA sites also facilitate, which can be provided by the investment in public policies and social projects.

Implementación de la guía de práctica clínica para el manejo de adultos con esquizofrenia en Colombia / Implementation of a Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Adults With Schizophrenia in Colombia

Objetivos: Presentar las estrategias y actividades globales que permitan llevar a la práctica las recomendaciones contenidas en la guía (GPCE). Priorizar las recomendaciones, identificar potenciales barreras y facilitadores, plantear estrategias de solución y desarrollar un sistema de seguimiento y evaluación de la implementación de las recomendaciones contenidas en la GPCE. Método: Durante el proceso de elaboración de la GPCE, se incluyeron profesionales con dedicación primordial a implementación. En las reuniones identificaron estos tópicos y posteriormente se complementaron con revisiones de literatura sobre implementación de guías de esquizofrenia. Se tuvieron en cuenta las discusiones planteadas en las reuniones de socialización, y las reuniones conjuntas con el Ministerio de Salud y Protección Social y el Instituto de Evaluación Tecnológica en Salud. Resultados: El capítulo de implementación de la GPCE incluye la descripción de las potenciales barreras, las estrategias de solución, los facilitadores y los indicadores de seguimiento, estos últimos categorizados por estructura, proceso y resultado. Las barreras identificadas se categorizaron en 3 grupos, haciendo referencia al contexto cultural, el sistema de salud y las intervenciones propuestas. Los temas referentes a estrategias de solución y facilitadoras incluyen programas de educación a la comunidad en salud mental, entrenamiento en salud mental a trabajadores de la salud de atención primaria, descentralización de los servicios de salud mental e integración a nivel primario, utilización de tecnologías de la información y la comunicación y telemedicina. Conclusión: La implementación de la GPCE dentro del Sistema General de Seguridad Social en Salud en Colombia plantea múltiples retos. Las potenciales barreras, estrategias facilitadoras e indicadores de seguimiento y evaluación descritos en el presente artículo, pueden brindar un soporte eficiente para contribuir al éxito de este proceso en las instituciones prestadoras de servicios de salud que adopten la guía.

Objectives: To present overall strategies and activities for the implementation process of the recommendations contained in the clinical practice guideline for the management of adults with schizophrenia (GPCE) published by the Colombian Ministry of Health and Welfare (MSPS). Prioritize the proposed recommendations, identify barriers and solving strategies to implement the GPCE, and develop a monitoring and evaluation system for the key recommendations. Method: The Guideline Developer Group (GDG) included professionals with primary dedication to implementation issues that accompanied the entire process. During the GDG meetings implementation topics were identified and discussed, and later complemented by literature reviews concerning the experience of mental health guidelines implementation at national and international level. Additionally, feedback from the discussions raised during the socialization meetings, and joint meetings with the MSPS and the Institute of Technology Assessment in Health (IETS) were included. The prioritization of recommendations was made in conjunction with the GDG, following the proposed steps in the methodological guide for the development of Clinical Practice Guidelines with Economic Evaluation in the General System of Social Security in Colombian Health (GMEGPC) using the tools 13 and 14. The conclusions and final adjustments were discussed with the GPCE leaders. Results: The implementation chapter includes a description of the potential barriers, solution strategies, facilitators and monitoring indicators. The identified barriers were categorized in the following 3 groups: Cultural context, health system and proposed interventions. The issues related to solving strategies and facilitating education programs include community mental health, mental health training for health workers in primary care, decentralization and integration of mental health services at the primary care level, use of technologies information and communication and telemedicine. To monitor and evaluate o the implementation process, five (5) indicators were designed one (1) structure, two (2) process and two (2) outcome indicators. Conclusion: The GPCE implementation within the Colombian General health System of Social Security (SGSSSC) poses multiple challenges. Potential barriers, enabling strategies and indicators for monitoring and evaluation described in this article, can provide efficient support to ensure the success of this process in the institutions that will adopt the guideline.