Postoperative Clinical Outcome and Risk Factors for Poor Outcome of Foraminal and Extraforaminal Lumbar Disc Herniation

OBJECTIVE: We evaluated postoperative outcomes in patients who have lumbar foraminal or extraforaminal disc herniation (FELDH) and suggested the risk factors for poor outcomes. METHODS: A total of 234 patients were selected for this study. Pre- and post-operative Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and Korean version Oswestry Disability Index (KODI) were evaluated and the changes of both score were calculated. Outcome was defined as excellent, good, fair, and poor based on Mcnab classification. The percentage of superior facetectomy was calculated by using the Maro-view 5.4 Picture Archiving Communication System (PACS). RESULTS: Paramedian lumbar discectomy was performed in 180 patients and combined lumbar discectomy was performed in 54 patients. Paramedian lumbar discectomy group showed better outcome compared with combined discectomy group. p value of VAS change was 0.009 and KODI was 0.013. The average percentage of superior facetectomy was 33% (range, 0-79%) and it showed negative correlation with VAS and KODI changes (Pearson coefficient : -0.446 and -0.498, respectively). Excellent or good outcome cases (Group I) were 136 (58.1%) and fair or poor outcome cases (Group II) were 98 (41.9%). The percentage of superior facetectomy was 26.5% at Group I and 42.5% at Group II. There was significant difference in superior facetectomy percentage between Group I and II (p=0.000). CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated that paramedian lumbar discectomy with preservation of facet joints is an effective and good procedure for FELDH. At least 60% of facet should be preserved for excellent or good outcomes.

The Comparisons of Surgical Outcomes and Clinical Characteristics between the Far Lateral Lumbar Disc Herniations and the Paramedian Lumbar Disc Herniations

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study is to analyze clinical characteristics and surgical outcomes of the far lateral and the paramedian disc herniations. METHODS: The 88 patients who underwent an operation for lumbar disc herniations were reviewed. Visual analogue scale of leg and back pain, occurrence of sensory dysesthesia and motor deficit before and after operations were used to compare the far lateral with the paramedian disc herniations. RESULTS: Statistically, the far lateral herniations had more severe radicular leg pain and showed more frequent occurrence of sensory dysesthesia than paramedian herniations before operation (p0.05). CONCLUSION: Preoperatively, the far lateral herniations had more severe radicular leg pain and frequent occurrence of sensory dysesthesia. Postoperatively, the sensory dysesthesia was less improved and back pain was more severe in the far lateral herniations.

New Diagnostic Tool for Far Lateral Lumbar Disc Herniation : The Clinical Usefulness of 3-Tesla Magnetic Resonance Myelography Comparing with the Discography CT

OBJECTIVE: To prospectively assess the diagnostic and clinical value of a new technique (3-tesla magnetic resonance myelography, 3T MRM) as compared to computed tomographic discography (disco-CT) in patients with far lateral disc herniation. METHODS: We evaluated 3T MRM and disco-CT of 25 patients, whom we suspected of suffering from far lateral disc herniation. Using an assessment scale, 4 observers examined independently both 3T MRM and disco-CT images. We analyzed observer agreement and the accentuation of each image. RESULTS: We found complete matching, and observer agreement, between high resolution images of 3T MRM and disco-CT for diagnosing far lateral disc herniation. CONCLUSION: We think noninvasive 3T MRM is an appropriate diagnostic tool for far lateral disc herniation as compared to disco-CT.

Clinical Outcome of Minimally Invasive Tubular Retractor Assisted Microscopic Discectomy in Far Lateral Lumbar Disc Herniation

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study is to analyze the clinical outcomes of the minimally invasive approach for the surgical treatment of far lateral lumbar disc herniation. METHODS: Between January 2007 and May 2009, 19 patients who underwent minimally invasive, tubular retractor-assisted microscopic discectomy were retrospectively reviewed. The patients included 11 men and eight women with a mean age of 58 years. The mean symptom duration before surgery was 6.5 months, and the mean follow up time was 20.5 months. Clinical outcomes were assessed according to neurologic status, bleeding volume, surgical time, length of hospital stay, visual analogue scale (VAS) and the modified MacNab's criteria. RESULTS: The most frequent lesion was at the L4-L5 level (53%), and the mean bleeding volume was 59.3ml. The mean surgical time and length of hospital stay were 91.1 minutes and 6.4 days, respectively. The mean VAS for radicular pain was improved from 8.37 +/- 1.11 before surgery to 1.37 +/- 1.33 (P<0.05) at discharge and 0.68 +/- 0.89 one year after surgery. The mean VAS for back pain was decreased from 4.6 3 +/- 0.99 before surgery to 2.00 +/- 1.23 (P<0.05) at discharge and 0.42 +/- 0.61 one year after surgery. The success rates were 100% according to the modified MacNab's criteria, and there were no postoperative complications or recurrences. CONCLUSIONS: The minimally invasive, tubular retractor-assisted microscopic discectomy method is a safe and effective procedure and may be an alternative for treating far lateral lumbar disc herniations.

Retroperitoneal Hematoma Secondary to Terminal Branch of Segmental Artery Injury during Intertransverse Discectomy through Paramedian Muscle Splitting Approach

A 47-year-old man underwent the surgery of intertransverse discectomy through paramedian muscle splitting due to extraforaminal type of far lateral disc herniation at 4th-5th interspace of lumbar vertebrae. The authors encountered the terminal branch of the segmental artery that traversed the extruded disc around the dorsal root ganglion during the sugery. We coagulated the artery by a bipolar coagulator and cut the artery for the discectomy. There was no active bleeding during the surgery. However, the patient suffered from abdominal, right leg and flank pain at the first postoperative day. The follow-up magnetic resonance imaging revealed a retroperitoneal hematoma at the operation site. The patient underwent removal of the retroperitoneal hematoma. We identified the cause of bleeding as the rupture of coagulated terminal branch of the segmental artery around the dorsal root ganglion. The retroperitoneal hematoma was evacuated completely. The ruptured artery was clipped by a small metal clip, and his symptoms subsequently were resolved.

A Case of Cervical Far Lateral Disc Herniation-Case Report-

Compared to the lumbar region, it is very rare to encounter far lateral disc herniation in the cervical spine, and because of this, correct diagnosis before surgery is difficult: the condition can, however, be identified through the use of advanced MRI imaging techniques. In this case, far lateral disc herniation at C7-T1 was effectivery removed through posterior laminoforaminotomy, and soon after surgery, the patient's symptoms showed complete remission.

Far Lateral Extraforaminal Disc Herniation after Percutaneous Laser Lumbar Discectomy

The authors report a case of far lateral disc herniation at L4-5 found one year after percutaneous laser lumbar discectomy. The patient was found to be suffering from new-onset right lumbar radiculopathy 6 months after his first operation, and post operative lumbar MRI confirmed a far lateral extraforaminal disc herniation at L4-5, with compression of the nerve. This corresponded to the nucleotomy site of the probe. The patient underwent surgery employng the combined paraspinal intertransverse and interlaminar approach, and his symptoms were relieved. This case emphasizes the importance of removing nuclear material, and shows that remaining material can herniate through a percutaneous discectomy window.

Combined Interlaminar and Paraspinal Intertransverse

A technique combining usual interlaminar approach and paraspinal intertransverse approach for exposing far-lateral disc herniations without disrupting the facet is described. This approach is useful because disc fragments can be removed from both intraspinal and paraspinal route with easy retraction and under short skin incision. This approach prevents reherniation by complete removing of residual nucleus pulposus. At the end of procedure the foramen can be explored in order to verify that foramen is opened. This approach is usuful especially in operating the double herniations and extruded far lateral disc herniations.

Clinical Experiences in the Treatment of Far Lateral Lumbar Disc Herni

The authors present 12 cases of far lateral disc herniation(FLDH) diagnosed and treated in our institution from march, 1992 to February, 1994. In the author's series the incidence of far lateral disc herniation was 5% of all lumbar disc herniations. The average age of the patients was 4 years and there were 7 men and 5 women. The L4-5 intervertebral disc level was the most commonly involved level. All patients initially presented with symptoms of radiculopathy. Cases with double herniations at the same level and on the same side seemed to have the most potential source of misdiagnosis and mismanagement, and a careful surgical consideration was needed for such cases. In 4 cases, a combined intraspinal and extraforaminal approach was performed with preservation of facet joints and in 2 cases, paramedian muscle splitting approach was performed. Chemonucleolysis and the usual partial hemilaminectomy were undertaken in 5 cases and in 1 case, respectively. The combined approaches proved to be an effective means of treatment for cases with double herniations, but misdiagnosis of such lesion can lead to an inappropriate and an ineffective treatment and poor surgical results. Furthermore, in the diagnosis of far lateral disc herniation, differentiation must be made from symptoms of conjoined nerve root and congested epidural vein.

Far Lateral Lumbar disc Herniation

Far lateral disc herniation(FLDH) with compression of the nerve root as it exits through the foramen has been a recognized entity for a number of years. Failure to diagonose and precisely localize these herniations can lead to unsuccessful surgical exploration or exploration of the innocent interspace. If these herniation are diagnosed, they often cannot be adequately exposed by the classic minline hemilaminectomy approach. A partial or complete unilateral facetectomy to expose these herniations can lead to vertebral instability or contribute to continued postoperative back pain. The authors present 5 patients who were diagnosed as having far lateral lumbar disc herniations from 1988 to 1990. Two of these were at L4-5 level, two at L5-S1 level and one at L3-4 level and all were over 60 years old. High resolution CT scan appeared to be the best study and the paramedian muscle splitting microsurgical approach, done in 3 cases, was found to be the most direct and favorable anatomical route to FLDH for vertebral stability and minimal postoperative back pain.