Apport du test expert MTBRIF dans le diagnostic de la tuberculose toute forme à Saint-Louis / contribution of the Xpert MTB / Rif test in the diagnosis of tuberculosis of any form in Saint-Louis

Introduction: le test Xpert MTB/RIF présente un double avantage d'une part le diagnostic rapide des cas mêmes difficiles par la technique standard de l'examen direct à la microscopie et d'autre part par la détection de la résistance à la rifampicine. Notre objectif était de déterminer l'apport du test Xpert dans le diagnostic de la tuberculose toutes formes confondues. Matériels et méthode : étude transversale, descriptive à collecte rétrospective menée dans le service de Pneumophtisiologie de CHRU de Saint-Louis. Tous les cas suspects de tuberculose qui avaient bénéficié d'un test Xpert de 2018 à 2020avec un dossier médical accessible et exploitable ont été inclus. Les paramètres étudiés étaient les données sociodémographiques, cliniques et biologiques. Résultats : Nous avions colligés 524dossiers de malades avec un sex-ratio de 1,3. L'âge moyen des patients était de 37 ans+/-15 ans. Il y'avait 285 prélèvements positifs au GeneXpert dont 224 d'origine pulmonaire et 61d'origine extra pulmonaire. Le nombre d'échantillons résistants à la rifampicine était de cinq, tous d'origine respiratoire. Conclusion: le test Xpert est une nouvelle technique moléculaire recommandée par l'OMS dans le diagnostic de la tuberculose pulmonaire. Toutefois il doit être évaluer dans le diagnostic de la tuberculose extra pulmonaire

Introduction: The Xpert MTB / RIF assay has a dual advantage on the one hand, the rapid diagnosis of even difficult cases by the standard technique of direct microscopic examination and on the other hand by the detection of resistance to rifampicin. Our objective was to determine the contribution of the Xpert test in the diagnosis of tuberculosis of all forms. Materials and method: retrospective, descriptive and analytical study carried out in the Pneumophtisiology department of the CHRU of Saint-Louis. All suspected tuberculosis cases who had received an Xpert test from 2018 to 2020 were included. The parameters studied were socio-demographic, clinical and biological data. Results: 524 patient records included in the study with a sex ratio of 1.3. The mean age of the patients was 37 +/-15 years. There were 285 positive GeneXpert samples, of which 224 were of pulmonary origin and 61 of extra-pulmonary origin. The number of rifampicin resistant samples was five, all of respiratory origin. Conclusion: the Xpert test is a new molecular technique recommended by the WHO in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis

Rendimiento del GeneXpert en el diagnóstico de tuberculosis pulmonar y extrapulmonar en la edad pediátrica / GeneXpert for the diagnosis of pulmonary and extrapulmonary tuberculosis in pediatric patients / GeneXpert para o diagnóstico da tuberculose pulmonar e extrapulmonar em pacientes pediátricos

resumen está disponible en el texto completo

Summary: Introduction: the World Health Organization (WHO) recommends molecular biology techniques, such as Xpert MTB/RIF, for the diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) and for the detection of Rifampicin resistance. In Uruguay, the Xpert MTB/RIF has been used since 2014, and no research papers have yet assessed its performance. A Cochrane review recommends the assessment of the Xpert diagnostic accuracy in difficult to diagnose groups, such as, children, people living with HIV and with extrapulmonary tuberculosis. Objectives: describe cases of TB in children of under 15 years of age in Uruguay during 2018 and 2019 and describe the influence of the various diagnostic tests on the bacteriological confirmation of the disease. Evaluate the performance of the Xpert MTB/RIF for the diagnosis of TB in respiratory and non- respiratory samples using the culture as a reference standard. Compare the performance of GeneXpert with smear microscopy for TB diagnosis. Material and methods: analytical, retrospective study of children of under 15 years of age in Uruguay between January 2018 and June 2019, based on data obtained from the PNC-TB information system. Clinical-epidemiological characteristics of the TB cases were described. Definitions were taken from CHLA-EP, as per WHO recommendations. All respiratory and non-respiratory samples received by the National Reference Laboratory in Tuberculosis of the CHLA-EP from 1/1/2018 to 6/30/2019, entered in the IT system ("TB soft") were analyzed; they belonged to patients with clinical suspicion of TB, studied as contacts, or to TB risk groups (patients with immunodeficiency or at risk of immunosuppression, mainly). All samples underwent smear microscopy and/or Xpert MTB/RIF (according to the CHLA-EP protocol) and culture. The detection of Rifampicin resistance in the Xpert was compared with first- line drug sensitivity tests using molecular methods made from the cultures. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of GeneXpert and ZN microscopy were calculated using Mycobacterium tuberculosis culture as gold standard. We calculated the Xpert positive and negative likelihood ratio (LR). Results: 67 patients under 15 years of age were diagnosed with TB, and 46% cases were bacteriologically confirmed. A total of 1670 samples were analyzed; 82% respiratory and 17% non-respiratory. A total of 32 samples showed a positive culture for M. tuberculosis (14 respiratory and 18 non- respiratory). One rifampicin resistance sample was detected in the Xpert that was not confirmed in the culture. The sensitivity of Xpert for all samples was 80%; the specificity 99,5%; PPV 80%; NPV 99,5%. In the case of smear microscopy for all samples: S 44,4%, specificity 99,4%, PPV 70,6%; NPV 98,2%. Respiratory samples: Xpert S 100%; E 99,4%; PPV 66,7%; NPV 100%. Bacilloscopy: S 72,7%; E 99,6%; PPV 72,7%; NPV 99,6%. Non-respiratory samples: Xpert S: 66,7%; E 100%; PPV 100%; NPV 97,9%. Bacilloscopy: S 25%; E 98,8%; PPV 66,7%; NPV 93,2%. The LR + of the Xpert for all samples was 160 and the LR - 0,2. Conclusions: TB in children under 15 remains difficult to diagnose. Bacteriological confirmation was attempted in 88% of TB cases, and almost 50% showed positive results by some bacteriological technique. The Xpert showed a good sensitivity and specificity profile in both respiratory and non-respiratory samples, similar to those reported in international papers. The main contribution in relation to smear microscopy is the greater sensitivity for the diagnosis of TB in children under 15 years of age. The Xpert is very useful for TB diagnosis when it is positive, although it does not ensure we can rule out the disease in case of negative results.

Resumo: Introdução: a Organização Mundial da Saúde (OMS) recomenda técnicas de biologia molecular, como o Xpert MTB / RIF para o diagnóstico de tuberculose (TB) e para a detecção de resistência à Rifampicina. No Uruguai, o Xpert MTB / RIF é usado desde 2014, e o seu desempenho ainda não tem sido avaliado. Uma revisão recente da Cochrane promove que pesquisas futuras devem avaliar a precisão diagnóstica do Xpert, em grupos difíceis de diagnosticar, como crianças, pessoas vivendo com HIV e pessoas com tuberculose extrapulmonar. Objetivos: descrever os casos de tuberculose em crianças menores de 15 anos no Uruguai nos anos 2018-2019 e a contribuição dos diferentes testes de diagnóstico na confirmação bacteriológica da doença. Avaliar o desempenho do Xpert MTB / RIF para o diagnóstico de TB em amostras respiratórias e não respiratórias de pacientes menores de 15 anos, utilizando a cultura como padrão de referência. Comparar o desempenho do GeneXpert com a baciloscopia para o diagnóstico da TB. Material e métodos: estudo analítico e retrospectivo de crianças menores de 15 anos estudadas para TB no Uruguai entre janeiro de 2018 e junho de 2019, utilizando a base em dados do sistema informático PNC-TB. Descrevemos as características clínico-epidemiológicas dos casos de TB. As definições foram retiradas do CHLA-EP de acordo com as recomendações da OMS. Todas as amostras respiratórias e não respiratórias recebidas pelo Laboratório Nacional de Referência (LNR) em Tuberculose do CHLA-EP de 01/01/2018 a 30/06/2019, inseridas no sistema computacional (TB Soft), corresponderam a pacientes com suspeita clínica de TB, estudados como contatos ou na detecção de TB em grupos de risco (pacientes com imunodeficiências ou com risco de imunossupressão, principalmente). As amostras foram realizadas por esfregaço (baciloscopia) e/ou Xpert MTB/RIF (de acordo com o protocolo CHLA-EP) e por cultura. A detecção da resistência à Rifampicina no Xpert foi comparada com os testes de sensibilidade a drogas de primeira linha (PSD), utilizando os métodos moleculares das culturas. A sensibilidade, especificidade, PPV e NPV do Xpert e esfregaço foram calculados usando a cultura como padrão de referência. Calculamos a razão de verossimilhança positiva e negativa (LR) do Xpert. Resultados: 67 crianças menores de 15 anos foram diagnosticadas com TB, e 46% dos casos foram confirmados bacteriologicamente. 1670 amostras foram analisadas; 82% respiratórias e 17% não respiratórias. 32 amostras tiveram uma cultura positiva para M. tuberculosis (14 respiratórias e 18 não respiratórias). A sensibilidade (S) do Xpert para todas as amostras foi de 80% (IC95% 37,5-96,3), especificidade (E) 99,5% (IC95% 97,3-99,9), PPV 80% (37,5-96,3), NPV 99,5% (97,3-99,9). Baciloscopia: S de 46,1% (28,7-64,5), E 99,5% (98,7-99,8), PPV 75% (50,5-89,8), VPL 98,3% (97,2-99). Amostras respiratórias: Xpert S 100%; E 99,3% VPP 66% e VPN 100%. Baciloscopia: S 66,6%, E 99,8%, PPV 80%, NPV 99,7%. Amostras não respiratórias: Xpert S: 66,6%, E 100%, PPV 100%, NPV 97,9%; Esfregaço S: 25%, E 99,3%, PPV 80%, NPV 93%. O LR + do Xpert para todas as amostras foi de 160 e o LR - 0,2. Conclusões: a TB em crianças menores de 15 anos é ainda difícil de diagnosticar. Tentamos a confirmação bacteriológica em 88% dos casos de TB, e quase 50% deles tiveram resultados positivos utilizando alguma técnica bacteriológica. O Xpert mostrou um bom perfil de sensibilidade e especificidade em amostras respiratórias e não respiratórias, semelhante ao relatado em papers internacionais. A principal contribuição em relação à baciloscopia é a maior sensibilidade para o diagnóstico de TB em menores de 15 anos. O Xpert é muito útil para o diagnóstico de TB em caso de ser positivo, embora não permita descartar a doença em casos negativos.