El principio ético de la intervención humana en la responsabilidad civil

Una de las mayores complejidades que se presentan respecto de la responsabilidad civil por daños causados por sistemas de inteligencia artificial viene dada por la dificultad de atribuir la conducta que causa daño a un sujeto particular. Frente a ello, este artículo expone la importancia del principio ético de la intervención humana para la responsabilidad civil, cuya función consiste en constituir la guía para la interpretación y aplicación de sus reglas en los casos en los que, como resultado de una acción u omisión emanada de una decisión, recomendación o predicción realizada por un sistema de inteligencia artificial, se causen daños a las personas.

One of the main challenges associated with regard to civil liability for damages resulting from artificial intelligence systems is the difficulty of attributing the behavior that led to harm to a specific individual. The aim of this article is to highlight the significance of the ethical principle of human intervention for civil liability. This principle serves as a guide for interpreting and applying rules when artificial intelligence systems cause harm to individuals due to actions, decisions, recommendations or predictions.

Uma das maiores complexidades que se apresentam a respeito da responsabilidade civil por danos causados por sistemas de inteligência artificial vem dada pela dificuldade de atribuir a conduta que causa dano a um sujeito particular. Frente a isso, este artigo expõe a importância do princípio ético da intervenção humana para a responsabilidade civil, cuja função consiste em constituir uma orientação para a interpretação e aplicação de suas regras nos casos em que, como resultado de uma ação ou omissão emanada de uma decisão, recomendação ou previsão realizada por um sistema de inteligência artificial, se cause danos às pessoas.

Evolution and importance of the Research Ethics Committee, CEP, in higher education institutions: a study in a western Amazonian institution between 2018 to 2022

The Research Ethics Committee (CEP) has become an essential mechanism for social control in Brazilian research involving human subjects, contributing to the development of studies guided by ethical standards and to the protection of research participants. This article analyzes the performance of CEP in Western Amazonian institution, its history, operating conditions, trends, and different aspects between 2018 to 2022. The theoretical framework addresses the history of research involving human subjects, the origins and evolution of bioethics in the international context, bioethics in Brazil, and regulations on the ethical analysis of research. The data were collected through the Brazil Platform and reports from the institution's CEP. The CEP evaluated 865 research protocols, most of which were from Health Sciences. Additionally, it was observed that during 2018 to 2022 the covid-19 pandemic had a negative impact on the number of projects submitted for evaluation to the CEP. The 57% drop in the number of projects registered during 2020/2022 reveals the negative impact of this event on the execution of projects with human participants.

El Comité de Ética en Investigación (CEP) se ha convertido en un mecanismo esencial para el control social en la investigación brasileña con seres humanos, contribuyendo al desarrollo de estudios guiados por normas éticas y a la protección de los participantes en la investigación. Este artículo analiza el desempeño del CEP en la institución amazónica occidental, su historia, condiciones de funcionamiento, tendencias y diferentes aspectos entre 2018 y 2022. El marco teórico aborda la historia de la investigación con seres humanos, los orígenes y la evolución de la bioética en el contexto internacional, la bioética en Brasil y la normativa sobre el análisis ético de la investigación. Los datos se recogieron a través de la Plataforma Brasil y de informes del CEP de la institución. El CEP evaluó 865 protocolos de investigación, la mayoría de los cuales eran de Ciencias de la Salud. Además, se observó que durante 2018 a 2022 la pandemia de covid-19 tuvo un impacto negativo en el número de proyectos presentados para evaluación al CEP. La caída del 57% en el número de proyectos registrados durante 2020/2022 revela el impacto negativo de este evento en la ejecución de proyectos con participantes humanos.

Os Comitês de Ética em Pesquisa (CEPs) tornaram-se um mecanismo essencial para o controle social em pesquisas brasileiras envolvendo sujeitos humanos, contribuindo para o desenvolvimento de estudos regido por padrões éticos e para a proteção de participantes de pesquisas. Esse artigo analisa o desempenho de CEP em instituição da Amazonia Ocidental, sua história, condições operativas, tendências e diferentes aspectos entre 2018 e 2022. O enquadre teórico visa a história da pesquisa envolvendo sujeitos humanos, as origens e evolução da bioética no contexto internacional, bioética no Brasil e regulamentos de análise ética de pesquisa. Os dados foram coletados através da Plataforma Brasil e relatórios do CEP da instituição. O CEP avaliou 865 protocolos de pesquisa, a maioria deles de Ciências da Saúde. Adicionalmente, foi observado que de 2018 a 2022 a pandemia da covid-19 teve um impacto negativo no número de projetos submetidos para avaliação do CEP. A queda de 57% no número de projetos registrados em 2020/2022 revela o impacto negativo desse evento na execução de projetos com participantes humanos.

Ethical assessment of privacy breaches in epidemiological investigations and information disclosure in the internet age: safeguarding identity information for infectious patients

While the Internet has brought convenience and speed to human life, it has also led to frequent privacy violations. In the context of epidemiological investigations and information disclosure regarding confirmed Covid-19 patients, many individuals have utilized the Internet as a means to disseminate information and engage in cyber manhunts, resulting in breaches of privacy for those involved. This phenomenon is particularly prevalent within the realm of the Internet, where the boundaries of privacy invasion become blurred. Various types of privacy infringements, both active and passive negligence, are evident on social networking platforms. The juxtaposition of the virtual world of the Internet with real-life scenarios presents novel challenges in the realm of privacy violations. The Internet era, coupled with the widespread use and integration of big data, has diminished the absolute right to privacy on the Internet. This paper examines the challenge of safeguarding the identity information of infectious patients through the lens of two theoretical frameworks -Kantianism and Utilitarianism- in an effort to address this ethical dilemma.

Aunque Internet ha aportado comodidad y rapidez a la vida humana, también ha dado lugar a frecuentes violaciones de la intimidad. En el contexto de las investigaciones epidemiológicas y la divulgación de información relativa a pacientes confirmados de covid-19, muchas personas han utilizado Internet como medio para difundir información y participar en cibercacerías, lo que ha dado lugar a violaciones en la intimidad de los implicados. Este fenómeno prevalece en el ámbito de Internet, donde los límites de la invasión de la intimidad se vuelven vagos. En las redes sociales, se manifiestan diversos tipos de violaciones de la intimidad, tanto por negligencia activa como pasiva. La yuxtaposición entre el mundo virtual de Internet con escenarios de la vida real plantea nuevos retos en el ámbito de las violaciones de la intimidad. La era de Internet, junto con el uso generalizado y la integración del bigdata, han mermado el derecho absoluto a la privacidad. Este artículo examina el reto de salvaguardar la información sobre la identidad de los pacientes infecciosos a través de la lente de dos marcos teóricos -el kantianismo y el utilitarismo- en un esfuerzo por abordar este dilema ético.

Enquanto a Internet trouxe conveniência e velocidade à vida humana, ela também levou a frequentes violações da privacidade. No contexto de investigações epidemiológicas e divulgação de informações em relação a pacientes confirmados de Covid-19, muitos indivíduos utilizaram a Internet como um meio para disseminar informação e participar de uma caçada cibernética, resultando em violações da privacidade para aqueles envolvidos. Esse fenômeno é particularmente prevalente no âmbito da Internet, onde os limites de invasão da privacidade se tornaram borrados. Vários tipos de infrações da privacidade, tanto negligências ativa como passiva, são evidentes em plataformas de redes sociais. A justaposição do mundo virtual da Internet com cenários da vida real apresenta novos desafios no âmbito das violações da privacidade. A era da Internet, juntamente com o amplo uso e integração de megadados (big data), diminuiu o direito absoluto à privacidade na Internet. Esse artigo examina o desafio de proteger a informação de identidade de pacientes infectantes através das lentes de dois enquadres teóricos -Kantianismo e Utilitarismo- em um esforço para abordar esse dilema ético.

La narratividad como perspectiva transdiscursiva para la formación ético-profesional del universitario

El artículo tiene como objetivo caracterizar las potencialidades formativas de la narratividad como criterio y práctica para la educación ético - profesional del estudiante universitario. Entre los resultados se destacó la propuesta de valores formativos transdisciplinares desde la narratividad y de acciones prácticas con una perspectiva transdisciplinar que permite pasar de los presupuestos de la narración a la narratividad como eje transdiscursivo en la formación ético-profesional de las diversas carreras.

The article aims to characterize the formative potential of narrativity as a criterion and practice for the ethical-professional education of the university student. Among the results, the proposal of transdisciplinary training values ​​from narrativity and practical actions with a transdisciplinary perspective that allows moving from the assumptions of narration to narrativity as a transdiscursive axis in the ethical-professional training of the various careers stood out.

Ethics and Welfare in invertebrates: a stepping-stone to research and animal production / Ética y bienestar en invertebrados: una piedra fundamental en investigación y producción animal

Abstract Introduction: Even though only a few species are considered to be dangerous, pests or vectors, the majority of invertebrates produce a feeling of aversion in humans. This has contributed to the delay in the development of ethical considerations as regards this group in contrast with vertebrates, with the exception of cephalopods. Objective: In the present study, we provide an overview of the current situation on animal ethics and welfare in order to contribute to the development of a framework for ensuring invertebrate welfare. Methods: Today, animal welfare is multidisciplinary in nature to a very high degree as it includes ethology, physiology, pathology, biochemistry, genetics, immunology, nutrition, cognitive-neural, veterinary medicine, and ethics. Animal welfare is a complex concept, difficult to achieve successfully from one perspective. Results: As a consequence, we propose to include the five domains (nutrition, environment, health, behaviour and mental state) along with the three conceptions (basic health and functioning, affective state and natural living), as well as the 5R Principle (Replace, Reduction, Refinement, Respect and Responsibility) in seeking to achieve a comprehensive welfare state. Conclusions: We consider that in both research and animal production, the individual and collective ethical concerns coexist and, in fact, the main moral concern to account for is the collective one and that, within that collective view, the individual moral concern should be applied with responsibility and respect for the individual. Finally, we propose a practical example of invertebrate welfare production in sea urchin aquaculture with the aim of including animal production of invertebrates in this important discussion.

Resumen Introducción: Aunque sólo unas pocas especies son consideradas peligrosas, plagas o vectores, la mayoría de los invertebrados producen un sentimiento de aversión en el ser humano. Esto ha contribuido al retraso en el desarrollo de consideraciones éticas respecto a este grupo en comparación con los vertebrados, a excepción de los cefalópodos. Objetivo: En el presente trabajo, proporcionamos una visión general de la situación actual en materia de ética y bienestar animal con el fin de contribuir al desarrollo de un marco para garantizar el bienestar de los invertebrados. Métodos: Hoy en día, el bienestar animal es de naturaleza multidisciplinaria en un grado muy alto, ya que incluye etología, fisiología, patología, bioquímica, genética, inmunología, nutrición, cognitivo-neural, medicina veterinaria y ética. El bienestar animal es un concepto complejo, difícil de lograr con éxito desde una sola perspectiva. Resultados: Como consecuencia, proponemos incluir los cinco dominios (nutrición, ambiente, salud, comportamiento y estado mental) junto con las tres concepciones (Salud básica y funcionamiento, estado afectivo y vida natural), así como el Principio 5R (Reemplazar, Reducir, Refinar, Respetar y Responsabilidad) en la búsqueda de alcanzar un estado de bienestar integral. Conclusiones: Consideramos que tanto en la investigación como en la producción animal coexisten las preocupaciones éticas individuales y colectivas y, de hecho, la principal preocupación moral a dar cuenta es la colectiva y que, dentro de esa visión colectiva, se debe aplicar la preocupación moral individual. con responsabilidad y respeto por la persona. Finalmente, proponemos un ejemplo práctico de producción de bienestar de invertebrados en la acuicultura de erizos de mar con el objetivo de incluir la producción animal de invertebrados en esta importante discusión.

Ethic analysis of the role of incentive system in the organ donation after citizen’s death / 器官移植

Organ transplantation has demonstrated its significant values by its excellent effectiveness in health reconstruction and life survival, where organ donation is a major component in promoting the development of organ transplantation in China. In recent years, an important progress has been made in organ transplantation in China with an annually increased organ donation rate. In spite of this, there is a serious fact confronted by us that the donated organ quantity is insufficient, which may be solved by further improvement of medical science and public health policy. According to the international experience, an incentive system may improve the organ donation rate effectively although the hidden ethic property of the incentive system itself may have an essentially conflict with the altruism contained in the organ donation. Therefore, in this article, the property of the incentive system, the interaction between organ donation and incentive system and the ethic justification of the system was reviewed, aiming to provide a reference for the further development of the organ donation and transplantation business in China.

Critical points in the current construction of ethics committees at medical institutions / 现代医院

Significant advancements have been made in the establishment of ethics committees within medical institu-tions.However,in order to achieve a high-quality development it is imperative to focus on such critical points as distinguishment between biomedical research and the clinical application of medical technologies,steadfast adherence to the fundamental princi-ples of ethical review,establishment of an ethics committee with independent administrative authority,establishing independent ethics review committees in large medical institutions based on specialty,and strengthening of ethical training for medical person-nel and biomedical researchers.

Interpretation of the Measures for Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans developing responsible research and innovation / 中国医学伦理学

The Measures for Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans responded to the new issues faced by ethical review arising from the development of science and technology， society， and ethics， as well as the requirements of laws and regulations for ethical review. It adapted to the continuous increase of investment in scientific and technological innovation research and the development of biotechnology in China， and expanded the applicable institutions and research types of the ethical review system. Facing the ethical review of life sciences and medical research involving humans is one of the practical forms of responsible research and innovation. Therefore， it is necessary to establish and improve the ethical review system， implement the “subject responsibility” of life sciences and medical research involving humans， carry out classified and hierarchical bioethics education， and enhance the consciousness of researchers， research managers， and students in responsible research and innovation.

Requirements for biological samples and challenges to ethical review under the Measures of Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans / 中国医学伦理学

Regarding biological samples， compared to the Measures of Ethical Review of Biomedical Research Involving Humans， the newly released Measures of Ethical Review of Life Science and Medical Research Involving Humans updated the definitions， clarified the scope， defined the responsibilities of the subject， as well as emphasized the management system， ethical review， and informed consent. By comparing and analyzing the current management status of biological samples at home and abroad， it was found that there were still many problems in the management and ethical review of biological samples in China， such as a chaotic management system of biological samples， unclear responsible entities for management， lack of widely recognized management standards of biological samples in the industry， absence of ethics committee， the non-standard ethical review， the inadequacy or inability to implement informed consent， and the difficulty in providing feedback on research results. Therefore， it is recommended to establish a standardized management system of biological samples， conduct a standardized and effective ethical review， as well as sufficient and necessary informed consent， in order to comply with the requirements of the Measures of Ethical Review of Life Science and Medical Research Involving Humans on biological samples， and enhancing the quality of the management of biological samples in China.

New requirements and key points for review for research related to health information data in the Measures of Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans / 中国医学伦理学

To further standardize the ethical review of life science and medical research involving humans， the National Health Commission， the Ministry of Education， the Ministry of Science and Technology， and the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine jointly issued the Measures of the Ethical Review of Life Science and Medical Research Involving Humans in 2023. The provisions concerning research related to health information data within it include： emphasizing the protection of personal information and privacy rights， personal information can only be collected， stored， and used under the premise that research participants know and permit， and must not be disclosed to third-party without the authorization of research participants； the ethical committee should focus on reviewing the adequacy of confidentiality measures of personal information； for research that provides information and data or cooperation with external organizations， it is necessary to fully understand the research， conduct a full ethical review， and clarify the use， processing， and disposal after completion of information data through an agreement. The research institutions should improve the information data governance and supervision system in conjunction with the key points of information data management in the new regulations. The initial ethical review should focus on the risk-benefit ratio of the research， the reasonableness of the informed consent procedure， the feasibility of the opt-out procedure， the protection measures for the privacy of the research participants， and the data management capability of the research team. The knowledge training of researchers should be strengthened， policy advisory services should be provided for them， and even a unified information data management platform should be built for them from the overall level of research institutions. The ethical follow-up review emphasizes whether the researchers continue to protect the participant’s right to independent information or personal information， and privacy. It is believed that through a series of governance measures， the health information data of research participants in China will be better protected， thus safeguarding their legitimate rights and interests.

Challenges， countermeasures and key points of ethical review for decentralized clinical trials / 中国医学伦理学

Decentralized clinical trials （DCT） are bringing new changes to clinical trials， the core concept of “patient-centered” must be adhered， and the safety and rights of research participants must be adequately safeguarded. Although DCTs have similarities with traditional clinical trials， they are not suitable for all clinical trials， and are more suitable for oral administration， stable condition of study participants， and longer duration of treatment in clinical trials. DCT， elements must be selected based on the characteristics of clinical trials， and strike a balance between improving the sense of gain， safety， and rights and dignity of research participants， as well as the quality of data collected. Currently， DCT in China face many challenges. To actively promote DCTs in China， regulatory regulations and guiding principles should be improved. Based on patient-centered design principles， the first discussion requires real-time online communication. Researchers should provide more clinical trial services， improve risk control and accessibility of medical assistance， use third-party convenient payments， ensure fair recruitment of research participants， consider compliance， validate digital health technology， remote monitoring and electronic informed consent compliance， ensure the security of data collection， transmission， and analysis， as well as strengthen multi-party training. Ethical review is one of the important means to protect the safety and rights of research participants. Ethics committees should focus on appropriate DCTs elements that are patient-centered， compliance and effectiveness of electronic informed consent， processing and reporting of security information， privacy protection of data collection， compliance of remote monitoring， family health follow-up， management of biological samples and experimental medical products， and training programs. The author believed that the complementarity and combination with traditional clinical trials will make DCTs elements implemented more easily and smoothly. By leveraging the power of scientific and technological advances， DCTs will boost the speed of China’s drug and medical device research and development， enhance international competitiveness， and benefit more patients.

Exploration of the misunderstandings， challenges， and countermeasures of exemption from ethical review from the perspective of medical and health institutions / 中国医学伦理学

In the implementation of exemption from ethical review， medical institutions equate exemption from ethical review with no ethical review or simple review， misunderstand the scope of exemption from ethical review， confuse the concepts of de-identification and anonymization， and equate privacy with personal information. The implementation faced challenges such as the coordination of conditions for exempt review with other regulations， the lack of clear decision-making subjects for exempting from ethical review， the legality and compliance of using general informed consent for biological samples and information data， as well as non-traceability and the risk of being re-identified of anonymous information for exemption from ethical review. Measures such as improving relevant laws and regulations， perfecting the construction and management of information databases and biological sample libraries， strengthening the project management and process supervision of exemption from ethical review， and implementing scientific review can ensure the legal and compliant implementation of exemption from ethical review by medical and health institutions.

The importance and updated key point of ethical review in health management research： based on the Measures of Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans / 中国医学伦理学

The release of the Measures of Ethical Review of Life Sciences and Medical Research Involving Humans has brought new requirements to the field of ethical review in health management research. Based on the background of new regulations and combining the characteristics of the health management discipline， this paper explored the needs and necessity of ethical review in health management research. In the Measures， the ethical governance of health management research was updated， the concept of exemption from the ethical review was put forward， as well as the importance of protecting the rights and interests of research participants and the protection of personal information were emphasized. This paper also explored the ethical review framework for health management research， including the formulation of operational standards for exemption from ethical review， the refinement of standardized ethical review work systems and processes， and the clarification of information data source verification. These explorations aimed to provide an ethical guarantee for health management research， promote its healthy development， and ensure that the rights and interests of research participants are fully respected and protected. Through research， it is hoped that the ethical level of health management research can be further improved， promoting the development of the discipline and social progress.

Ethical reviewof cosmetic efficacy claims evaluation trails / 中国医学伦理学

The supervision of cosmetics started relatively late in China， and corresponding laws and regulations on ethical review are not yet perfect. The Cosmetics Supervision and Administration Regulations， which came into force on January 1， 2021， had stricter requirements for cosmetic efficacy claims， requiring that cosmetic efficacy claims should have a sufficient scientific basis. Cosmetic efficacy claims evaluation trials include human efficacy evaluation trials， consumer use tests， and laboratory trials. Human efficacy evaluation trials and consumer use tests should comply with the requirements of ethical principles， the necessary product safety evaluation should be completed before the tests are carried out， to ensure that there is no harm to the human health of research participants （or consumers） under normal， foreseeable circumstances. The Regulations on the Administration of Registration and Filing Materials for Cosmetics required that product test reports should include microbiological and physical-chemical tests， toxicological trials， human safety trial reports， and human efficacy trial reports. The key points of the ethics committee’s review of cosmetic efficacy claims evaluation trials include the reasonableness of the trial protocol， consumer survey and expert evaluation， selection of detection methods， study population and sample size， safety evaluation of the cosmetics， risk assessment of cosmetic raw materials， protection of privacy， and qualifications of the testing institutions and researchers. High-quality ethical review is conducive to safeguarding the safety and rights of research participants （or consumers）， and will also promote the quality of cosmetic efficacy claims evaluation trails in China.

Research on the necessity and program design of the development of an ethical review information system for organ donation and transplantation / 中国医学伦理学

Currently， the ethical review model for organ donation and transplantation in domestic hospitals is generally characterized by suddenness， unpredictability， tight time， difficulty in convening meetings and training committee members， as well as generally low quality and efficiency of ethical review， which cannot meet clinical needs and cause the waste of some scarce resources. The team of the Clinical Application Center of Human Organ Transplantation and the Ethics Committee of the First People’s Hospital of Kunming combine more than 10 years of review practice experience， as well as continuously explore and optimize the ethical review process and operating procedures for organ donation and transplantation. The special application has been approved and jointly developed with Soochow University and the Medical Ethics Committee of Fujian Province to build a full-process information software system management platform for organ ethical review of donation and transplantation， giving the full play the advantages of the review information system in improving work efficiency and review quality， facilitating full-process information management， and conducting online training and learning for committee members， with a view to providing a specialized practical model for addressing the difficulties and challenges related to ethical review of human organ donation and transplantation.

Research on ethical dilemmas in scientific research among medical graduate students / 中国医学伦理学

The ethical dilemma in scientific research exists at all stages of the scientific research activities among medical graduate students， mainly involving conflicts of interest， clinical trials， animal experiments， and the relationship between teachers and students. If medical graduate students are in the ethical dilemma in scientific research for a long time， their research activities will be greatly affected. By discussing the connotation， evaluation tools， current situation， influencing factors， and improvement measures of ethical dilemmas in scientific research， this paper proposed some suggestions， such as comprehensively investigating the influencing factors of ethical dilemmas in scientific research， and formulating targeted improvement measures， with a view to helping medical graduate students identify and get rid of ethical dilemmas in scientific research， and promote the stability of research activities.

Exploration and construction of an evaluation indicator framework for clinical research benefits in China / 中国医学伦理学

ObjectiveThe aim is to construct an evaluation framework for clinical research benefits， and provide a reference for the formulate of evaluation standards for clinical research benefits. MethodsThe Delphi method was used to carry out expert consultation， and the mean， score of importance， coefficient of variation and coordination， etc. of evaluation indicators were summarized and calculated， to screen evaluation indicators for clinical research benefits. ResultsTwenty-three experts in this field were selected for correspondence， and their enthusiasm was 100% in both rounds， the authority coefficients were≥0.90， and Kendall’s coefficients of concordance were<0.25 （P<0.001）. By referring to the mean and coefficient of variation of the indicators， as well as combining them with expert suggestions， an evaluation framework for clinical research benefits was ultimately formed with 2 primary indicators， 5 secondary indicators， and 8 tertiary indicators. ConclusionThe evaluation framework for clinical research benefits constructed in this paper can comprehensively evaluate the research benefits， as well as provide a basis for reasonably determining the research risk-benefit ratio and developing quantitative evaluation tools for clinical research benefits.

Research progress on ethical issues in the process of fertility preservation in tumor patients / 中国医学伦理学

Fertility preservation technology provides an effective method for protecting the reproductive resources of patients with malignant tumors. At the same time， it is inevitable to face great ethical dilemmas in the process of technological implementation. From an ethical perspective， this paper sorted out the research on fertility preservation in tumor patients abroad， as well as analyzed the ethical issues faced by tumor patients in the communication decision-making and implementation stages of fertility protection. Specifically， these included informing and discussing the reproductive information and preservation choices of tumor patients， fertility decision-making of adolescent tumor patients， psychological support for fertility in tumor patients， ownership and use rights of reproductive materials and their disposal methods， fairness in the allocation of social health resources and other ethical issues. Combining with the actual situation in China， this paper further discussed how to put forward corresponding countermeasures based on following ethical principles such as favorable without harm， informed consent， cautious application， and ethical supervision， with a view to promoting the further development and application of fertility preservation technology in clinical practice.

Ethical considerations on the development and application of artificial intelligence in public health / 上海预防医学

With the development of digital technology， an increasing number of artificial intelligence （AI） technologies are being applied in the field of public health， significantly improving the efficiency of healthcare systems. However， such technological advancement also introduces a series of ethical risks. In this article， we conducted a systematic review by searching nine domestic and international databases and analyzing the ethical issues related to AI in public health， ultimately including 158 articles. Based on the analysis of the included literature， ethical risks were categorized into four aspects： data， algorithms， rights and responsibilities， and social impact. A total of 15 key issues were identified， among which privacy and confidentiality， informed consent， data security， and fairness， justice and inclusion emerged as the most prominent issues. The ethical challenges posed by AI in the field of public health cannot be ignored， and it is necessary to formulate ethical guidelines and practical recommendations for AI in this field， establish sound regulatory and review mechanisms， thereby ensuring the healthy development of AI research in public health.

Expert Consensus on Ethical Management and Review of Stem Cell Clinical Research in Beijing Area / 中国医学伦理学

Stem cell clinical research is a hot frontier research. The ethical review of stem cell clinical research is full of challenges. Currently, clinical researches lack specific operational guidelines. Considered the related laws and regulations, and the operability of practical work, experts from the field of stem cells, such as law, ethics and management, will form a consensus on the basis of full discussion and continuous revision. It will provide reference for the operation of the ethics committee of corresponding institutions, and lay a certain foundation for the establishment of national expert consensus in the future, so as to promote the effective guidance of ethical review practice and quality evaluation of stem cell research.