Evaluation of cytopathological findings in thyroid nodules with macrocalcification: macrocalcification is not innocent as it seems / Avaliação dos achados citopatológicos em nódulos tiroidianos com macrocalcificações: elas não são tão inocentes como parecem

Objective Microcalcification is strongly correlated with papillary thyroid cancer. It is not clear whether macrocalcification is associated with malignancy. In this study, we aimed to assess the result of fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNAB) of thyroid nodules with macrocalcifications. Subjects and methods We retrospectively evaluated 269 patients (907 nodules). Macrocalcifications were classified as eggshell and parenchymal macrocalcification. FNAB results were divided into four groups: benign, malignant, suspicious for malignancy, and non-diagnostic. Results There were 79.9% female and 20.1% male and mean age was 56.9 years. Macrocalcification was detected in 46.3% nodules and 53.7% nodules had no macrocalcification. Parenchymal and eggshell macrocalcification were observed in 40.5% and 5.8% nodules, respectively. Cytologically, malignant and suspicious for malignancy rates were higher in nodules with macrocalcification compared to nodules without macrocalcification (p = 0.004 and p = 0.003, respectively). Benign and non-diagnostic cytology results were similar in two groups (p > 0.05). Nodules with eggshell calcification had higher rate of suspicious for malignancy and nodules with parenchymal macrocalcification had higher rates of malignant and suspicious for malignancy compared to those without macrocalcification (p = 0.01, p = 0.003 and p = 0.007, respectively). Conclusions Our findings suggest that macrocalcifications are not always benign and are not associated with increased nondiagnostic FNAB results. Macrocalcification, particularly the parenchymal type should be taken into consideration. Arq Bras ...

Objetivo A microcalcificação está fortemente correlacionada com o câncer papilar de tiroide. Não está claro se a macrocalcificação também está associada com malignidade. Neste estudo, nosso objetivo foi avaliar o resultado da biópsia de aspiração por agulha fina (FNAB) de nódulos tiroidianos com macrocalcificações. Sujeitos e métodos Avaliamos retrospectivamente 269 pacientes (907 nódulos). As macrocalcificações foram classificadas como periféricas (casca de ovo) ou parenquimatosas (interna). Os resultados da FNAB foram divididos em quatro grupos citológicos: benignos, com malignidade, suspeita de malignidade e não diagnósticos. Resultados Das amostras, 79,9% foram coletadas de mulheres e 20,1% de homens, e a idade média foi de 56,9 anos. A macrocalcificação foi detectada em 46,3% dos nódulos, e em 53,7% dos nódulos não havia macrocalcificação. A macrocalcificação parenquimatosa e periférica foi observada em 40,5% e 5,8% dos nódulos, respectivamente. Em termos citológicos, a malignidade e suspeita de malignidade foram mais comuns em nódulos com macrocalcificação em comparação com nódulos sem macrocalcificação (p = 0,004 e p = 0,003, respectivamente). Resultados benignos e não diagnósticos da citologia foram similares em ambos os grupos (p > 0,05). Os nódulos com calcificações periféricas apresentaram uma taxa maior de suspeita de malignidade e os nódulos com macrocalcificação parenquimatosa apresentaram ...

Thyroid Nodules with Macrocalcification: Sonographic Findings Predictive of Malignancy

PURPOSE: To analyze which sonographic features of thyroid nodules with macrocalcifications were predictable of thyroid malignancy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed sonographic findings of 854 macrocalcified thyroid nodules in patients who underwent fine needle aspiration biopsy between December 2009 and January 2011. There were 171 non-diagnostic aspirations, 34 nodules with category 3, 4, 5 based on Bethesda system, which were not confirmed by surgery, and these nodules were excluded from the analysis. Sonographic characteristics of the macrocalcifications including its thickness, interruption, and existence of soft tissue rim outside the macrocalcification were analyzed. Other sonographic characteristics of nodules such as shape, margin, composition, echo pattern, vascularity, and underlying parenchymal echogenicity were also evaluated. The correlation of sonographic features with cytopathologic results and the diagnostic performance of sonographic features for the prediction of malignancy were analyzed. RESULTS: Among 649 nodules, 179 (27.6%) nodules were malignant and 470 (72.4%) nodules were benign. Among the features of the macrocalcification, interruption, irregular thickness, or the presence of soft tissue outside calcification rim were associated with malignancy (p<0.001). A high sensitivity and negative predictive values for the prediction of malignancy was found in sonographic characteristics of irregular thickness (92.2% and 91.0%, respectively) and the presence of soft tissue (88.5% and 88.8%, respectively). CONCLUSION: Sonographic characteristics of macrocalcification such as interruption, irregular thickness and the presence of soft tissue rim were associated with malignancy in thyroid nodules with macrocalcifications.

Relationship of Shape of Macrocalcification and Thyroid Cancer: Correlation with US and Pathologic Findings

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to categorize macrocalcifications into several subtypes by the US findings and to determine which type of macrocalcification in a thyroid nodule is associated with thyroid malignancy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively analyzed the macrocalcification patterns of thyroid nodules in 396 patients that underwent ultrasonography (US)-guided thyroid FNA or surgery in our institution between August 2009 and August 2011. Two radiologists evaluated US findings and categorized macrocalcifications into 5 subtyes : (A) solitary macrocalcification no association with thyroid nodule; (B) nodular macrocalcification(s) within indeterminate thyroid nodule; (C) dense macrocalcification without ability to interpret internal content by its posterior acoustic shadowing; (D) irregular-shaped macrocalcification(s); (E) macrocalcification with other suspicious malignant US finding(s). A chi-squared test and a Fisher exact test were used for comparison of categoric variables. The diagnostic sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values (PPV and NPV) were obtained. RESULTS: Among total of 417 nodules, 114 (27.3%) were suspicious malignancy or malignancy on histopathological result. Macrocalcification with other malignant US feature had the highest incidence of malignancy (77.5%), followed by irregular-shaped macrocalcification(s) (43.9%), and dense macrocalcification without ability to interpret internal content by its posterior acoustic shadowing (38.5%), solitary macrocalcification no association with thyroid nodule (8.3%) respectively, and nodular macrocalcification(s) with indeterminate thyroid nodule had the lowest incidence (7.5%). A nodule with macrocalcification with other malignant US finding(s) has the highest odds ratio (42.52), followed by a nodule with irregular-shaped macrocalcification(s) (9.65) and dense macrocalcification (7.72). Leaving macrocalcification with compositive malignant findings aside, irregular-shaped macrocalcification is more likely to be associated with increased risk for malignancy compared with other patterns of macrocalcification. CONCLUSIONS: Irregular-shaped macrocalcification is a fine indicator for differentiation between benign and malignant thyroid nodules on ultrasonography.

Assessment of association between macrocalcification in thyroid nodule and thyroid carcinoma with ultrasound / 中国医师进修杂志

Objective To determine the association between macrocalcificatoin in thyroid nodule and thyroid carcinoma. Methods Sonogram of 169 patients of thyroid nodule with macrocalcification was retrospectively analyzed. The ultrasonographic finding was compared with pathological results after excision. Macrocalcification was divided into three types and assessed the relation between each type macrocalcification and thyroid carcinoma.Results Macrocalcification was detected in 176 nodules, 122 were malignant, and 54 were benign. Irregular macrocalcification were more common in malignant nodule (82.9%, 34/41), the malignant risk of solitary macrocalcification were lower (58.5%,31/53),and the malignant risk of curvilinear macrocalcification were between irregular macrocalcification and solitary macrocalcification (69.5%, 57/82). Conclusion Ultrasonography can play an important role in differentiating benign and malignant thyroid nodule macrocalcification.

Clinical Analysis of Macrocalcifications Accompanying a Thyroid Nodule: A Comparative Study with Microcalcifications / 대한내분비외과학회지

PURPOSE: The clinical value of macrocalcifications as an indicator that predicts malignancy of thyroid nodules is controversial. The purpose of this study was to investigate additional ultrasonographic findings accompanying macrocalcifications for predicting malignancies in thyroid nodules. METHODS: Between January 2005 and April 2008, 315 patients who had thyroid nodules with FNAB resulting in suspicious malignancies underwent thyroidectomy at the Wallace Memorial Baptist Hospital. Three hundred fifteen nodules, which were confirmed to be papillary thyroid carcinoma, and 192 nodules, which were confirmed to be benign, were reviewed retrospectively. We analyzed the malignancy rates according to calcification patterns and US findings of the associated solid nodules. RESULTS: Among the 165 papillary thyroid carcinomas with microcalcifications, 161 accompanied solid nodules, and 4 were found with microcalcifications, but without solid nodules. Of the 161 papillary thyroid carcinomas with microcalcifications and solid nodules, 85.7% showed signs suggestive of malignancy. The remaining 14.3%, where only microcalcifications were present, showed indications of predicting malignancy. When solid nodules were found with macrocalcifications, there were indicators of predicting malignancy (100%). Also, for situations in which benign nodules were accompanied by solid nodules, 29% had signs of predicting malignancy. For situations in which benign nodules did not accompany solid nodules, 21% showed suspicious signs of predicting malignancy, but were all confirmed as benign. CONCLUSION: CFor nodules that accompany microcalcifications, there can be indicators that predict malignant conditions separate from other opinions that accompany microcalcifications. However, for macrocalcifications, it would be more effective to set up future treatment plans based on ultrasonographic features of solid nodules accompanying calcifications rather than the calcification itself.