Clinical implementation of brass mesh bolus for chest wall postmastectomy radiotherapy and film dosimetry for surface dose estimates

Objective: This study presents the dosimetric data taken with radiochromic EBT3 film with brass mesh bolus using solid water and semi-breast phantoms, and its clinical implementation to analyze the surface dose estimates to the chest wall in postmastectomy radiotherapy (PMRT) patients. Materials and Methods: Water-equivalent thickness of brass bolus was estimated with solid water phantom under 6 megavoltage photon beam. Following measurements with film were taken with no bolus, 1, 2, and 3 layers of brass bolus: (a) surface doses on solid water phantom with normal incidence and on curved surface of a locally fabricated cylindrical semi-breast phantom for tangential field irradiation, (b) depth doses (in solid phantom), and (c) surface dose measurements around the scar area in six patients undergoing PMRT with prescribed dose of 50 Gy in 25 fractions. Results: Water-equivalent thickness (per layer) of brass bolus 2.09 ± 0.13 mm was calculated. Surface dose measured by film under the bolus with solid water phantom increased from 25.2% ±0.9% without bolus to 62.5% ± 3.1%, 80.1% ± 1.5%, and 104.4% ± 1.7% with 1, 2, and 3 layers of bolus, respectively. Corresponding observations with semi-breast phantom were 32.6% ± 5.3% without bolus to 96.7% ± 9.1%, 107.3% ± 9.0%, and 110.2% ± 8.7%, respectively. A film measurement shows that the dose at depths of 3, 5, and 10 cm is nearly same with or without brass bolus and the percentage difference is <1.5% at these depths. Mean surface doses from 6 patients treated with brass bolus ranged from 79.5% to 84.9%. The bolus application was discontinued between 18th and 23rd fractions on the development of Grade 2 skin toxicity for different patients. The total skin dose to chest wall for a patient was 3699 cGy from overall treatment with and without bolus. Conclusions: Brass mesh bolus does not significantly change dose at depths, and the surface dose is increased. This may be used as a substitute for tissue-equivalent bolus to improve surface conformity in PMRT

EBT3 and EDR2 film dosimetry for scanning carbon ion beams / 中华放射医学与防护杂志

Objective To investigate EBT3 and EDR2 film responses to different linear energy transfers ( LETs) and doses from carbon ion beams. Methods EBT3 and EDR2 films were calibrated by two methods. In the first method, films were placed at the same depth within a phantom and irradiated by beams with different parameters such as beam energy. In the second method, films were separately placed at different depths in a phantom and irradiated by the same beams. These methods were used to irradiate films with ions of different LETs. Results For EBT3 film, the dose calibration curves correlated with different LETs appeared to be typical hyperbolic curves with a maximum difference between the curves of ± 17％ (1σ). Meanwhile, the shape of the dose calibration curves for EDR2 film appeared to be linear. The values along all these curves were within ± 27.4％ (1σ) of the value for the average curve. The dose responses of both films were inversely proportional to LETs. The sensitivity of EBT3 film was inversely proportional to the dose, while the sensitivity of EDR2 film showed no relationship with the dose. Conclusions Influenced by the dual factor of LET and dose, the application of EBT3 film was limited in carbon ion. However, without no dose dependence, EDR2 film could be used to measure dose distributions created by single LET carbon ion beam.

Effects of chemical processing time on the reproducibility of film dosimetry and its optimization / 中华放射肿瘤学杂志

Objective To monitor the performance constancy of the HS-126E automatic X-ray film processor and to investigate the effects of chemical processing time on the reproducibility of film dosimetry.Methods With films having identical exposure,15 ready-pack Kodak X-omat-V films from the same batch were divided into 5 groups and exposed one by one under the identical conditions.One group of test film was processed per day from Monday to Friday with identical temperature and time.All films were digitized with a Vidar VXR-16 bit film digitizer. The average optical density(A) at irradiation field center was analyzed with RIT113 film dosimetry system software.At the same time,another 10 films in 5 groups from the same batch were exposed with vertical method and processed to get the calibration data and sensitometric curves.The film sensitivities,i.e.,ratio of A to delivered dose,were calculated and compared between groups.Another 15 films in 5 groups were exposed with horizontal method and processed similarly to the test films,the point dose at 1.5?cm depth on the central axis was calculated with sensitometric curve and compared with the value measured by ion chamber.Results Variations of A value in each group was less than 2%.During the processing period,a trend of decrease along with time in mean A value decreased day by day was observed.Both the standard deviations and coefficients of variation in all groups were within 2%.One-way ANOVA showed that there was a significant difference of the mean A value among all films from Monday to Friday(P

Patient Specific Quality Assurance of IMRT: Quantitative Approach Using Film Dosimetry and Optimization / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: Film dosimetry as a part of patient specific intensity modulated radiation therapy quality assurance (IMRT QA) was performed to develop a new optimization method of film isocenter offset and to then suggest new quantitative criteria for film dosimetry. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Film dosimetry was performed on 14 IMRT patients with head and neck cancers. An optimization method for obtaining the local minimum was developed to adjust for the error in the film isocenter offset, which is the largest part of the systemic errors. RESULTS: The adjust value of the film isocenter offset under optimization was 1 mm in 12 patients, while only two patients showed 2 mm translation. The means of absolute average dose difference before and after optimization were 2.36 and 1.56%, respectively, and the mean ratios over a 5% tolerance were 9.67 and 2.88%. After optimization, the differences in the dose decreased dramatically. A low dose range cutoff (L-Cutoff) has been suggested for clinical application. New quantitative criteria of a ratio of over a 5%, but less than 10% tolerance, and for an absolute average dose difference less than 3% have been suggested for the verification of film dosimetry. CONCLUSION: The new optimization method was effective in adjusting for the film dosimetry error, and the newly quantitative criteria suggested in this research are believed to be sufficiently accurate and clinically useful.

Patient Specific Quality Assurance of IMRT: Quantitative Approach Using Film Dosimetry and Optimization / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: Film dosimetry as a part of patient specific intensity modulated radiation therapy quality assurance (IMRT QA) was performed to develop a new optimization method of film isocenter offset and to then suggest new quantitative criteria for film dosimetry. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Film dosimetry was performed on 14 IMRT patients with head and neck cancers. An optimization method for obtaining the local minimum was developed to adjust for the error in the film isocenter offset, which is the largest part of the systemic errors. RESULTS: The adjust value of the film isocenter offset under optimization was 1 mm in 12 patients, while only two patients showed 2 mm translation. The means of absolute average dose difference before and after optimization were 2.36 and 1.56%, respectively, and the mean ratios over a 5% tolerance were 9.67 and 2.88%. After optimization, the differences in the dose decreased dramatically. A low dose range cutoff (L-Cutoff) has been suggested for clinical application. New quantitative criteria of a ratio of over a 5%, but less than 10% tolerance, and for an absolute average dose difference less than 3% have been suggested for the verification of film dosimetry. CONCLUSION: The new optimization method was effective in adjusting for the film dosimetry error, and the newly quantitative criteria suggested in this research are believed to be sufficiently accurate and clinically useful.

Dosimetric Verification of Dynamic Conformal Arc Radiotherapy / 의학물리

The purpose of this study is to develop the optimization method for adjusting the film isocenter shift and to suggest the quantitative acceptable criteria for film dosimetry after optimization in the dynamic conformal arc radiation therapy (DCAR). The DCAR planning was performed in 7 patients with brain metastasis. Both absolute dosimetry with ion chamber and relative film dosimetry were performed throughout the DCAR using BrainLab's micro-multileaf collimator. An optimization method for obtaining the global minimum was used to adjust for the error in the film isocenter shift, which is the largest part of systemic errors. The mean of point dose difference between measured value using ion chamber and calculated value acquired from planning system was 0.51+/-0.43% and maximum was 1.14% with absolute dosimetry. These results were within the AAPM criteria of below 5%. The translation values of film isocenter shift with optimization were within +/-1 mm in all patients. The mean of average dose difference before and after optimization was 1.70+/-0.36% and 1.34+/-0.20%, respectively, and the mean ratios over 5% dose difference was 4.54+/-3.94% and 0.11+/-0.12%, respectively. After optimization, the dose differences decreased dramatically and a ratio over 5% dose difference and average dose difference was less than 2%. This optimization method is effective in adjusting the error of the film isocenter shift, which is the largest part of systemic errors, and the results of this research suggested the quantitative acceptable criteria could be accurate and useful in clinical application of dosimetric verification using film dosimetry as follows; film isocenter shift with optimization should be within +/-1 mm, and a ratio over 5% dose difference and average dose difference were less than 2%.

Study on the characteristics of Insight dental x-ray film / 대한구강악안면방사선학회지

PURPOSE: To investigate the characteristics of the newly marketed, Insight dental X-ray film. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Kodak Ultraspeed (DF-58), E-speed, Agfa Dentus M2, and Kodak Insight (IP-21) films were radiographed using a Trophy intra-oral radiographic machine. 10 step exposure times were prepared and each step exposure was monitored using a FH 40G (ESM Eberline Instruments) dosimeter for each of the 4 types of intra-oral film. All films were manually processed and the radiographic densities at 6 sites of each processed film were measured, and the characteristic curves of each of the 4 types intra-oral films were created utilizing these dosimetric data and radiographic densities, based on ISO 5779. The film contrast, speed, and base plus fog density of Insight film were compared with those of the 3 other films examined in this experiment. RESULTS: E-speed film showed greatest average gradients followed by Insight film. E-speed and Ultraspeed film showed great average gradients at low density levels. Insight film showed the fastest speed followed by E-speed, Dentus M2 and Ultraspeed film. Dentus M2 film showed greatest base plus fog density level followed by Insight film. CONCLUSION: Kodak Insight film showed fastest film speed with comparable film contrast on characteristic curve.

Film Dosimetry for Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy: Dosimetric Evaluation / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: X-ray film over responds to low-energy photons in relative photon beam dosimetry because its sensor is based on silver bromide crystals, which are high-Z molecules. This over-response becomes a significant problem in clinical photon beam dosimetry particularly in regions outside the penumbra. In intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), the radiation field is characterized by multiple small fields and their outside-penumbra regions. Therefore, in order to use film dosimetry for IMRT, the nature the source of the over-response in its radiation field need to be known. This study is aimed to verify and possibly improve film dosimetry for IMRT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Modulated beams were constructed by a combination of five or seven different static radiation fields using 6 MeV X-rays. In order to verify film dosimetry, we used X-ray film and an ion chamber were used to measure the dose profiles at various depths in a phantom. In addition, in order to reduce the over-response, 0.01 inch thick lead filters were placed on both sides of the film. RESULTS: The measured dose profiles showed a film over-response at the outside-penumbra and low dose regions. The error increased with depths and approached 15% at a maximum for the field size of 15X15 cm(2) at 10 cm depth. The use of filters reduced the error to 3%, but caused an under-response of the dose in a perpendicular set-up. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated that film dosimetry for IMRT involves sources of error due to its over-response to low-energy photons. The use of filers can enhance the accuracy in film dosimetry for IMRT. In this regard, the use of optimal filter conditions is recommended.

One Click Film (OCF) Dosimetry System for Routine QA / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: To develop a practical film dosimetry system for routine Quality Assurance (QA). MATERIALS AND METHODS: An One Click Film (OCF) Dosimetry system was designed to perform swift routine QA with functions including automatic fog value elimination, angle adjustment, automatic symmetry calculation, and realtime profile generation with the ability to display realtime three-dimensional dose distributions. RESULTS: The most frequently used functions for routine QA, such as the elimination of the fog value, conversion into an H&D curve, symmetry, and isodose distribution, can be achieved with only one click. CONCLUSION: Reliable results were achieved with the OCF dosimetry with simpler steps than other commercially available film dosimetry systems for routine QA. More research on the refined user interface will make this system be clinically useful.

Evaluation of Tissue Inhomogeneity for Gamma-knife Radiosurgery Using Film Dosimetry / 대한방사선종양학회지

PURPOSE: Since the mid cranial fossa is composed of various thickness of bone, the tissue inhomogeneity caused by bone would produce dose attenuation in cobalt-60 gamma knife irradiation. The correction factor for bone attenuation of cobalt-60 which is used for gamma knife source is -3.5%. More importantly, nearly all the radiosurgery treatment planning systems assume a treatment volume of unit density; any perturbation due to tissue inhomogeneity is neglected. This study was performed to confirm the bone attenuation in mid cranial fossa using gamma knife. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Computed tomography was performed after Leksell stereotactic frame had been fixed to the Alderson Rando phantom (human phantom) skull area. Kodak X-omat V film was inserted into two sites of pituitary adenoma point and acoustic neurinoma point, and irradiated by gamma knife with 14mm and 18mm collimator. An automatic scanning densitometer with a 1mm aperture is used to measure the dose profile along the x and y axis. RESULTS: Isodose curve constriction in mid cranial fossa is observed with various ranges. Pituitary tumor point is greater than acoustic neurinoma point (0.2-3.0 mm vs. 0.1-1.3 mm) and generally 14 mm collimator is greater than 18mm collimator (0.4-3.0 mm vs. 0.2-2.2 mm). Even though the isodose constriction is found, constriction of 50% isodose curve which is used for treatment reference line does not exceed 1 mm. This range is too small to influence the treatment planning and treatment results. CONCLUSION: Radiosurgery planning system of gamma knife does not show significant error to be corrected without consideration of bone attenuation.

Dosimetric Characteristics on Penumbra Regions of the multileaf Collimator as Compared with the Lead Alloy Block / 대한치료방사선과학회지

PURPOSE: The Conformal Radiation Therapy has been widely used under favour of development of computer technologies. The delivery of a large number of static radiation fields are being necessary for the conformal irradiation. In this paper, we investigate dosimetric characteristics on penumbra regions of a multileaf collimator(MLC), and compare to those of lead alloy block for he optimal use of the system in 3-D conformal radiotherapy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The measurement of penumbra by MLC or lead alloy block was performed with 6 or 10 MV X-rays. The film was positioned at a dmax depth and 10 cm depth, and its optical density was determined using a scanning videodensitometer. The effective penumbra, the distance from 80% to 20% isodose lines and 90 to 10 were analyzed as a function of the angle between the direction of leaf motion and the edge defined by leaves. RESULTS: Increasing MLC angle (0-75degree) was observed with increasing the penumbra widths and the scalloping effect. There was no definite differences of penumbra width from 80% to 20% isodose lines, while being the small increase of penumbra width of lead alloy block are agree reasonably with those of MLC within 4.8mm. CONCLUSION: The comparative qualitative study of the penumbra between MLC and lead alloy block demonstrate the clinical acceptability and suitability of the multileaf collimator for 3-D conformal radiotherapy.

Dosimetric Characteristics on Penumbra Regions of the multileaf Collimator as Compared with the Lead Alloy Block / 대한치료방사선과학회지

PURPOSE: The Conformal Radiation Therapy has been widely used under favour of development of computer technologies. The delivery of a large number of static radiation fields are being necessary for the conformal irradiation. In this paper, we investigate dosimetric characteristics on penumbra regions of a multileaf collimator(MLC), and compare to those of lead alloy block for he optimal use of the system in 3-D conformal radiotherapy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The measurement of penumbra by MLC or lead alloy block was performed with 6 or 10 MV X-rays. The film was positioned at a dmax depth and 10 cm depth, and its optical density was determined using a scanning videodensitometer. The effective penumbra, the distance from 80% to 20% isodose lines and 90 to 10 were analyzed as a function of the angle between the direction of leaf motion and the edge defined by leaves. RESULTS: Increasing MLC angle (0-75degree) was observed with increasing the penumbra widths and the scalloping effect. There was no definite differences of penumbra width from 80% to 20% isodose lines, while being the small increase of penumbra width of lead alloy block are agree reasonably with those of MLC within 4.8mm. CONCLUSION: The comparative qualitative study of the penumbra between MLC and lead alloy block demonstrate the clinical acceptability and suitability of the multileaf collimator for 3-D conformal radiotherapy.

Verification of Dose Distribution for Stereotactic Radiosurgery with a Linear Accelerator / 대한치료방사선과학회지

The calculation of dose distribution in multiple arc stereotactic radiotherapy is a three-dimensional problem and, therefore, the three-dimensional dose calculation algorithm is important and the algorithm's accuracy and reliability should be confirmed experimentally. The aim of this study is to verify the dose distribution of stereotactic radiosurgery experimentally and to investigate the effect of the beam quality, the number of arcs of radiation, and the tertiary collimation on the resulting dose distribution. Film dosimetry with phantom measurements was done to get the three-dimensional orthogonal isodose distribution. All experiments were carried out with a 6 MV X-ray, except for the study of the effects of beam energy on dose distribution, which was done for X-ray energies of 6 and 15 MV. The irradiation technique was from 4 to 11 arcs at intervals of from 15 to 45 degrees between each arc with various field sizes with additional circular collimator. The dose distributions of square field with linear accelerator collimator compared with the dose distributions obtained using circular field with tertiary collimator. The parameters used for comparing the results were the shape of the isodose curve, dose fall-offs from 90% to 50 % and from 90% to 20% isodose line for the steepest and shallowest profile, and A= (90% idsose area) /( 50% isodose area - 90% isodose area (modified from Chierego)). This ratio may be considered as being proportional to the sparing of normal tissue around the target volume. The effect of beam energy in 6 and 15 MV X-ray indicated that the shapes of isodose cuties were the same. The value of ratio A and the steepest and shallowest dose fall-offs for 6 MV X-ray was minimally better than that for 15 MV X-ray. These data illustrated that an increase in the dimensions of the field from 10 to 28 mm in diameter did not significantly change the isodose distribution. There was no significant difference in dose gradient and the shape of isodose cutie regardless of the number of arcs for field sizes of 10, 21, and 32 mm in diameter The shape of isodose cuties was more circular in circular field and square in square field. And the dose gradient for the circular field was slightly better than that for the square field.