Résumé
Objective To compare the short-term perioperative outcomes of video-assisted mini-thoracotomy(VAMT),multiple port-video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery(MP-VATS)and single utility port-VATS(SP-VATS)in treatment of early stage non-small cell lung cancer(NSCLC).Methods A total of 157 cases of early stage NSCLC patients were collected and divided into three groups:66 cases received VAMT treatment as group VAMT;45 cases received MP-VATS treatment as group MP-VATS;46 cases received SP-VATS treatment as group SP-VATS.The intraoperative and postoperative conditions,lung function indexes including forced expiratory volume in one second(FEV1),forced vital capacity(FVC)and maximal voluntary ventilation(MVV)among the groups were compared.Results There were no significant differences in the operation time and the number of lymph node dissection among the SP-VATS group,MP-VATS group and group VAMT[(154.89±32.34)min vs(158.43±36.78)min vs(161.21±40.02)min,(12.34±4.55)pieces vs(12.47±3.81)pieces vs(11.78±3.32)pieces,P>0.05];the incision length,blood loss,amount and time of postoperative drainage and the postoperative ambulation in groupSP-VATS were significantly lower than group MP-VATS and VAMT[(4.11±0.65)cm vs(6.42±0.65)cm vs(12.14±2.23)cm;(170.31±45.68)ml vs(166.23±43.21)ml vs(228.96±63.21)ml;(623.42±231.56)ml vs(681.23±278.54)ml vs(924.54±324.51)ml;(5.27±1.32)d vs(7.43±2.27)d vs(7.66±2.89)d;(3.36±0.78)d vs(4.62±1.26)d vs(4.78±1.43)d,all P0.05);After surgery,the lung function(FEV1,FVC,MVV)among the three groups were significantly decreased,and the group SP-VATS was significantly higher than VAMT group(P0.05).Conclusion The SP-VATS for early stage NSCLC has similar short-term efficacy with VAMT and MP-VATS,but SP-VATS has faster recovery and maller postoperative pulmonary dysfunction.
Résumé
Objective To evaluate the clinical effect of Uniportal video -assisted thoracoscopic surgery and single utility port video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery for ⅠA stage non-small cell lung cancer .Methods A total of 81 patients with ⅠA stage non-small cell lung cancer was admitted to our hospital from January 2015 to November 2015 .The patients were divided into control group and observation group .51 patients of control group received single utility port video -assisted thoracoscopic surgery , while other 30 patients of observation group received Uniportal video -assisted thoracoscopic surgery .Results The incision length of observation group was(4.27 ±0.29) cm,operative time was (208.80 ±61.12) mins.The volume of blood intra -operation was (92.33 ±73.75)mL;the number of lymph nodes dissection was (15.62 ±5.12),post-operative drainage within 24 hours was(401.70 ±53.31)mL;drainage tube retention was (6.30 ±3.01)days;postoperative hospitalization time was(19.03 ±5.85)days.The incidence rate of postoperative complications was 13.33%.The incision length of control group was(3.86 ±0.23)cm.The operative time was(184.30 ±51.36)mins;The volume of blood intra-operation was(84.90 ±80.98)mL,the number of lymph nodes dissection was (15.84 ±5.66),post-operative drainage within 24 hours was(398.00 ±52.73)mL;drainage tube retention was(6.10 ±3.25)days;postoperative hospitalization time was(18.69 ±6.81) days;The incidence rate of postoperative complications was 25.49%, there were no significant difference between the two groups (P>0.05).VAS pain score of the observation group was(2.32 ±0.94)and it was(4.18 ±0.95)in control group,and observation group was significantly better than the control group(P<0.05).Conclusion Uniportal video -assisted thoracoscopic surgery has the benefit of less trauma and pain ,and it is worth using widely .