Effect of two corticotomy protocols on periodontal tissue and orthodontic movement

Abstract Objective To compare two corticotomy surgical protocols in rats to verify whether they alter conventional orthodontic movement. Methodology Sixty Wistar rats were divided into three groups - orthodontic movement (CG), orthodontic movement and corticotomy (G1) and orthodontic movement with corticotomy and decortication (G2) - and euthanized after 7 and 14 days. Tooth movement (mm), bone volume fraction and bone volume ratio to total volume (BV/TV), and bone mineral density (BMD) were evaluated by micro-CT. The total amount of bone was measured in square millimeters and expressed as the percentage of bone area in the histomorphometry. The number of positive TRAP cells and RANK/RANKL/OPG interaction were also investigated. Results Day 14 showed a statistically significant difference in orthodontic tooth movement in CG compared with G1 (7.52 mm; p=0.009) and G2 (7.36 mm; p=0.016). A micro-CT analysis revealed a difference between CG, G1 and G2 regarding BV/TV, with G1 and G2 presenting a lower BV/TV ratio at 14 days (0.77 and 0.73 respectively); we found no statistically significant differences regarding BMD. There was a difference in the total amount of bone in the CG group between 7 and 14 days. At 14 days, CG presented a significantly higher bone percentage than G1 and G2. Regarding TRAP, G2 had more positive cells at 7 and 14 days compared with CG and G1. Conclusion Corticotomy accelerates orthodontic movement. Decortication does not improve corticotomy efficiency.

Efeito da corticotomia e decorticalização na movimentação ortodôntica: estudo em ratos / Corticotomy and Decortication effect on orthodontic tooth movement: study in rats

Este estudo comparou dois protocolos cirúrgicos, corticotomia e corticotomia com decorticalização, em ratos para verificar alteração na movimentação ortodôntica convencional. 60 animais foram divididos aleatoriamente: Grupo controle (GC) - movimentação ortodôntica convencional; Grupo 1 (G1) -movimentação ortodôntica e corticotomia; Grupo 2 (G2) - movimentação ortodôntica com corticotomia e decorticalização. Os animais foram eutanasiados após 7 e 14 dias. No G1 e G2 houve uma maior movimentação ortodôntica comparado aos animais do GC aos 14 dias (p = 0,009 e 0,016) com uma maior área radiográfica interradicular, menor volume ósseo/volume total, menor área final e menor porcentagem de osso. Aos 7 dias os animais do G2 apresentaram menor volume de osso/volume total comparado com GC e aos 14 dias os animais do G2 apresentaram uma menor medida linear da crista óssea comparado com o GC. Os animais do GC aos 14 dias apresentaram uma maior área final comparado aos 7 dias, enquanto o G2 apresentou maior número de células TRAP positivas tanto aos 7 quanto aos 14 dias comparado com o G1. Na análise histológica aos 7 dias houve frequente reabsorção radicular inicial geralmente associada às áreas de hialinização e aos 14 dias, presença do infiltrado inflamatório e com menor ocorrência de áreas hialinas. O padrão de reabsorção radicular iniciado no 7º dia de movimento e consolidado no 14º dia. Concluímos que a corticotomia acelera a movimentação ortodôntica em 14 dias independente da magnitude da injúria cirúrgica (AU)

This study compared two surgical protocols, corticotomy and decorticalization corticotomy, in rats to verify alteration in conventional orthodontic movement. 60 animals were randomly divided: Group 1 (G1) orthodontic movement and corticotomy, and Group 2 (G2) orthodontic movement with corticotomy and decorticalization. The animals were euthanized after 7 and 14 days. In G1 and G2, there was a greater orthodontic movement compared to CG animals at 14 days (p = 0.009 and 0.016) with a higher interradicular radiographic area, lower bone volume / total volume, lower final area and lower percentage of bone. At 7 days the G2 animals presented lower bone volume / total volume compared to CG and at 14 days G2 animals presented a smaller linear measure of bone crest compared to CG. GC animals at 14 days presented a larger final area compared to 7 days, while G2 presented a higher number of TRAP cells positive at 7 and 14 days compared to G1. In the histological analysis at 7 days, there was frequent initial root resorption generally associated with hyalinization areas and at 14 days, presence of inflammatory infiltrate and less occurrence of hyaline areas. The root resorption pattern started on day 7 of movement and was consolidated on the 14th day. We conclude that corticotomy accelerates orthodontic movement in 14 days regardless of the magnitude of the surgical injury(AU)