Eficácia e segurança da alfa-agalsidase e a beta-agalsidase para intervenção na doença de Fabry: revisão rápida / Effectiveness and safety of agalsidase alfa and agalsidase beta for intervention in fabry disease: rapid review

Tecnologia: Alfa-agalsidase e/ou beta-agalsidase, comparada aos cuidados paliativos e ao tratamento sintomático associado aos órgãos alvos da doença de Fabry. Indicação: Manejo e intervenção aos desfechos clínicos em pacientes com a doença de Fabry. Pergunta: A intervenção por alfa-agalsidase e/ou beta-agalsidase é mais eficaz e segura que o manejo para o tratamento de sintomas ou paliativo aos desfechos clínicos esperados para a doença de Fabry? Métodos: Estudo de revisão sistemática rápida. A base consultada foi a Medline/Pubmed por meio de estratégias de buscas predefinidas. Foi feita avaliação da qualidade metodológica das revisões sistemáticas com a ferramenta AMSTAR-2 (Assessing the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews version 2). Resultados: Foram selecionadas 3 revisões sistemáticas, que atendiam aos critérios de inclusão. Conclusão: A intervenção com alfa-agalsidase e/ou beta-agalsidase promove redução para acúmulo de globotriaosilceramida; no entanto a redução é dependente do período de intervenção e concentração do fármaco, assim como o tecido avaliado e o tempo de sinais clínicos da doença. Há evidências de melhora na função renal, dor, desconfortos gastrointestinais e qualidade de vida. É importante considerar a heterogeneidade para as diferentes características dos grupos afetados, como idade, sexo e estágio da doença. No entanto, a compreensão consistente da relação tratamento e os desfechos são afetados pela baixa frequência de pessoas atingidas, e isso diminui o poder para inferências entre os diferentes estudos, reportando para as limitações da geração de protocolos de intervenção mais robustos e assertivos. Portanto, há necessidade de se seguir com novas avaliações, sobretudo para os estudos clínicos aleatorizados

Technology: Alphagalsity and/or beta-agalsidase compared to palliative care and symptomatic treatment associated with target organs in Fabry disease. Indication: Management and intervention to clinical outcomes in patients with Fabry disease. Question: Is alfagalsidase and/or beta-agalsidase intervention more effective and safer than management to treat symptoms or palliate expected clinical outcomes for Fabry disease? Methods: Rapid systematic review. Medline/Pubmed was consulted using predefined search strategies. The methodological quality of systematic reviews was assessed using the AMSTAR-2 (Assessing the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews version 2) tool. Results: Three systematic reviews were selected that met the inclusion criteria. Conclusion: Intervention with alfagalsidase and/or beta-agalsidase promotes a reduction in the accumulation of globotriaosylceramide; however, the reduction is dependent on the period of intervention and concentration of the drug, as well as the evaluated tissue and the time of clinical signs of the disease. There is evidence for improvements in kidney function, pain, gastrointestinal discomfort and quality of life. It is important to consider heterogeneity for different characteristics of affected groups, such as age, sex and disease stage; however, the consistent understanding of the relationship between treatment and outcomes is affected by the low frequency of people affected, and this reduces the power for inferences between different studies, referring to the limitations of generating more robust and assertive intervention protocols. There is therefore a need to continue with new assessments, especially for randomized clinical studies

Major cardiovascular adverse events in Fabry disease patients receiving agalsidase alfa / Eventos cardiovasculares mayores en pacientes con enfermedad de Fabry tratados con agalsidasa alfa

Abstract Cardiovascular mortality (CVM) has become the major contributor to overall Fabry disease (FD) mortality in the enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) era. Our objectives were to describe causes and potential predictors of mortality in FD adult patients in Argentina, and to assess risk of major adverse cardio vascular events (MACE) in the ERT era. We retrospectively studied 93 consecutive patients treated with alpha-galactosidase A (median follow up: 9.5 years from start of ERT). Mean age at ERT starting was 35±16.3 years. Prevalence of cardiomyopathy and renal disease reached 47% and 41%, respectively. Eleven subjects (11.8%, 95%CI: 5-18%) died during follow up (1.24/100 patient-years). Mean overall survival was 71 years (95%CI: 66-75 years). Seven cases were considered as CVM; main causes were sudden death and stroke. Risk of MACE was 14% (95%CI: 6.9-21.1%; 1.47 events/100 patient-years from start of ERT). All but 2 subjects had at least one comorbid cardiovascular risk factor; however, 86% of patients remained free of MACE during follow-up. CVM remained low and our study was underpowered for detection of predictors of mortality, but it is worth noting that age at diagnosis and ERT starting, left ventricular mass index and renal disease trended to correlate with CVM. Prevalence of hypertension, diabetes and dyslipidemia were lower in FD patients when compared to population level data. As in the Argentinean general population, CVM was the leading cause of mortality among this cohort of consecutive FD patients treated with agalsidase alfa.

Resumen La mortalidad cardiovascular (MCV) se ha convertido en el principal contribuyente a la mortalidad general por enfermedad de Fabry (EF) en la era de la terapia de reemplazo enzimático (TRE). Nuestros objetivos fueron describir las causas y posibles predictores de mortalidad en pacientes adultos con EF en la Argentina, y evaluar el riesgo de eventos cardiovasculares mayores (MACE) en la actual era de TRE. Se estudiaron 93 pacientes consecutivos tratados con agalsidasa-alfa por una mediana de 9.5 años tras iniciar TRE. La edad al inicio de TRE fue 35 ± 16.3 años. La prevalencia de cardiomiopatía y enfermedad renal alcanzó 47% y 41%, respectivamente. Once sujetos (11.8%; IC95%: 5-18%) murieron durante el seguimiento (1.24/100 pacientes/año). La supervivencia global fue 71 años (IC95%: 66-75 años). Siete casos fueron considerados como MCV; las principales causas fueron muerte súbita e ictus. El riesgo de MACE fue 14% (IC95%: 6.9-21.1%; 1.47 eventos/100 pacientes/año desde la ERT). Todos menos 2 sujetos tenían al menos un factor de riesgo cardiovascular, pero el 86% permaneció libre de MACE. Los eventos de MCV fueron escasos. El estudio tuvo reducido poder estadístico para detectar predictores de mortalidad, pero la edad al diagnóstico y al iniciar la TRE, índice de masa ventricular izquierda y enfermedad renal tendieron a correlacionarse con MCV. La prevalencia de hipertensión, diabetes y dislipidemia fue menor en comparación con la población general. Como ocurre con la población general en Argentina, los eventos cardiovasculares fueron la principal causa de muerte en esta cohorte de pacientes consecutivos con EF tratados con agalsidasa-alfa.

Switch from agalsidase beta to agalsidase alfa in the enzyme replacement therapy of patients with fabry disease in Latin America

There are currently two available enzyme replacement therapies for Fabry disease and little information regarding efficacy and safety of switching therapies. Between 2009 and 2012 there was a worldwide shortage of agalsidase beta and patients on that enzyme were switched to agalsidase alfa. This retrospective observational study assessed a 2-year period of efficacy and safety in a population of Fabry patients, in Argentina (30 patients) and Venezuela (3 patients), who switched therapies from algasidase beta to agalsidase alfa. Thirty-three patients completed 24-months follow-up after the switch (age 32.4 ± 2.0, range 10.0-55.9 years; male: female 23:10). Measures of renal function such as estimated glomerular filtration rate remained almost unchanged in 31 patients without end stage renal disease over the 2 years after switching and urine protein excretion continued stable. Cardiac functional parameters: left ventricular mass index, interventricular septum, left ventricular posterior wall showed no significant change from baseline in the 33 patients. Quality of life, pain and disease severity scores were mostly unchanged after 24-months and agalsidase alfa was generally well tolerated. Our findings showed there is no significant change in the efficacy measured through the renal or cardiac function, quality of life, pain, disease severity scoring and safety for at least 2 years after switching from agalsidase beta to agalsidase alfa.

Actualmente hay disponibles dos terapias de reemplazo enzimático en enfermedad de Fabry y existe poca información sobre la eficacia y seguridad del cambio de una a la otra. Entre 2009 y 2012 hubo falta a nivel mundial de agalsidasa beta y los pacientes tratados hasta entonces con esa enzima iniciaron tratamiento con agalsidasa alfa. El presente estudio retrospectivo, observacional evaluó la eficacia y seguridad a 2 años en pacientes con enfermedad de Fabry en Argentina (30 pacientes) y Venezuela (3 pacientes), que cambiaron su tratamiento de agalsidasa beta a agalsidasa alfa. Treinta y tres pacientes completaron 24 meses de seguimiento post-cambio (edad 32.4 ± 2.0; rango 10.0-55.9; hombre: mujer 23:10). La función renal, medida con la tasa de filtrado glomerular, se mantuvo sin cambios en 31 pacientes sin enfermedad renal terminal durante 2 años post-cambio. La secreción de proteína en orina continuó estable. Los parámetros de función cardíaca -índice de masa ventricular izquierda, septum interventricular, espesor de la pared posterior ventricular- no mostraron cambios significativos post-cambio de terapia en los 33 pacientes. La calidad de vida, el dolor y la gravedad de la enfermedad se mantuvieron mayormente estables luego de 24 meses, y la agalsidasa alfa fue generalmente bien tolerada. Nuestros resultados muestran que no hay cambios significativos en la eficacia medida por la función renal y cardíaca, en la seguridad y en los valores de la calidad de vida, el dolor o la gravedad de la enfermedad durante al menos 2 años luego del cambio de agalsidasa beta a agalsidasa alfa.

Enzyme Replacement Therapy for Fabry Disease

Abstract Fabry disease is a rare X-linked disease caused by the deficiency of α-galactosidase that leads to the accumulation of abnormal glycolipid. Untreated patients develop potentially lethal complications by age 30 to 50 years. Enzyme replacement therapy is the current standard of therapy for Fabry disease. Two formulations of recombinant human α-galactosidase A (agalsidase) are available in most markets: agalsidase-α and agalsidase-β, allowing a choice of therapy. However, the US Food and Drug Administration rejected the application for commercialization of agalsidase-α. The main difference between the 2 enzymes is the dose. The label dose for agalsidase-α is 0.2 mg/kg/2 weeks, while the dose for agalsidase-β is 1.0 mg/kg/2 weeks. Recent evidence suggests a dose-dependent effect of enzyme replacement therapy and agalsidase-β is 1.0 mg/kg/2 weeks, which has been shown to reduce the occurrence of hard end points (severe renal and cardiac events, stroke, and death). In addition, patients with Fabry disease who have developed tissue injury should receive coadjuvant tissue protective therapy, together with enzyme replacement therapy, to limit nonspecific progression of the tissue injury. It is likely that in the near future, additional oral drugs become available to treat Fabry disease, such as chaperones or substrate reduction therapy.

A 15-Year Perspective of the Fabry Outcome Survey

Abstract The Fabry Outcome Survey (FOS) is an international long-term observational registry sponsored by Shire for patients diagnosed with Fabry disease who are receiving or are candidates for therapy with agalsidase alfa (agalα). Established in 2001, FOS provides long-term data on agalα safety/efficacy and collects data on the natural history of Fabry disease, with the aim of improving clinical management. The FOS publications have helped establish prognostic and severity scores, defined the incidence of specific disease variants and implications for clinical management, described clinical manifestations in special populations, confirmed the high prevalence of cardiac morbidity, and demonstrated correlations between ocular changes and Fabry disease severity. These FOS data represent a rich resource with utility not only for description of natural history/therapeutic effects but also for exploratory hypothesis testing and generation of tools for diagnosis/management, with the potential to improve future patient outcomes.

Terapia de reemplazo enzimático en la Enfermedad de Fabry: la dosis es importante / Enzyme replacement therapy in Fabry Disease: the importance of dose

La enfermedad de Fabry es una enfermedad rara ligada al X consecuencia de la deficiencia de α-galactosidasa A lisosomal, lo que genera un depósito excesivo de glicoesfingolípidos, predominantemente globotriaosilceramida (Gl3) y mortalidad de causa renal cardíaca y neurológica. El tratamiento actual consiste en la terapia de reemplazo enzimático, lo que intenta reemplazar por vía intravenosa la enzima deficiente. Existen en el mercado europeo y latinoamericano dos formulaciones de agalsidasa: agalsidasa alfa y agalsidasa beta, lo que permite al médico elegir el tratamiento. Sin embargo, la Food and Drug Administration en Estados Unidos rechazó aprobar la agalsidasa alfa. La diferencia fundamental entre agalsidasa alfa y agalsidasa beta es la dosis autorizada: 0,2 mg/kg y 1 mg/kg cada dos semanas respectivamente. Durante años esta diferencia tan grande de dosis sorprendió a los clínicos. Sin embargo varios estudios recientes sugieren que hay un efecto dosis-respuesta y que para algunos pacientes la dosis de 0,2 mg/kg cada dos semanas puede ser insuficiente. Sin embargo, no existen herramientas que permitan predecir que pacientes van a necesitar una dosis más alta para detener o enlentecer la progresión de la enfermedad. En esta revisión resumimos el estado actual del conocimiento sobre el impacto Tratamiento en la enfermedad de Fabry de las diferentes dosis y su eficacia en tratamiento de la enfermedad de Fabry.

Fabry disease is a rare X-linked inherited disorder due to deficient or absent lysosomal α-galactosidase A activity, resulting in an excessive glycosphingolipid deposit, mainly globotriaosylceramide (gl3) and mortality due renal, cardiac and neurological cause. Current treatment available is enzyme replacement therapy, where the deficient enzyme is substituted. In Latinamerica and Europe two different formulations of agalsidase (alfa and beta) are available. Food and Drug Administration in United States did not approve agalsidasa Alfa. The main difference among these formulations is the licensed dose: 0.2 mg/kg every other week for Alfa and 1 mg/kg every other week for Beta. Recent studies suggest a dose-dependent response, making 0.2 mg/kg every other week not sufficient in some patients. However there are no tools to predict which patients need a higher dose for preventing or decreasing the disease progression. This review, summarize the current knowledge about the impact of different dose and its efficacy in Fabry disease.

Enfermedad de Fabry: la importancia de la terapia de reemplazo enzimático (TRE): tratar rápida y eficazmente / Fabry Disease: the importance of the, enzyme replacement therapy (TRE): treating quickly and efficiently

La enfermedad de Fabry en un trastorno lisosomal por ausencia o deficiencia de la enzima Alfa galactosidasa A que genera un acúmulo patológico de glicoesfingolípidos principalmente en células endoteliales, musculares lisas de vasos sanguíneos y podocitos entre otras. La terapia de reemplazo enzimático es la única chance de tratamiento específico a la fecha. El creciente conocimiento de los mecanismos fisiopatológicos ha llevado a cambiar el manejo de la enfermedad y por sobretodo el momento de inicio del tratamiento. Actualmente el inicio en edades más tempranas parece ser una forma de evitar y en algunos casos revertir algunos de los signos y síntomas de la enfermedad de Fabry.

Fabry Disease is a lysosomal disorder due to the absence or deficiency of the Alpha galactosidase A enzyme that causes a pathological ac cumulation of glycosphingolipids mainly in the REVISIÓN endothelial cells, vascular smooth muscle cells and podocytes among others. Enzyme replacement therapy is the only option for a specific treatment at present. Increasing knowledge of the physiopathological mechanisms has changed the management of the disease and above all, when treatment should begin. At present, beginning treatment at an early age seems to be a way of preventing and in some cases reverting some of the signs and symptoms of Fabry disease.

Home infusion program for Fabry disease: experience with agalsidase alfa in Argentina / Programa de infusión domiciliaria para la enfermedad de Fabry: experiencia con agalsidasa alfa en la Argentina

Fabry disease is an X-linked lysosomal storage disorder caused by inherited deficiency of the enzyme α-galactosidase A. Enzyme replacement treatment using agalsidase alfa significantly reduces pain, improves cardiac function and quality of life, and slows renal deterioration. Nevertheless, it is a life-long treatment which requires regular intravenous infusions and entails a great burden for patients. Our objective was to evaluate retrospectively the safety and tolerability of the home infusion of agalsidase alfa in patients with Fabry disease in Argentina. We evaluated all the patients with Fabry disease who received home infusion with agalsidase alfa 0.2 mg/kg between January 2005 and June 2011. The program included 87 patients; 51 males (mean age: 30 years) and 36 females (mean age: 34 years). A total of 5229 infusions (mean: 59 per patient; range: 1-150) were administered. A total of 5 adverse reactions were seen in 5 patients (5.7% of patients and 0.9% of the total number of infusions). All were mild in severity and resolved by reducing the rate of infusion and by using antihistaminics. All these 5 patients were positive for IgG antibodies, but none of them presented IgE antibodies and none suffered an anaphylactic shock. In our group 18 patients were switched from agalsidase beta to agalsidase alfa without complications. Home infusion with agalsidase alfa is safe, well tolerated and is associated to high compliance.

La enfermedad de Fabry es un trastorno de almacenamiento lisosomal hereditario ligado al cromosoma X ocasionado por el déficit de la enzima alfa galactosidasa A. La terapia de reemplazo enzimático utilizando agalsidasa alfa reduce significativamente el dolor, mejora la función cardíaca y la calidad de vida y enlentece el deterioro renal. Sin embargo, es un tratamiento de por vida que requiere infusiones intravenosas regulares y supone una gran carga para los pacientes. Nuestro objetivo fue evaluar retrospectivamente la tolerabilidad y la seguridad del procedimiento de infusión domiciliaria de agalsidasa alfa en pacientes con enfermedad de Fabry en Argentina. Evaluamos a todos los pacientes con enfermedad de Fabry que recibieron infusiones domiciliarias de 0.2 mg/kg de agalsidasa alfa entre enero del 2005 y junio del 2011. El programa incluyó 87 pacientes; 51 hombres (edad media: 30 años) y 36 mujeres (edad media: 34 años). Se administraron un total de 5229 infusiones (media: 59 por paciente; rango: 1-50). Se observaron un total de 5 reacciones adversas en 5 pacientes (5.7% de los pacientes y 0.9 % del número total de infusiones). Todas fueron de gravedad leve y se resolvieron reduciendo la velocidad de la infusión o usando antihistamínicos. Los 5 pacientes fueron positivos para anticuerpos IgG, pero ninguno presentó anticuerpos IgE o sufrió un shock anafiláctico. En nuestro grupo, 18 pacientes fueron cambiados de agalsidasa beta a agalsidasa alfa sin complicaciones. La infusión domiciliaria de agalsidasa alfa es segura, bien tolerada y logra una alta adherencia al tratamiento.

Early Diagnosis of Fabry Disease in a Patient with Toe Tip Pain

Fabry disease is an X-linked lysosomal disease caused by deficiency of alpha-galactosidase, in which early diagnosis may be missed due to the wide variety of clinical symptoms presenting during disease progression. A 13 year-old boy visited our pain clinic complaining of pricking and burning pain in the toe tips of both feet. Continuous epidural infusion for pain management was performed because of oral analgesics ineffectiveness. The patient underwent alpha-galactosidase A (GLA) enzyme analysis based on the clinical impression of Fabry disease from pain with a peripheral neuropathic component and history of anhidrosis. He was diagnosed with Fabry disease after confirming mutation of the GLA gene through a screening test of GLA activity. Enzyme replacement therapy was initiated and pain was tolerated with oral analgesics.

Fabry disease: diagnosis of a rare disorder / Doença de fabry: diagnóstico de uma doença rara

Fabry disease (FD) is an X-linked inborn error of glycosphingolipid metabolism due to thedeficiency of α-galactosidase A. The progressive accumulation of globotriaosylceramide (Gb3),particularly in the vascular endothelium, leads to renal, cardiac, and cerebrovascularmanifestations and early death. Clinical manifestations include the onset of pain and paresthesiasin extremities, angiokeratoma and hypohidrosis during childhood or adolescence. Proteinuriaand lymphedema occur with increasing age. Severe renal impairment leads to hypertension anduremia. Death usually occurs due to renal failure or cardiac or cerebrovascular disease. Diseasepresentation may be subtle, and its signs and symptoms are often discounted as malingering orare mistakenly attributed to other disorders, such as rheumatic fever, neurosis, multiple sclerosis,lupus, or petechiae.We present a 46-year-old man who since adolescence has suffered from painfulacroparesthesia, disseminated skin angiokeratomas, hypohidrosis and heat intolerance. He wassubmitted to a thorough investigation with different specialists, but never reached a diagnosis.He started hemodialysis 3 years ago and at the moment is in standby for kidney transplantation.He was enrolled in a Brazilian FD screening and a reduced serum activity of α-galactosidase A(0.0027 nmol/h/mL – reference value 4-22) confirmed the diagnosis of FD.He has angiokeratoma at the bottom area, his echocardiogram demonstrated left ventricularhypertrophy and the family history is very rich, as the patient has 15 siblings.

This case represents a very common story for FD patients. They usually spend most oftheir lives trying to find someone who could understand or explain their suffering. These resultsindicate that FD may be much more common among male dialysis patients than previouslyrecognized. Subsequently, FD should be considered in every patient with unexplained renaldisease, especially when cardiac or cerebral complications suggest an underlying multisystemicdisorder. Early diagnosis of FD is important because it allows family studies to identify otheraffected relatives for genetic counseling and therapeutic intervention.

A doença de Fabry (DF) é um erro inato do metabolismo dos glicoesfingolipídeos devido àdeficiência da α-galactosidase A. O acúmulo progressivo de globotriaosilceramida (Gb3), particularmente no endotélio vascular, leva a manifestações renais, cardíacas e cerebrovascularese morte precoce. As manifestações clínicas incluem o início, durante a infância ou adolescência,de episódios de dor e parestesias nas extremidades, angioqueratomas e hipohidrose. Com aidade, podem aparecer proteinúria e linfedema. Insuficiência renal grave leva à hipertensão euremia. O óbito ocorre devido à insuficiência renal ou doença cardíaca ou cerebrovascular. Aapresentação da doença pode ser sutil, e seus sinais e sintomas são erroneamente atribuídosa outras doenças, como febre reumática, neurose, esclerose múltipla, lúpus ou petéquias.Relatamos o caso de um paciente masculino com 46 anos que, desde a adolescência,sofre de acroparestesia, angioqueratomas disseminados, hipohidrose e intolerância ao calor.

Ele foi submetido a extensa investigação com diferentes especialistas, mas nunca chegou a umdiagnóstico. Iniciou hemodiálise há 3 anos e, no momento, está na lista de espera para transplantede rim. Participou de um programa brasileiro de triagem para DF, e uma atividade reduzida de α-galactosidase A (0,0027 nmol/h/mL – valor de referência 4-22) confirmou o diagnóstico de DF.O paciente apresenta angioqueratomas na área do calção, seu ecocardiograma demonstrahipertrofia ventricular esquerda e sua história familiar é rica, pois ele tem 15 irmãos.Este caso representa uma história muito comum entre pacientes com DF. Eles geralmentepassam a maior parte de suas vidas tentando encontrar alguém que compreenda ou expliqueseu sofrimento. Estes resultados indicam que a DF pode ser muito mais comum entre homensque realizam hemodiálise do que antes previsto. Subseqüentemente, a DF deve ser consideradaem todo paciente com doença renal sem causa aparente, principalmente quando complicaçõescardíacas ou cerebrovasculares sugerirem uma doença multissistêmica. O diagnóstico precoceda DF é importante, pois permite estudo familiar para identificar parentes afetados paraaconselhamento genético e intervenção terapêutica.