Construction of an evaluation index system for research-oriented disciplines in medical institutions / 中华医学科研管理杂志

Objective:To construct an index system for evaluating the development of research-oriented disciplines in medical institutions, and to provide a basis for guiding the superior disciplines towards international high-level disciplines.Methods:Through literature research and expert discussions, the basic framework of the research-oriented disciplines development evaluation system was established. The final version of the index system was determined using the Delphi method and expert interviews, and the weights of each index were established using the hierarchical analysis method.Results:After consultation, the framework of 5 first-class indexes, 16 second-class indexes, and 51 third-class indexes was finally constructed for the evaluation system of research-oriented discipline development, and the weights of indexes at different classes were calculated. The high-frequency terms " research mechanism construction" , " research team construction" and " representative research results" extracted from the expert interviews echoed the results of the weighting calculation.Conclusions:The evaluation system for research-oriented disciplines constructed in this study is relatively reasonable, scientific, reliable, and operable. The construction of the index system adapts to the characteristics of the development of research-oriented disciplines, with guiding significance for enhancing the development of research-oriented disciplines.

Construction of a risk prediction and evaluation system for postoperative incisional infection after spinal surgery / 中华创伤骨科杂志

Objective:To construct a risk prediction and assessment system for incisional infection after spinal surgery.Methods:Based on the failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA), risk factors and assessment indicators of postoperative incisional infection in spinal surgery were sorted out through literature search followed by expert consultation using the Delphi expert consultation method. After three-level assessment indicators were selected according to their importance and expert opinions and assigned by different scores, a risk prediction and evaluation system was constructed for postoperative incisional infection after spinal surgery.Results:The 2 rounds of expert consultation questionnaire resulted in an effective response rate of 100%. The degree of expert consultation authority was 0.85, showing high reliability; the Kendall coordination coefficients of expert consultation ranged from 0.525 to 0.686, showing good coordination ( P<0.05). The three-level assessment indicators consisted of 3 primary, 18 secondary and 54 tertiary ones. After statistical analyses of the important risk indicators selected which consisted of 6 preoperative evaluation ones and 18 postoperative evaluation ones, 6 preoperative and 12 postoperative predictive indicators were obtained. The values of risk priority number (RPN) were calculated for high, medium and low risks for postoperative incisional infection using a semi-quantitative method. Conclusion:A self-designed system has been constructed for risk prediction and assessment of incisional infection after spinal surgery based on expert consultation and FMEA method.

Construction of competency index of nurses in public health emergencies based on iceberg model / 中国实用护理杂志

Objective:To construct competency index of nurses in public health emergencies based on iceberg mode.Methods:Based on the analysis of the work of public emergencies in the past five years, the deficiencies were summarized, and the competence index of nursing staff in public health emergencies was preliminarily formulated with the Iceberg Model as the theoretical framework and the literature review. The Delphi expert consultation method was used to select 15 experts from 7 Class Ⅲ Grade A general hospitals and Class Ⅲ Grade A specialized hospitals in Jiangsu Province who met the standards of admission and discharge from January to June 2020 for two rounds of consultation, and the competency index was finally formed.Results:The competency index of nursing staff in public health emergencies included 5 first-level indicators and 27 second-level indicators. The authority coefficient of experts on the first-level index and second-level index were 0.84 and 0.81. The coordination coefficients were 0.68 and 0.72, respectively. The differences were statistically significant( χ2 values were 73.22, 95.30, P<0.01). Conclusions:The competency index of nurses in public health emergencies in this study is highly reliable and scientific, and can provide reference for the reserve, training and assessment of nurses in public health emergencies.

Application of Delphi method to building a visual literacy evaluation system for pupils / 预防医学

Objective @#To construct a visual literacy evaluation system for pupils by Delphi expert consultation method（Delphi method）. @*Methods @#The visual literacy evaluation indices for pupils were preliminarily constructed through literature review. Twenty experts in relevant fields were invited and the visual literacy evaluation system for pupils was established by two rounds of expert consultation based on Delphi method. @*Results @# The average age of 20 experts was（48.35±5.79）years old,of which 19 experts had senior titles,and 17 experts had master's degree or above. The enthusiasm of the experts in two rounds of consulting was both 100.00%. The average authoritative coefficient（W）of the experts was 0.88. For the first consulting round,the W of importance scores from experts was 0.91（P<0.01）;the W of operability scores from experts was 0.89（P<0.01）,which indicated satisfactory consistency. For the second consulting round,the W of importance scores from experts was 0.79（P<0.01）;the W of operability scores from experts was 0.77（P<0.01）,which also indicated satisfactory consistency. The finalized visual literacy evaluation system for pupils after two rounds of expert consultation included three primary indices（eye care knowledge literacy,eye care attitude literacy and eye care behavior literacy）,six secondary indices（basic knowledge,eye care behavior,eye care attitude,eye care willingness,bad eye care behavior and eye protection）and 40 tertiary indices（≥5.0 of eyesight among normal people,always wearing glasses due to poor eyesight and so on）. @*Conclusion @#The experts who participated in the construction of visual literacy evaluation system for pupils had strong professional representativeness,high enthusiasm,high authority and good coordination,and the evaluation system can be used for evaluating pupils visual literacy.

Research about evaluation index system of home treatment quality for chronic wound patients with negative pressure therapy / 中国实用护理杂志

Objective To study the evaluation index system for home treatment quality of negative pressure therapy. Methods Two-round Delphi expert consultation method was used to consult 20 experts, so as to initially establishthe quality evaluation index system. Results An evaluation index system for home treatment quality of negative pressure therapy was formed, including 4 items of primary indexes, 13 items of secondary indexes and 30 items of tertiary indexes. Conclusions The evaluation index system for home treatment quality of negative pressure therapy in patients with chronic wounds has a clear hierarchy, the reliability of the research results is high, which provides a standardized reference for the objective evaluation of the work and the continuous improvement of nursing quality.