RESUMO
Objective:To explore the effects of goals-activity-motor enrichment(GAME) therapy on the function of gross and fine motion in infants at high risk of cerebral palsy.Methods:Prospective study.A total of 116 children at high risk of cerebral palsy who met the inclusion criteria and were admitted to the Rehabilitation Department of Qingdao Women and Children′s Hospital from November 2017 to November 2019 were selected in a randomized, single-blind, controlled trial, and randomly divided into control group (58 cases) and observation group (58 cases) according to the random number table method.The two groups were then divided into mild group, moderate group and severe group according to the gross motor quotient(GMQ) of Peabody Motor Development Scale-2 (PDMS-2). During treatment, 4 cases of shedding occurred in the control group and 8 cases in the observation group, respectively.Finally, 54 cases were included in the control group and 50 cases in the observation group.The control group was given regular early intervention rehabilitation, whereas the observation group was given GAME treatment.The Gross Motor Function Measure-88 (GMFM-88), the GMQ of PDMS-2 and the fine motor quotient (FMQ) of PDMS-2 were used to assess the motor function of children before intervention and after 12 weeks of treatment.The Chi- square test or Fisher′ s exact test was used to compare gender-specific data, while the t-test was used to compare age-specific data and rehabilitation evaluation indices. Results:The GMFM-88 scores, GMQ, and FMQ of children in both groups improved significantly after treatment, and the difference was statistically significant [control group GMFM-88: (63.52±10.06) scores vs.(47.02±8.19) scores, t=-19.770, GMQ: 83.02±15.52 vs.73.56±14.72, t=-18.180, FMQ: 81.19±14.88 vs.71.22±13.92, t=-18.413, all P<0.05; observation group GMFM-88: (68.06±10.82) scores vs.(46.16±8.73) scores, t=-32.856, GMQ: 89.98±18.10 vs.72.94±13.84, t=-17.089, FMQ: 88.34±18.08 vs.72.26±13.74, t=-15.370, all P<0.05], and the GMFM-88, GMQ, and FMQ scores of the observation group were significantly higher than those of the control group after treatment, with statistically significant differences(GMFM-88: t=-2.176, GMQ: t=-2.111, FMQ: t=-2.210, all P<0.05). In the observation group, the added value score and quotient of mild group and moderate group were significantly increased compared with that of severe group, and the differences were statistically significant [GMFM-88 added value: the mild group (24.11±3.36) scores and moderate group (22.91±3.46) scores were compared with the severe group (15.70±4.08) scores, t=5.881, 5.164, all P<0.05, GMQ added value: the mild group (19.61±6.83) and moderate group (18.27±6.61) were compared with the severe group (9.80±4.29), t=4.098, 3.915, all P<0.05, the added value of FMQ: mild group (18.72±7.11) and moderate group (17.36±6.10) were compared with severe group (8.50±5.82), t=3.873, 3.863, all P<0.05]. Conclusions:GAME treatment is more effective than early rehabilitation training at improving gross and fine motor function in infants at high risk of cerebral palsy.Its benefits on mild and moderate infants at high risk of cerebral palsy are superior.
RESUMO
Objective To compare the efficacy of goal_activity_motor environment( xAmE)therapy and neurodevelopmental therapy(NDT)in the early intervention of high_risk infants with cerebral palsy(IHRCP),and to provide scientific evidence_based medical basis for early intervention of IHRCP. Methods A total of 62 cases of IHRCP were enrolled in the Children＇s Neurological Rehabilitation Center of the First Affiliated Hospital of Anhui medi_cal University from June 2017 to December 2018. They were divided into xAmE group(32 cases)and NDT group(30 cases)according to the admission order. xross motor Function Scale(xmFm),Fine motor Function measure(FmFm) and xesell Development Scale(xDS)were used for detection and comparison. The differences among the gross motor, the fine motor score and the developmental quotient( D匝)between two groups before treatment,9 months after treat_ment and 12 months after treatment,and the normalization rate and the incidence of cerebral palsy between the two groups at 12 months of age were compared. Results ( 1 )motor function was as follows:at 9 months[ xAmE:(32. 63 ± 15. 83)scores,(30. 03 ± 15. 88)scores],[NDT:(33. 37 ± 15. 61)scores,(29. 67 ± 12. 54)scores]and at 12 months[xAmE:(40. 56 ± 15. 79)scores,(36. 31 ± 14. 98)scores],[NDT:(40. 47 ± 15. 50)scores,(36. 73 ± 14. 58)scores]after treatment,and xmFm and FmFm scores in xAmE and NDT groups were significantly higher than those before treatment[xAmE:(27. 56 ± 14. 24)scores,(21. 75 ± 11. 35)scores],[ NDT:(26. 93 ± 14. 96)scores, (21. 30 ± 10. 67)scores],and the differences were significant( all P<0. 01),but there was no significant difference between the 2 groups(all P> 0. 05).(2)D匝 had no significant difference in D匝 between xAmE group(63. 59 ± 10. 83)and NDT group(61. 59 ± 7. 96)before treatment(P>0. 05). The total D匝 at 9 months,12 months,the total D匝 of xAmE group(73. 67 ± 12. 00,81. 59 ± 13. 03)was significantly higher than that of NDT group(66. 05 ± 9. 54, 75. 17 ± 1. 92)(all P<0. 05). Among them,the improvement of xAmE in speech(79. 84 ± 16. 56,83. 19 ± 17. 05)at 9 months and 12 months,and adaptive ability(78. 63 ± 16. 37,85. 78 ± 13. 60)were significantly higher than that of NDT group(71. 63 ± 13. 36,72. 53 ± 12. 77),(68. 20 ± 14. 97,77. 43 ± 12. 10),and the differences were significant( all P<0. 05).(3)Prognosis was as follows:at 12 months after treatment,25 cases in xAmE group and 23 cases in NDT group developed into normal children,there was no significant difference in the normalization rate between the 2 groups( P>0. 05);the incidence of cerebral palsy was present in 6 cases in xAmE group and 5 cases in NDT group,and there was no significant difference between the 2 groups(P>0. 05). Conclusions xAmE therapy and NDT had significant effects on both gross and fine exercise of IHRCP,and the efficacy of the two methods is similar. Both xAmE therapy and NDT can equally promote IHRCP development into normal infants and reduce the incidence of cerebral palsy.
RESUMO
Objective@#To compare the efficacy of goal-activity-motor environment (GAME) therapy and neurodevelopmental therapy (NDT) in the early intervention of high-risk infants with cerebral palsy (IHRCP), and to provide scientific evidence-based medical basis for early intervention of IHRCP.@*Methods@#A total of 62 cases of IHRCP were enrolled in the Children′s Neurological Rehabilitation Center of the First Affiliated Hospital of Anhui Medi-cal University from June 2017 to December 2018.They were divided into GAME group (32 cases) and NDT group (30 cases) according to the admission order.Gross Motor Function Scale (GMFM), Fine Motor Function Measure (FMFM) and Gesell Development Scale (GDS) were used for detection and comparison.The differences among the gross motor, the fine motor score and the developmental quotient (DQ) between two groups before treatment, 9 months after treatment and 12 months after treatment, and the normalization rate and the incidence of cerebral palsy between the two groups at 12 months of age were compared.@*Results@#(1) Motor function was as follows: at 9 months[GAME: (32.63±15.83) scores, (30.03±15.88) scores], [NDT: (33.37±15.61) scores, (29.67±12.54) scores] and at 12 months[GAME: (40.56±15.79) scores, (36.31±14.98) scores], [NDT: (40.47±15.50) scores, (36.73±14.58) scores] after treatment, and GMFM and FMFM scores in GAME and NDT groups were significantly higher than those before treatment[GAME: (27.56±14.24) scores, (21.75±11.35) scores], [NDT: (26.93±14.96) scores, (21.30±10.67) scores], and the differences were significant (all P<0.01), but there was no significant difference between the 2 groups (all P> 0.05). (2) DQ had no significant difference in DQ between GAME group(63.59±10.83) and NDT group (61.59±7.96) before treatment (P>0.05). The total DQ at 9 months, 12 months, the total DQ of GAME group (73.67±12.00, 81.59±13.03) was significantly higher than that of NDT group (66.05±9.54, 75.17±1.92) (all P<0.05). Among them, the improvement of GAME in speech (79.84±16.56, 83.19±17.05) at 9 months and 12 months, and adaptive ability(78.63±16.37, 85.78±13.60) were significantly higher than that of NDT group(71.63±13.36, 72.53±12.77), (68.20±14.97, 77.43±12.10), and the differences were significant (all P<0.05). (3) Prognosis was as follows: at 12 months after treatment, 25 cases in GAME group and 23 cases in NDT group developed into normal children, there was no significant difference in the normalization rate between the 2 groups (P>0.05); the incidence of cerebral palsy was present in 6 cases in GAME group and 5 cases in NDT group, and there was no significant difference between the 2 groups (P>0.05).@*Conclusions@#GAME therapy and NDT had significant effects on both gross and fine exercise of IHRCP, and the efficacy of the two methods is similar.Both GAME therapy and NDT can equally promote IHRCP development into normal infants and reduce the incidence of cerebral palsy.
RESUMO
Cerebral palsy or high risk of cerebral palsy can be diagnosed accurately and early using the clinical signs and symptoms of cerebral palsy,involves neuroimaging,standardized neurological and standardized motor assess-ments before 6 months' corrected age. When the clinical diagnosis is suspected but cannot be made with certainty,re-commend using the interim clinical diagnosis of high risk of cerebral palsy until a diagnosis is confirmed,because infant with cerebral palsy require and benefit from different early interventions. Before 5 months' corrected age,the most pre-dictive tools for detecting risk are term - age magnetic resonance imaging(MRI),the Prechtl Qualitative Assessment of General Movements(GMs),and the Hammersmith Infant Neurological Examination(HINE). After 5 months' corrected age,the most predictive tools for detecting risk are MRI,HINE and the Developmental Assessment of Young Children. Early diagnosis and early intervention can optimize infant motor and cognitive plasticity,prevent secondary complica-tions. Cerebral palsy - specific early intervention maximizes neuroplasticity and minimizes deleterious modifications to muscle and bone growth and development. Early interventions included Goals - Activity - Motor Enrichment,neurode-velopmental treatment(Bobath,Vojta),Conductive Education and Environmental enrichment. Infants with of cerebral palsy who receive early CIMT have better hand function,and infants with any type and topography of cerebral palsy who receive GAME have better motor and cognitive skills than those who receive usual care.
RESUMO
El objetivo fue determinar la evidencia existente acerca de la efectividad de intervenciones tempranas sobre el desarrollo motor de niños con alto riesgo de desarrollar una parálisis cerebral. Método: Se realizó una búsqueda literaria en bases de datos y revistas relevantes para el tema (CINAHL, The Cochrane Library, EMBASE, PEDro y PubMed). Los criterios de selección consideran a recién nacidos muy prematuros (<32 semanas de gestación) y/o con extremo bajo peso al nacer (<1.500 g), recién nacidos con encefalopatías neonatales y recién nacidos (prematuros o de término) que presentan resonancia magnética anormal y/o ultrasonido craneal anormal y/o la evaluación de movimientos generales alterada. Las calidades metodológicas de los estudios se evalúan con la escala PEDro y el nivel de evidencia con la clasificación del centro basado en la Evidencia de Oxford. Resultados: Se analizaron 9 estudios, comprendiendo 687 lactantes menores de 18 meses, quienes reflejan una gran variedad respecto al tipo y frecuencia de intervenciones y las herramientas de evaluación utilizadas. Los componentes terapéuticos asociados a efectos beneficiosos son: la participación de los padres en las intervenciones y la estimulación a la producción del movimiento por parte del bebé durante las actividades de la vida diaria. Discusión: Se evidencia que programas de intervención temprana que incluyen a cuidadores para promover el desarrollo motor y cognitivo, parecen tener más efectos beneficiosos en el largo plazo. Se requiere más investigación sobre este tema, y mejoras metodológicas para resultados más consistentes y así establecer el nivel de eficacia de los programas de intervención temprana.
The goal was to determine the evidence on the effectiveness of early interventions on motor development in children at high risk of developing cerebral palsy. Method: A literature search was conducted in databases and journals relevant to the topic (CINAHL, The Cochrane Library, EMBASE, PEDro and PubMed). Selection criteria considered very preterm infants (<32 weeks gestation) and/or with extremely low birth weight (<1,500 g), infants with neonatal encephalopathy and newborns (preterm or term) that have abnormal MRI and/ or abnormal cranial ultrasound and / or evaluation of altered general movements. Methodological quality of the studies was assessed with the PEDro scale and level of evidence with the classification based center for Evidence of Oxford scale. Results: 9 studies were analyzed, comprising 687 infants under 18 months, which reflect a variety regarding the type and frequency of interventions and evaluation tools used. The therapeutic benefits associated components are: the involvement of parents in interventions and stimulation to production of movement by the baby during activities of daily living. Discussion: It is evident, that early intervention programs which include caregivers to promote motor and cognitive development seem to have more beneficial effects in the long run. More research on this subject, and methodological improvements for more consistent results is required, to establish the level of effectiveness of early intervention programs.