Is Distal Locking Constantly Necessary When Intertrochanteric Femur Fracture Is Stably Fixed in the Distal Area with Intramedullary Hip Nail? / 대한정형외과학회잡지

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to investigate the constant necessity of distal locking when intertrochanteric fracture was treated with an intramedullary hip nail. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From April 2010 to June 2013, 47 stable intertrochanteric fractures (AO/OTA 31-A1) were treated with second generation intramedullary hip nailing. They were followed-up for more than 12 months. In the first group of 18 cases distal locking was used, and in the second group of 29 cases, distal locking was not used. We compared the radiologic and clinical results of the two groups. RESULTS: Comparison of the two groups of patients showed no difference in terms of radiological and functional results. Postoperative thigh pain developed in eight cases (17%). A statistically difference was observed between isthmic diameter and used nail diameter (Fisher exact test, p=0.01) for postoperative thigh pain. In logistic regression analysis, the difference between isthmic diameter and used nail diameter was the most statistically significant factor in development of postoperative thigh pain (p=0.04, odd ratio=27.75). CONCLUSION: Our results suggested that the second generation intramedullary hip nail may be successfully implanted without distal interlocking in 31-A1 intertrochanteric femur fracture when the reduction status was satisfactory and stable fixation of the distal area was estimated by less than 3 mm difference between isthmic diameter and used nail diameter.

The Stability Score of the Intramedullary Nailed Intertrochanteric Fractures: Stability of Nailed Fracture and Postoperative Patient Mobilization

BACKGROUND: Intertrochanteric fractures of the femur are the most common type of fracture, and are an increasing occurrence due to the aging of the population. The objectives of our study are to predict the fate of intertrochanteric fractures treated with intramedullary hip nails by assessing the postoperative fracture stability utilizing the newly developed scoring system, and to help rehabilitate these patients. METHODS: Eighty-two patients with intertrochanteric fractures that were treated with intramedullary hip nails between December, 2004 and January, 2011 were subjected to this study. The patients who could be followed for a minimum of one year postoperatively were enrolled. The immediate postoperative conditions were determined by radiograms: reduction status (3 parameters/4 points: contact accuracy of posteromedial cortex, severity of angulation, and distraction), fixation status (3 parameters/3 points: tip-apex distance, location of tip of the lag screw, entry point of the intramedullary nail), and fracture type (1 parameter/1 point: stable or unstable type by the Kyle's classification). Postoperative reduction loss and fixation failure were checked by radiograms taken at a minimum 3 months postoperative. RESULTS: Reduction loss and fixation failure were observed in 14 consecutive patients (17%). The fixation failure rate was 100% (2 patients) in score 1, 60% (3 out of the 5 patients) in score 2, 39% (3 out of the 8 patients) in score 3, and 50% (4 out of the 8 patients) in score 4 groups. There were fixation failures only in 1 out of 13 patients with score 5, and in 1 out of 18 patients with score 6. There was no fixation failure in 17 patients with score 7 and 11 patients with score 8. CONCLUSIONS: Maintenance of the fracture reduction by the stable fixation in the patient scores over 5 could be predicted by the postoperative radiograms.