The Appropriateness of the Items of Korean Ages and Stages Questionnaires (K-ASQ) Developmental Screening Test in Korean Infants and Children / 대한소아신경학회지

PURPOSE: Since National Health Screening Program for Infants and Children in Korea started from November, 2007, the need to design a new tool that can timely identify infants and chlildren with possible delayed development has been emphasized. The developmental screening devices currently used in Korea are mostly adapted from foreign tests and could be considered inappropriate for children growing in a different cultural background. Therefore, we assessed the appropriateness of Korean-Ages and Stages Questionnaires (K-ASQ) items in Korean infants and children, as a preliminary study to develop a new developmental screening test tool. METHODS: Data on K-ASQ tests that were performed in multicenters as a National Health Screening Program in Korea were analyzed to measure (1) the item difficulty and norm relevance (2) the goodness of fit for factor structure (3) the sensitivity of item for developmental evaluation. A total of 1,696 subjects, 877 boys (51.7%) and 819 girls (48.3%) were studied and with about 50 boys and 50 girls for each age of months, the sample was relatively evenly distributed. RESULTS: Analysis of K-ASQ data showed that (1) The subjects scored higher when compared to the K-ASQ's original criteria. (2) The suitability of confirmative factor structure was insufficient, especially problem solving [x2=41.063, P<0.01, CFI (Comparative Fit Index)=0.929, TLI (Turker-Lewis index)=0.834, RMSEA (Root Mean Square Error Approximation)=0.152] and personal-social domains (x2=55.208, P<0.01, CFI=0.817, TLI=0.573, RMSEA=0.182). (3) Some questions did not show significant difference in the sensitivity of item for developmental evaluation among monthly age groups. CONCLUSION: According to the analysis of previous K-ASQ data, the appropriateness of the questionnaires is good in general, but some questions of problem-solving and personal social domains are not appropriate. We suggested the development of a new developmental screening test tool, which is suitable for Korean infants and children.

The Validity of Korean Ages and Stages Questionnaires (K-ASQ) in Korean Infants and Children / 대한소아신경학회지

PURPOSE: As a preliminary study on the development of a new developmental screening tool, this study examined the validity of the Korean Ages and Stages Questionnaires (K-ASQ). METHODS: The clinical sample included a total of 218 Infants and children at 30, 36, 60 months of age, who were diagnosed with developmental disorders. Age- and sex-matched normal controls were selected from a national large-scale K-ASQ database. Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were calculated in different age and diagnosis groups, and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was performed as well. In addition, concurrent validity was analyzed for the clinical sample by comparing the K-ASQ with other reference scales. RESULTS: The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the K-ASQ were above fair (0.82-0.96) overall, however they varied depending on age and diagnosis groups. Specifically, the sensitivity at 60 months was relatively low (0.65). Especially, the discrimination sensitivity for the language delay group was poor at 60 months (0.42). ROC analysis showed that the overall discrimination capacity was above fair in all 5 domains [area under the curve (AUC): 0.74-0.98]. However, there were some domains and age groups with relatively poor discrimination capacity. In terms of concurrent validity, the correlations between the K-ASQ domains and reference scale subscales were statistically significant overall, but weak in some domains. CONCLUSION: The overall discrimination capacity and concurrent validity of the K-ASQ were above fair, but there were some domains, age, and diagnosis groups in which the K-ASQ was not successful in identifying potentially developmentally challenged children. These findings suggested the need for the development of a new developmental screening test tool, which is suitable for Korean infants & children.

A Comparison of the Korean-Ages and Stages Questionnaires and Denver Developmental Delay Screening Test

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate concurrent validity between the Korean-Ages and Stages Questionnaires (K-ASQ) and the Denver Developmental Screening Test II (DDST II), and to evaluate the validity of the K-ASQ as a screening tool for detecting developmental delay of Korean children. METHOD: A retrospective chart review was done to examine concurrent validity of the screening potentials for developmental delay between the K-ASQ and the DDST II (n=226). We examined validity of the K-ASQ compared with Capute scale (n=141) and Alberta Infant Motor Scale (AIMS) (n=69) as a gold standard of developmental delay. Correlation analysis was used to determine the strength of the associations between tests. RESULTS: A fair to good strength relationship (k=0.442, p<0.05) was found between the K-ASQ and the DDST II. The test characteristics of the K-ASQ were sensitivity 76.3-90.2%, specificity 62.5-76.5%, positive likelihood ratio (PLR) 2.41-3.40, and negative likelihood ratio (NLR) 0.16-0.32. CONCLUSION: Evidence of concurrent validity of the K-ASQ with DDST II was found. K-ASQ can be used for screening of developmental delay.