Is Alcohol Swabbing Sufficient to Clean Otoscopes in Hospitals? / 대한이비인후과학회지

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: An otoscope is a basic instrument used by otorhinolaryngologists. An inappropriately sterilized otoscope has been reported to be a possible bacterial vector for infection. In this regard, we decided to investigate contaminated otoscopes for possible bacterial contamination and evaluate the efficacy of the otoscope disinfection methods. MATERIALS AND METHOD: We randomly drew 22 otoscope cones from university hospitals and 10 from private hospitals. Cones were divided into three groups accordingly to their sterilization methods: group 1 was wiped with 70% isopropyl alcohol, group 2 was soaked for 20 min in 70% isopropyl alcohol, and group 3 was soaked in CIDEX solution. The samples were cultured twice, first before the disinfection process and then after the disinfection process. Otoscopes were cleaned for a week by employing these techniques. RESULTS: Most of the pre-sterilized otoscopes (20/22) were obtained from the hospitals which demonstrated contamination with microorganisms. Staphylococcus was the most common bacteria found (16/22). After a week of cleansing, no bacteria were seen in group 1 (0%, 0/8), whereas group 2 (14.3%, 1/7), and group 3 (28.6%, 2/7) still showed remaining microorganisms. The three methods were significantly effective on sterilizing microorganisms. CONCLUSION: An otoscope can be a vector for spreading infection. We found that disinfection by alcohol-swabbing alone is sufficient for sterilizing otoscope cones. Clinically, this information may be useful to otorhinolaryngologists. However, further studies are required to establish the most appropriate disinfection protocol to prevent infection from microorganisms.

Current situation of otoscopy in general practice in China / 中华全科医师杂志

Objective To investigate current situation of otoscope use by practitioners at community health-care service facilities in Hainan and Shenzhen and explore its importance and feasibility of spread of its use in community health-care service facilities in China.Methods Group discussion, telephone personal interview, otoscope market survey and literature research all were used among 112 practitioners at 67 community health-care service facilities in Hainan, 47 practitioners at 23 community health-care service facilities in Shenzhen, Guangdong, and 11 representatives involved in general practice training from 11 districts.Results In Hainan, only one community health-care service facility ( 1.5% ) was equipped with otoscopes and only one practitioner (0.9% ) could use it.In Shenzhen, two community health-care service facilities (8.7%) were equipped with it, but which had never be used.All the practitioners at community health-care service facilities surveyed have not been trained for its use, so most practitioners there did not have basic skills to use otoscope.Conclusions Otoscope is not equipped at most community health-care service facilities in Hainan and Shenzhen, and it is little used there even equipped with it.Otoscopy should be used as an adequate and feasible technique at community health-care service and be spread among general practitioners in China.

Clinical Value of a Video Otoscope in Diagnosis of Acute Otitis Media

PURPOSE: Acute otitis media(AOM) has variable clinical symptoms and is diagnosed with injection, bulging, and decreased mobility of tympanic membrane. There are many misdiagnoses because children who are suspected of having acute otitis media are uncooperative during diagnosis with an otoscope. An inaccurate diagnosis of acute otitis media when using an otoscope results in wasted of medical resourses and increased tolerance to antibiotics. Therefore, this study was conducted to evaluate the usefulness of a video otoscope as a tool of diagnosis of acute otitis media. METHODS: Among 416 patients who visited Pundang Jesaeng Hospital Emergency Medical Center with a complaint of otalgia from 1 October 2002 to 30 September 2003, we studied 51 patients who were followed up at the otorhinolaryngology depatment. Emergency Medicine residents recorded the findings for tympanic membrane by using an otoscope and by using a video otoscope. we used kappastatistics to carry out a prospective study in which the accuracy of diagnosis of AOM was analyzed by comparison with the confirmed diagnosis by an otolaryngologic specialist. RESULTS: In this study, the number of males was 24 (47%) and that of females was 27 (53%). Of the 51 Patients, 22 (43%) presented with rhinorrhea, 15 (29%) with cough, 11 (22%) with sputum, 10 (20%) with fever, 8 (16%) with a sore throat, 7 (14%) with otorrhea, 4 (8%) with hearing difficulty, 3 (6%) with irritability, 3 (6%) with tinnitus, 3 (6%) with vomiting and 2 (4%) with dizziness. A comparison of the diagnostic accuracy of AOM between otolaryngologic specialist and residents in emergency department, when was undertaken by using kappa statistics, and a diagnostic agreement of 65% (kappa=0.28) for the otoscope, and 76 %( kappa=0.45) for the video otoscope. The diagnostic sensitivity of acute otitis media by video otoscope was 75%, and specificity was 82%. CONCLUSION: When the tympanic membrane of the patient suspected of a having AOM is examined in an emergency medical center, video otoscopy should be a useful diagnostic tool for AOM owing to its high diagnostic accuracy.