Resultados funcionales de la aplicación de toxina botulínica tipo A contra antiinflamatorios orales en la rehabilitación de síndrome de hombro doloroso por lesión del mango de los rotadores / Functional results of type a botulinum toxin versus oral antiinflammatory agents in the rehabilitation of painful shoulder syndrome caused by rotator cuff lesion

Las enfermedades del mango de los rotadores se caracterizan por signos inespecíficos, síntomas y alteraciones de la anatomía, su etiología es multifactorial y pueden abarcar desde tendinitis hasta rupturas masivas de espesor completo del tendón del manguito de los rotadores, las cuales comprometen la biomecánica normal del hombro afectado. Normalmente suceden en mayores de 40 años; sin embargo, el asociado a trauma depende del mecanismo de lesión y no tiene relación directa con la edad de aparición de los síntomas. Se han descrito factores vasculares en el daño al tendón del manguito de los rotadores, en patologías que afectan a la microcirculación; sin embargo, estudios recientes no han demostrado que el tendón bajo observación directa presente datos de hipovascularidad. La toxina botulínica tipo A realiza su acción mediante bloqueo de la liberación de acetilcolina en la placa neuromuscular; en las articulaciones provoca liberación de la tensión capsular así como la disminución de factores pro inflamatorios tales como la interleucina-1; aunque existen pocos artículos sobre su utilidad intraarticular, en los grupos musculares y tendinosos, además de tener un efecto miorrelajante existen diversas publicaciones que apoyan su utilidad en el manejo del dolor y su utilidad en la rehabilitación de este grupo de pacientes; en dosis bajas, ha sido ampliamente utilizada. Material y métodos: Se trata de un estudio prospectivo, experimental y longitudinal en el cual se realizó seguimiento a 24 pacientes con diagnóstico de síndrome de hombro doloroso demostrado por pruebas clínicas y de gabinete debido a lesiones del mango de los rotadores, sin criterios de reparación quirúrgica inmediata, o ya reparados, a los cuales a 12 pacientes se les aplicará toxina botulínica tipo A en el espacio subacromial de forma peri-tendón del tendón conjunto del manguito de los rotadores, así como en puntos de dolor y contractura muscular en hombro, con una dosis total de 200 UI de toxina botulínica tipo A, mientras que al grupo control, de 12 pacientes, se le administraron antiinflamatorios vía oral por seis semanas, tipo Cox 2, Celecoxib 100 mg cápsulas una cada 12 horas; a los dos grupos se les sometió a un programa de rehabilitación ya establecido, el cual fue supervisado cada dos semanas y hasta las seis semanas de evolución; se realizaron valoraciones subjetivas y objetivas valorando la presencia de dolor, el nivel funcional y la movilidad posible mediante la escala de valoración funcional de hombro de Constant y la escala visual análoga. Resultados: Grupo de Celecoxib Promedio de escala de Constant inicial fue de 60 puntos, el inmediato a la primera dosis se mantuvo en 60 puntos, a las dos semanas de tratamiento con Celecoxib se encontró un puntaje de Constant promedio de 66 puntos y a las seis semanas el promedio fue de 70.33 puntos, siendo el valor de la p > 0.005. Grupo de toxina botulínica 200 UI máximo en hombro afectado, 50 UI subacromial y 150 en puntos de dolor además de asociarlo a programa de ejercicios de rehabilitación supervisados en consultorio. El promedio de la escala de Constant inicial fue de 58 puntos, el inmediato a la primera dosis se elevó a 70.83 puntos, a las dos semanas posteriores a infiltración y seguimiento de ejercicios en consultorio fue de puntaje Constant promedio de 77.16 puntos y a las seis semanas el promedio fue de 78.5 puntos, siendo el valor de la p < 0.005 (p = 0.00045). En cuanto a la escala visual análoga se observó que en el grupo de Celecoxib existió una disminución de dicha escala a las seis semanas con una p < 0.005.

Rotator cuff conditions are characterized by unspecific signs, as well as anatomic alterations and symptoms. They have a multifactorial etiology and may include everything from tendinitis to massive, full thickness tears of the rotator cuff tendon that compromise the normal biomechanics of the involved shoulder. They usually occur in people over 40 years of age but lesions resulting from trauma may vary according to the mechanism of injury and are not directly related with the age at onset of symptoms. Vascular factors have been described as related with rotator cuff tendon damage in conditions affecting the microcirculation. However, recent studies have not proven that the tendon under direct observation shows hypovascularity. Type A botulinum toxin acts by blocking the release of acetylcholine in the neuromuscular plate; in the joints it releases capsular tension and reduces proinflammatory factors such as interleukin-1 (IL-1). There are only a few papers on its intraarticular benefit; in muscle and tendon groups it not only has a muscle relaxant effect, but several publications support its utility for pain management. It has been widely used in the rehabilitation of this group of patients at low doses. Material and methods: Prospective, investigational and longitudinal study involving the follow-up of 24 patients with a diagnosis of painful shoulder syndrome proven clinically and with imaging tests, and caused by rotator cuff lesions. The patients either did not meet the criteria for immediate surgical repair or had already undergone such a repair. Type A botulinum toxin was applied to 12 patients in the subacromial space around the rotator cuff conjoint tendon, as well as in the painful spots and in the muscle contracture in the shoulder. The total dose of Type A botulinum toxin was 200 IU. The control group, also composed of 12 patients, was given a COX-2 oral antiinflammatory agent for 6 weeks (Celecoxib, 100 mg BID). Both groups followed a pre-established rehabilitation program for a total of 6 weeks and were supervised every 2 weeks. Subjective and objective assessments were made including pain, performance level and possible mobility, using Constant's functional shoulder assessment and the visual analog scale (VAS). Results: Celecoxib group: Mean initial Constant scale score was 60; after the first dose it remained unchanged. After 2 weeks of treatment with Celecoxib the mean Constant score was 66; by 6 weeks it was 70.33, with p > 0.005. The botulinum toxin group received a maximum dose of 200 IU in the affected shoulder, 50 IU were administered subacromially and 150 in the painful spots. This treatment was combined with rehabilitation exercises supervised at the doctor's office. The mean initial Constant scale score was 58; immediately after the first dose it went up to 70.83. Two weeks after the injection and the supervision of rehabilitation exercises at the office, the mean Constant scale score was 77.16; at six weeks it was 78.5, with p < 0.005 (p = 0.00045). The VAS in the Celecoxib group decreased at six weeks with p < 0.005.

Rotator Cuff Repair Without Bony Trough / 대한정형외과학회잡지

Surgical repair has been widely accepted for full thickness tear of the rotator cuff. In traditional method, hony trough on the greater tuberosity of the humerus has heen used for tendon to hone suture. Recently, there have been some suggestions that hony trough would not he essential for repairing the rotator cuff. Purpose of this study was to investigate the clinical result of rotator cuff repair without bony trough. We evaIuated the clinical results of 23 operative repairs of the full-thickness tear of the rotator cuff, using modified ASES scoring system, at an average of l4 months postoperatively. For these cases, all the tendon to hone sutures were done without makin bony trough. There were 3 cases of small tear. 14 case of medium tear, 1 case of large tear and 5 cases of massive tear. Mini-open repairs with arthroscopic acromioplaslies were used for 9 cases with small or medium sized tear. Open acromioplasties and repairs were done for 14 cases. Nine cases were rated excellent (39%), and twelve cases showed good results (52%). Two cases showed fair results (9%). Averagc increase of score was 40 (ranee, 18 to 78). There were no complications or deteriorations of function. No patient needed additional surgery. Repair without hony trough is more simple and easier than the traditional method making bony trough. There would he possibility of less tension to the tendons and preserving more natural course of tendons. The authors believe that this method provides larger contact surface between the tendon and hone. The repairing method without hony trough is considered to he a safe and efficient method for the full thickness tear of the rotator cuff. This technique can he useful not only for ordinary open repair, but also for mini-open repair.