Comparison of Cone-Beam Computed Tomography and Intraoral Radiography in Detection of Recurrent Caries under Composite Restorations

ABSTRACT

Abstract Secondary caries is the most common cause of dental restoration failures. This study aimed to compare the diagnostic accuracy of conventional and digital intraoral radiography and cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) for detection of recurrent caries around composite restorations. mesio-occluso-distal (MOD) cavities were prepared using bur on 45 extracted sound human molar teeth. The teeth were divided into 3 groups. In the control group, cavities were restored with composite resin after etching and bonding (n=15). In Group 2, 500-μm thick wax was placed over the buccal, lingual and gingival walls and the cavities were restored with composite resin. Group 3 specimens were subjected to pH cycling and artificial caries were created on the buccal, lingual and gingival walls. The cavities were restored with composite. Conventional and digital photo-stimulable phosphor (PSP; Optime) radiographs and two CBCTs images (NewTom 3G and Cranex 3D) were obtained from them. Presence or absence of caries in the cavity walls was assessed on these images. Data were analyzed using Kappa statistic. The diagnostic accuracy of CBCT was significantly higher than that of digital and conventional intraoral radiography (p<0.05). The accuracy was 0.83, 0.78, 0.55 and 0.49 for CBCT Cranex 3D, CBCT NewTom 3G, conventional and digital intraoral radiography, respectively. CBCT has a higher diagnostic accuracy than digital and conventional intraoral radiography for detection of secondary caries around composite restorations.

RESUMO

Resumo A causa mais comum de falha das cáries dentais são as cáries secundárias. Este estudo objetivou comparar a acurácia diagnóstica da radiografia intraoral digital e convencional com a tomografia computadorizada de feixe cônico (TCFC) para a detecção de cáries recorrentes em torno restaurações com compósitos. Cavidades mésio-oclusais-distais (MOD) foram produzidas com broca em 45 molares hígidos humanos extraídos. Os dentes foram dividdos em 3 grupos. No grupo controle, as cavidades foram restauradas com compósito após condicionamento e colagem (n=15). No Grupo 2, foi aplicada uma camada de cera de 500 µm de espessura sobre as paredes bucais, linguais e gengivais; as cavidades foram então restauradas com resina composta. No Grupos 3, as amostras foram submetidas a ciclagem de pH e criação artificial de cáries sobre as paredes bucais, linguais e gengivais; as cavidades foram então restauradas com resina composta. Radiografias convencional e digital com fósforo foto-estimulável (PSP, Optima) e duas imagens em TCFC (NewTom 3G e Granex 3D) foram obtidas de cada amostra. A presença ou não de cáries foi avaliada nestas imagens. Os dados foram analisados por estatística Kappa. A acurácia diagnóstica da TCFC foi significantemente (p<0,05) maior que na radiografia intraoral convencional e digital. A acurácia foi de 0,83, 0,78, 0,55 e 0,49, respectivamente para TCFC Cranex 3D, TCFC NewTom 3G, a radiografia intraoral convencional e digital. A TCFC tem maior acurácia diagnóstica que a radiografia intraoral convencional e digital para detecção de cáries secundárias em torno de restaurações com compósito.