Comparison of three different ceruminolytic agents [soda-bicarbonate, almond oil and normal saline] with respect to their efficacy

ABSTRACT

To compare the efficacy of three ceruminolytic agents for cerumen impaction with respect to its ease of complete removal via suctioning or probe. A comparative prospective study. This study was conducted carried out at the outpatient department of ENT, Abbasi Shaheed hospital, Karachi from November 2010 to March 2011. A comparative prospective study of 75 adult patients with cerumen impaction in either or both of the ears carried out at the outpatient department of ENT, Abbasi Shaheed hospital, Karachi. The study was done after taking the consent of the patients. All the adult patients of age 18 years or greater, of either sex with the symptoms in the ear[s] because of cerumen which was hard/dry and difficult to remove were included in the study. Those of age less than 18 years and not having any symptomatology because of the cerumen or with soft wax which was easy to clear were not included in the study. The study was carried out from November 2010 till March 2011. the patients with problematic, difficult to remove cerumen or cerumen impaction with symptoms were divided in to three groups Groups A, Group B and Group c; all having equal number of cases that is 25 each. In group A they were given soda-bicarbonate in glycerin based ear drops; in group B almond oil and group C the normal saline for instillation in ear. The doses and timings for drops were equal in all the group and it was 3 drops in the affected ear every 6-hourly for 1-week. They were councilled that the dose should not be missed and they have to lay down for 5 minutes so that drops are absorbed and does not come out of the ear. After one week they were called in the OPD, was compared with completeness of removal of impacted cerumen for the three groups. Ease and completeness of cerumen removal was 80% in group A, followed by 60% for group C and 20% for group B. We found soda-glycerin to be superior to almond oil and normal saline as ceruminolytic agent