Comparison of manual vaccum aspiration and sharp curettage in the treatment of first trimester abortions

ABSTRACT

To compare the safety and efficacy of manual vaccum aspiration and sharp curettage in the treatment of first trimester abortions. Randomized controlled trial. Department of gynecology, Social Security Hospital Shahdra Lahore in collaboration with Family Health Hospital Johar Town Lahore, from May 2007 to May 20102. Six hundred women admitted with the diagnosis of first trimester less than or equal to 12 weeks abortions were randomly assigned, 300 to manual vacuum aspiration [MVA] and 300 to traditional sharp curettage. Diagnosis of abortion was confirmed by last menstrual period, physical examination and ultrasonography. In total of 600 patients, 300 randomly assigned to MVA and another 300 patients assigned to sharp curettage managemet were having mean age of 31.8 and 33 yrs respectively. mean parity was in both groups, mean gestational age 8.9 and 8.2 weeks, mean duration of procedure was 6.4 and 5.8 minutes, duration of hospital stay was 4 and 40 hrs, missed abortion in 47% and 43% patients, incomplete abortion in 53% and 57% patients, cervical dilatation was needed in 1% against 53%, 10% against 8% experienced mild pain in both groups, no patient of incomplete evacuation against 0.6%, uterine perforation in none against 0.3%, excessive bleeding was experienced by 0.3% against 0.6% patients in both groups, and patient satisfaction rate was 99% against 99.4% in the two groups respectively. in the management of first trimester pregnancy loss, MVA offers a quick solution to the problem with reduced hospital stay and lower rate of complications