Post dural puncture headache after spinal anaesthesia for caesarean section: a comparison of 25G Quincke, 27G Quincke and 27G whitacre spinal needles

ABSTRACT

To compare the frequency and severity of post dural puncture headache in obstetric patients using 25G Quincke, 27G Quincke and 27G Whitacre spinal needles. Comparative, randomized, double-blind, interventional study. Liaquat University Hospital Hyderabad from October 2005 to December 2006. 480 ASA I-II full term pregnant women, 18 to 45 years of age, scheduled for elective Caesarean section, under spinal anaesthesia, were randomized into three groups Group I [25G Quincke spinal needle n=168], Group II [27G Quincke spinal needle n=160] and Group III [27G Whitacre spinal needle n=152]. Spinal anaesthesia was performed with 1.5-2.0 ml 0.75% hyperbaric bupivacaine using 25G Quincke spinal needle [Group I], 27G Quincke spinal needle [Group II] and 27G Whitacre spinal needle [Group III] at L3-4 inter-vertebral space. Each patient was assessed daily for four consecutive days following Caesarean section. Frequency and severity and of postdural puncture headache [PDPH] were recorded. Data were analyzed using SPSS-11. Frequency of PDPH following the use of 25G Quincke [Group I], 27G Quincke [Group II] and 27G Whitacre [Group III] spinal needles was 8.3% [14/168], 3.8% [6/160] and 2.0% [3/152] respectively. In Group I, PDPH was mild in 5 patients, moderate in 7 patients and severe in 2 patients. In Group II, it was mild in 2, moderate in 3 and severe in 1 patient. In group III, it was mild in 2 and moderate in 1 patient. Severe PDPH did not occur in Group III. Most of the patients with PDPH developed it on first and second postoperative day. When using a 27G Whitacre spinal needle, the frequency and severity of PDPH was significantly lower than when a 25G Quincke or 27G Quincke needle was used