Clinical comparison of 12 mg ropivacaine and 8 mg bupivacaine, both with 20 microg fentanyl, in spinal anaesthesia for major orthopaedic surgery in geriatric patients

ABSTRACT

The aim of this study was to compare the haemodynamic and anaesthetic effects of 12 mg ropivacaine and 8 mg bupivacaine, both with 20 microg fentanyl, in spinal anaesthesia for major orthopaedic surgery in geriatric patients. Sixty American Society of Anesthesiologists [ASA] II-III patients scheduled for hip arthroplasty were randomly assigned to receive an intrathecal injection of either 12 mg ropivacaine with 20 microg fentanyl [group R, aged 70 +/- 7 years, range 67-89] or 8 mg hyperbaric bupivacaine with 20 microg fentanyl [group B, aged 69 +/- 6 years, range 66-92]. Motor and sensory block, haemodynamics and side effects were recorded. Mean levels of sensory block were similar, but the onset time of sensory block in group B [2.52 +/- 0.69 min] was shorter than that in group R [3.17-0.72 min]; the difference was statistically significant [p < 0.01], and the number of patients who had motor Bromage scale 3 in group B [24] was greater than in group R [16]. The difference was also statistically significant [p<0.05]. Systolic and diastolic arterial pressures [SAP, DAP] and heart rate [HR] decreased after the block in both groups. SAP [after the 60th and 120th mm of block], DAP [all measurement times], and HR [after the 20th, 25th and 30th min of block] were lower in group B than in group R. The data showed that 12 mg of ropivacaine and 8 mg of bupivacaine with 20 microg fentanyl in spinal anaesthesia can provide sufficient motor and sensory block for major orthopaedic surgery in geriatric patients. However, ropivacaine caused less motor block and haemodynamic side effects than bupivacaine during the procedure