¿Violencia episódica o terrorismo íntimo? Una propuesta exploratoria para clasificar la violencia contra la mujer en las relaciones de pareja / Episodic violence or intimate terrorism? An exploratory proposal to classify violence against women in the context of intimate couple relationships
Salud ment
;
31(6): 469-478, nov.-dic. 2008. graf, tab
Article
in Spanish
|
LILACS-Express
| LILACS
| ID: lil-632709
ABSTRACT
Introduction The concern of this paper comes from a reflection on the phenomenon of violence against women in the context of intimate couple relationships. Even though studies dealing with the issue tend to focus on the presence of physical violence, it should not be forgotten that in the same relationships several types of emotional and sometimes sexual violence may co-exist. Violent men intentionally aim to create a threatening climate against women. To do so, they resort to devaluations, insults, threats, maltreatment, shouting, contempt, intolerance, humiliations, jealousy and accusations. Nevertheless, women are often unaware of many of them given the social tolerance towards overall abuse and the lack of institutional alternatives. There are, however, some difficulties to operationalize these behaviours. It is particularly difficult to measure the characteristic pattern followed by these relationships as this may involve very subtle forms of violence. Likewise, results obtained in the physical and psychological dimensions are usually kept as separate areas or they are presented at best in a mixed form to show the prevalences from the different surveys carried out. This article is a theoretical and statistical exercise aimed at constructing a typology of male violence against women. Its starting point is a proposal posing that in heterosexual relationships two types of violence are present. The first one may be called episodic violence, where one or both members of the couple carry out some violent act without the desire to control or dominate the other partner. In the other one, defined as intimate terrorism, the man acts out with the clear purpose of exerting both a violent and non-violent control and dominion over the woman's actions, thoughts, and emotions. Although it is certainly arguable, it might be interesting to analyze this classification for it is risky to suppose that there are couple relationships where a symmetry in the use of violence exists both on the part of men and women -that is, that women are as violent as men. It is risky because it distorts violence's gender nature by presupposing that the same behaviour may be exerted with the same physical and symbolic strength and that it will have similar consequences. However, we think it is worth taking it into account as a starting point for this analysis. To do so, a database derived from a study conducted among a sample of women attending general medical consultation was used. The main analysis axis was the indicator of having experienced a physically violent behaviour on the part of the partner during the last year. This was related to five emotional violence dimensions which represent different modalities as to their intentionality and impact. The groups thus formed were analyzed considering some variables which were previously regarded as associated to this form of violence, including demographic features, and some other features related to household income participation and the distribution of household keeping chores in the women's families. Specific features regarding the violent relationship, such as the motives behind the physical violence episodes and the role played by alcohol abuse on the part of the male partner in these episodes, were also considered. Method A database derived from a transversal ex post facto study conducted with a 345-women sample attending first-time or subsequent medical attention in a first level institution was analyzed. A structured questionnaire made up of different areas was applied. The following areas were included in this study: 1. Socio-demographic variables from each woman, her male partner and her family. 2. A violence severity scale containing 22 different types of physically violent behaviours from men against women, and 36 emotional violence types. A previous analysis of the latter showed five conceptually congruous dimensions: Devaluation, Threatening behaviours, Intimidation, Hostility, and Abusive expectations. 3. Features of both the relationship and the violent episodes. 4. Alcohol abuse on the part of the partner. To construct the typology, women who had experienced at least one physical violence attack by their partners during the last twelve months were classified, regardless of the frequency and severity of such behaviour. With this sub-sample, a multidimensional escalation analysis was performed with the five emotional violence dimensions reported and these were considered as <RESUMEN
El presente trabajo es un ejercicio teórico y estadístico para construir una tipología de la violencia masculina hacia la mujer. Parte de una propuesta que plantea que en las relaciones heterosexuales ocurren dos tipos de violencia física. Uno de éstos puede denominarse violencia episódica, donde uno o ambos integrantes de la pareja realizan algún acto violento sin que esté presente el deseo de controlar o dominar al otro integrante. En el otro, definido como terrorismo íntimo, el hombre actúa con una clara intención de ejercer un control y dominio tanto violentos como no violentos sobre las conductas, pensamientos y emociones de la mujer. Los grupos construidos se analizan según algunas variables que previamente se ha considerado que se pueden asociar con esta forma de violencia, como las características demográficas, las características relacionadas con la participación económica y la distribución de las labores domésticas en las familias de las mujeres y las características específicas de la relación violenta, en particular el uso de alcohol por parte de la pareja. Método Se analizó una base de datos derivada de un estudio transversal y ex post facto realizado con una muestra de 345 mujeres que asistieron a atención médica de primera vez o subsecuente a una institución del primer nivel en el Distrito Federal. Para construir la tipología, se eligió a las mujeres que habían sufrido al menos una manifestación de violencia física por su pareja en los últimos 12 meses, y se realizó un análisis de escalamiento multidimensional a partir de cinco dimensiones de la violencia emocional. Con base en la clasificación de grupos, se realizaron análisis de varianza y de chi cuadrada con variables demográficas, y otras que la bibliografía ha reportado como relevantes. Resultados Un 30% de las mujeres había sufrido algún episodio de violencia física en el último año. Éstos se clasificaron de la siguiente manera: 1. con violencia física episódica, que incluye a aquellas que no reportaron amenazas, ni intimidación y devaluación (12.5% de la población total); 2. violencia física intimidatoria, que incluye mujeres que reportaron amenazas e intimidación y poca o ninguna devaluación (12.5% de la población total); y 3. terrorismo íntimo, referido a mujeres que sufrieron amenazas e intimidaciones muy frecuentes junto con una devaluación que va de <
Full text:
Available
Index:
LILACS (Americas)
Type of study:
Observational study
/
Prevalence study
/
Prognostic study
/
Qualitative research
Language:
Spanish
Journal:
Salud ment
Journal subject:
Psychiatry
Year:
2008
Type:
Article
/
Project document
Affiliation country:
Mexico
Institution/Affiliation country:
Instituto Nacional de Psiquiatría Ramón de la Fuente Muñíz/MX
Similar
MEDLINE
...
LILACS
LIS