Assessment of suitability & ease of performance of seven commercial assay systems for the detection of antibodies to HIV-1.

ABSTRACT

In this study, we have evaluated the suitability and ease of performance of seven HIV assays namely Vironostika anti-HIV Uni-Form; Vironostika HIV MIXT; Elavia MIXT; Genelavia MIXT; Serodia-HIV; Immunocomb Bi-spot; and Test pack HIV-1 and 2 Abbott, for use in Indian laboratories. A panel of 41 blind coded Western blot confirmed sera were used for this purpose. Rapid assays like Immunocomb Bi-Spot, Serodia HIV and Test pack HIV-1/HIV-2 Abbott were found to be more suitable and easy to perform as compared to the ELISAs. Sensitivity of all the assays was excellent (100%). Specificity of Serodia HIV, Immunocomb Bi-spot, Test pack HIV-1 and 2 Abbott and Elavia MIXT were excellent (100%), while that of Vironostika MIXT and Vironostika anti-HIV Uni-Form was poor. Positive predictive value of the assays ranged from 64.5 to 100 per cent. Negative predictive value of six of the assays was 100 per cent and that of Vironostika anti-HIV Uni-Form was very poor.