Comparison of the Operative Methods for Varicose Veins in the Lower Extremities

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: There are several new surgical techniques for varicose vein surgery. Transilluminated Powered Phlebectomy (TIPP) and Endovenous Laser Therapy (EVLT) are accepted as useful surgical procedures for varicose veins. However, these techniques have some associated problems such as complications, remnant varicosities and are relatively expensive. We compared some of the new techniques with conventional methods and introduce new technique called Transillumination assisted EVLT (T-EVLT). METHOD: We reviewed cases with primary varicose veins involving the lower extremity in 217 patients managed by TIPP, EVLT and T-EVLT in the department of Surgery, Presbyterian Medical Center, from January 2003 to January 2007. RESULT: The distribution of age was the fifth decade (38.4%), fourth (23.8%) and third (15.2%), in order frequency. The male to female ratio was 11.43. The TIPP procedure had the lowest frequency of remnant varicosities (6.0%) but the second highest complication rate (17.9%). The EVLT procedure had a relatively low complication rate (9.5%) and good cosmetic results but the longest operation time and the highest frequency of remnant varicosities (21.6%). The T-EVLT procedure had the shortest operation time and the lowest frequency of remnant varicosities (19.5%) compared to the EVLT. CONCLUSION: Each of the operation methods had risks and benefits. The EVLT procedure had good cosmetic results and was easy to learn. However, had a relatively long operation time and many remnant varicosities. These problems may be overcome by the T-EVLT.